ILAMB Benchmark Results

ILAMB 2.3

ILAMB Benchmark Results

ILAMB Benchmark Results

Mean State Scores

CLM4_CRUNCEP CLM4_GSWP3 CLM4SP_GSWP3 CLM4.5_CRUNCEP CLM4.5_GSWP3 CLM4.5SP_GSWP3 CLM5_CRUNCEP CLM5_GSWP3 CLM5SP_CRUNCEP CLM5SP_GSWP3
Biomass0.600.64~0.630.68~0.700.72~~
   GEOCARBON (27.8%)0.720.76~0.770.78~0.770.75~~
   Tropical (27.8%)0.480.58~0.510.62~0.680.75~~
   GlobalCarbon (22.2%)0.480.58~0.510.62~0.600.68~~
   NBCD2000 (11.1%)0.740.66~0.740.72~0.740.69~~
   USForest (11.1%)0.690.59~0.710.65~0.720.67~~
Burned Area0.390.39~0.520.53~0.570.56~~
   GFED4S (100.0%)0.390.39~0.520.53~0.570.56~~
Gross Primary Productivity0.560.580.620.610.610.650.620.610.660.66
   Fluxnet (37.5%)0.610.620.680.640.660.700.670.670.690.69
   GBAF (62.5%)0.530.550.580.590.590.620.590.580.640.64
Leaf Area Index0.380.420.700.390.430.630.460.510.630.63
   AVHRR (50.0%)0.400.440.610.410.450.630.490.530.630.63
   MODIS (50.0%)0.370.400.780.370.410.620.440.480.620.62
Global Net Ecosystem Carbon Balance0.520.63~0.690.63~0.840.87~~
   GCP (50.0%)0.530.55~0.590.61~0.800.77~~
   Hoffman (50.0%)0.510.70~0.790.65~0.880.97~~
Net Ecosystem Exchange0.500.49~0.530.53~0.560.55~~
   Fluxnet (69.2%)0.590.58~0.620.62~0.640.63~~
   GBAF (30.8%)0.290.27~0.310.31~0.390.37~~
Ecosystem Respiration0.520.55~0.570.60~0.600.61~~
   Fluxnet (60.0%)0.560.57~0.590.63~0.620.63~~
   GBAF (40.0%)0.470.51~0.540.57~0.570.58~~
Soil Carbon0.480.41~0.610.68~0.320.55~~
   HWSD (55.6%)0.600.51~0.570.68~0.330.51~~
   NCSCDV22 (44.4%)0.340.29~0.670.69~0.310.59~~
Ecosystem and Carbon Cycle Summary0.500.52~0.580.60~0.590.63~~
Evapotranspiration0.600.620.670.630.650.680.630.660.650.68
   GLEAM (50.0%)0.600.620.680.640.670.690.640.670.650.68
   MODIS (50.0%)0.600.620.670.620.640.670.630.640.650.67
Evaporative Fraction0.730.710.750.750.750.760.730.740.720.74
   GBAF (100.0%)0.730.710.750.750.750.760.730.740.720.74
Latent Heat0.600.620.660.620.640.670.620.660.640.68
   Fluxnet (25.0%)0.660.660.710.650.660.690.630.690.660.69
   GBAF (75.0%)0.580.600.650.620.630.670.610.660.630.67
Runoff0.680.810.810.750.810.820.690.790.700.79
   Dai (100.0%)0.680.810.810.750.810.820.690.790.700.79
Sensible Heat0.660.680.690.660.690.690.650.690.650.69
   Fluxnet (37.5%)0.700.710.720.700.710.700.680.700.680.69
   GBAF (62.5%)0.650.660.680.640.680.680.630.680.630.68
Terrestrial Water Storage Anomaly0.630.650.630.680.700.690.700.710.690.70
   GRACE (100.0%)0.630.650.630.680.700.690.700.710.690.70
Snow Water Equivalent0.630.610.620.550.560.570.500.540.510.54
   CanSISE (100.0%)0.630.610.620.550.560.570.500.540.510.54
Permafrost0.820.810.810.820.760.790.870.840.880.84
   NSIDC (100.0%)0.820.810.810.820.760.790.870.840.880.84
Hydrology Cycle Summary0.650.670.690.670.690.700.650.690.660.69
Albedo0.560.570.560.560.570.570.570.580.560.57
   CERES (50.0%)0.580.590.580.580.590.590.590.600.580.60
   GEWEX.SRB (50.0%)0.540.550.540.540.550.540.550.560.540.55
Surface Upward SW Radiation0.630.640.640.630.640.640.630.640.630.64
   CERES (35.7%)0.710.720.720.700.720.720.710.720.710.72
   GEWEX.SRB (35.7%)0.640.660.660.640.650.660.650.660.650.66
   WRMC.BSRN (28.6%)0.520.520.530.530.520.510.510.520.500.52
Surface Net SW Radiation0.710.730.730.710.730.730.710.730.700.73
   CERES (35.7%)0.780.810.810.780.820.820.780.820.780.82
   GEWEX.SRB (35.7%)0.740.780.780.740.780.780.740.780.740.78
   WRMC.BSRN (28.6%)0.600.570.570.580.570.570.580.570.580.57
Surface Upward LW Radiation0.740.760.760.730.750.760.730.750.740.75
   CERES (35.7%)0.780.790.800.780.790.800.780.780.780.79
   GEWEX.SRB (35.7%)0.790.800.810.780.800.800.780.790.790.80
   WRMC.BSRN (28.6%)0.620.650.650.610.640.650.620.640.630.65
Surface Net LW Radiation0.580.660.660.590.660.660.560.650.560.65
   CERES (35.7%)0.630.690.700.630.690.700.610.680.610.68
   GEWEX.SRB (35.7%)0.620.710.710.620.700.710.610.690.600.69
   WRMC.BSRN (28.6%)0.480.570.560.490.560.560.440.560.450.56
Surface Net Radiation0.690.710.720.690.710.720.690.700.680.71
   CERES (27.8%)0.740.750.750.740.750.750.730.740.730.74
   Fluxnet (22.2%)0.750.790.790.750.790.790.740.780.740.79
   GEWEX.SRB (27.8%)0.680.730.730.680.730.730.680.730.670.73
   WRMC.BSRN (22.2%)0.590.570.570.580.570.570.580.560.580.56
Radiation and Energy Cycle Summary0.660.680.680.660.680.680.650.680.650.68
Surface Air Temperature0.880.900.900.890.900.900.910.910.910.91
   CRU (73.5%)0.900.910.920.900.920.920.930.930.930.93
   Fluxnet (26.5%)0.840.860.860.840.860.860.860.860.860.86
Precipitation0.740.760.760.740.760.760.740.760.740.76
   CMAP (29.0%)0.750.740.740.750.740.740.750.740.750.74
   Fluxnet (13.0%)0.610.610.610.610.610.610.610.610.610.61
   GPCC (29.0%)0.780.860.860.780.860.860.780.860.780.86
   GPCP2 (29.0%)0.740.760.760.740.760.760.740.760.740.76
Surface Relative Humidity0.610.570.570.610.570.570.600.560.600.56
   ERA (100.0%)0.610.570.570.610.570.570.600.560.600.56
Surface Downward SW Radiation0.780.820.820.780.820.820.780.820.780.82
   CERES (27.8%)0.790.830.830.790.830.830.790.830.790.83
   Fluxnet (22.2%)0.810.860.860.810.860.860.810.860.810.86
   GEWEX.SRB (27.8%)0.770.830.830.770.830.830.770.830.770.83
   WRMC.BSRN (22.2%)0.750.760.760.750.760.760.750.760.750.76
Surface Downward LW Radiation0.740.820.820.740.820.820.740.820.740.82
   CERES (35.7%)0.750.810.810.750.810.810.750.810.750.81
   GEWEX.SRB (35.7%)0.750.860.860.750.860.860.750.860.750.86
   WRMC.BSRN (28.6%)0.720.780.780.720.780.780.720.780.720.78
Forcings Summary0.740.750.750.740.750.750.740.750.740.75
Overall Summary0.640.66~0.660.68~0.660.69~~

Relationship Scores

CLM4_CRUNCEP CLM4_GSWP3 CLM4SP_GSWP3 CLM4.5_CRUNCEP CLM4.5_GSWP3 CLM4.5SP_GSWP3 CLM5_CRUNCEP CLM5_GSWP3 CLM5SP_CRUNCEP CLM5SP_GSWP3
BurnedArea/GFED4S0.450.44~0.530.58~0.600.63~~
   Precipitation/GPCP2 (50.0%)0.450.45~0.530.58~0.590.63~~
   SurfaceAirTemperature/CRU (50.0%)0.440.44~0.540.58~0.610.64~~
GrossPrimaryProductivity/GBAF0.700.780.770.790.840.790.790.850.790.86
   Evapotranspiration/GLEAM (20.0%)0.820.850.870.810.860.880.830.890.900.96
   Precipitation/GPCP2 (20.0%)0.520.730.700.710.880.790.850.920.780.88
   SurfaceDownwardSWRadiation/CERES (20.0%)0.660.690.720.740.760.740.750.800.680.78
   SurfaceNetSWRadiation/CERES (20.0%)0.710.810.740.840.880.720.770.810.700.77
   SurfaceAirTemperature/CRU (20.0%)0.770.830.810.820.840.830.770.830.900.92
LeafAreaIndex/AVHRR0.340.540.930.450.610.900.650.840.890.90
   Precipitation/GPCP2 (100.0%)0.340.540.930.450.610.900.650.840.890.90
LeafAreaIndex/MODIS0.360.550.910.470.630.890.670.860.890.89
   Precipitation/GPCP2 (100.0%)0.360.550.910.470.630.890.670.860.890.89
Ecosystem and Carbon Cycle Summary~~~~~~~~~~
Evapotranspiration/GLEAM0.660.750.810.750.860.880.750.900.740.86
   Precipitation/GPCP2 (50.0%)0.590.730.800.700.860.880.680.910.670.86
   SurfaceAirTemperature/CRU (50.0%)0.720.770.830.800.870.880.820.900.800.86
Evapotranspiration/MODIS0.750.820.850.820.860.850.810.820.800.83
   Precipitation/GPCP2 (50.0%)0.740.880.930.850.930.900.830.880.820.91
   SurfaceAirTemperature/CRU (50.0%)0.760.750.770.800.790.790.800.760.780.76
Hydrology Cycle Summary~~~~~~~~~~
   Radiation and Energy Cycle Summary (0.0%)~~~~~~~~~~
   Forcings Summary (0.0%)~~~~~~~~~~
Overall Summary~~~~~~~~~~