NCAR logo

AMIP_CLM5_CAM5_CLUBB_1979-1984
and
AMIP_CLM45_CAM5_CLUBB_1979-1984

Set 9



TSA modified control Comparison
Model AMIP_CLM5_CAM5_CLUBB_1979-1984 AMIP_CLM45_CAM5_CLUBB_1979-1984 Summary
RMSE 2.65 2.62 +0.03
RMSE % Area 17.85 20.71 -2.86
ANN Bias 0.61 -0.03 +0.58
ANN Bias % Area 12.41 18.31 -5.90
DJF Bias 0.75 0.38 +0.37
DJF Bias % Area 7.02 6.71 +0.31
MAM Bias 0.53 -0.43 +0.10
MAM Bias % Area 12.13 13.47 -1.34
JJA Bias 0.53 -0.27 +0.26
JJA Bias % Area 15.86 13.73 +2.13
SON Bias 0.66 0.21 +0.45
SON Bias % Area 8.82 9.47 -0.65
% Area with r>0.9 85.12 84.83 +0.29


PREC modified control Comparison
Model AMIP_CLM5_CAM5_CLUBB_1979-1984 AMIP_CLM45_CAM5_CLUBB_1979-1984 Summary
RMSE 1.26 1.29 -0.03
RMSE % Area 5.72 5.30 +0.42
ANN Bias 0.15 0.23 -0.08
ANN Bias % Area 5.35 3.93 +1.42
DJF Bias 0.28 0.34 -0.06
DJF Bias % Area 2.65 2.06 +0.59
MAM Bias 0.17 0.33 -0.16
MAM Bias % Area 8.54 3.33 +5.21
JJA Bias -0.01 0.01 0.00
JJA Bias % Area 3.81 2.02 +1.79
SON Bias 0.17 0.23 -0.06
SON Bias % Area 3.33 2.63 +0.70
% Area with r>0.9 33.65 32.76 +0.89


ASA modified control Comparison
Model AMIP_CLM5_CAM5_CLUBB_1979-1984 AMIP_CLM45_CAM5_CLUBB_1979-1984 Summary
RMSE 4.78 4.72 +0.06
RMSE % Area 16.82 23.98 -7.16
ANN Bias -1.32 -0.59 +0.73
ANN Bias % Area 7.58 17.48 -9.90
DJF Bias 2.01 2.90 -0.89
DJF Bias % Area 4.50 16.05 -11.55
MAM Bias -0.53 0.52 +0.01
MAM Bias % Area 7.35 13.59 -6.24
JJA Bias -0.16 0.40 -0.24
JJA Bias % Area 8.75 10.14 -1.39
SON Bias -2.54 -2.00 +0.54
SON Bias % Area 6.85 12.02 -5.17
% Area with r>0.9 21.66 21.10 +0.56


LHEAT modified control Comparison
Model AMIP_CLM5_CAM5_CLUBB_1979-1984 AMIP_CLM45_CAM5_CLUBB_1979-1984 Summary
RMSE 13.65 16.78 -3.13
RMSE % Area 29.99 7.16 +22.83
ANN Bias 3.31 7.42 -4.11
ANN Bias % Area 28.02 10.77 +17.25
DJF Bias 4.80 8.83 -4.03
DJF Bias % Area 19.82 6.24 +13.58
MAM Bias 3.90 9.68 -5.78
MAM Bias % Area 26.08 9.77 +16.31
JJA Bias 2.31 4.86 -2.55
JJA Bias % Area 20.79 11.40 +9.39
SON Bias 2.23 6.11 -3.88
SON Bias % Area 18.20 10.23 +7.97
% Area with r>0.9 68.15 60.61 +7.54

FPSN modified control Comparison
Model AMIP_CLM5_CAM5_CLUBB_1979-1984 AMIP_CLM45_CAM5_CLUBB_1979-1984 Summary
RMSE 1.19 1.12 +0.07
RMSE % Area 0.09 0.48 -0.39
ANN Bias 0.53 0.48 +0.05
ANN Bias % Area 0.00 0.54 -0.54
DJF Bias 0.40 0.40 0.00
DJF Bias % Area 0.41 0.44 -0.03
MAM Bias 0.68 0.62 +0.06
MAM Bias % Area 0.00 0.05 -0.05
JJA Bias 0.79 0.67 +0.12
JJA Bias % Area 0.20 0.52 -0.32
SON Bias 0.24 0.23 +0.01
SON Bias % Area 0.57 1.26 -0.69
% Area with r>0.9 62.21 63.46 --1.25