CVDP logo

Back to Diagnostics Plots

CMIP5 Historical Run Comparison 1900-2005


Metrics Table


Pattern Correlations/RMS Differences   Observations vs. Model(s)

                                                                                                                                                                                                           ENSO TAS   ENSO PSL   El Nino    La Nina      AMO        PDO        NAM        SAM     SST sigma  PSL sigma   PR sigma    Mean  
                                                                                                                                                                                                            (DJF+1)    (DJF+1)     Hov        Hov     (Monthly)  (Monthly)    (DJF)      (DJF)      (Ann)      (Ann)       (Ann)     Score  
                                                                                                                                                                                                          ---------  ---------  ---------  ---------  ---------  ---------  ---------  ---------  ---------  ---------  ---------  ---------
OBS 2                                                                                                                                                                                                     0.94/0.25  0.98/0.38  0.98/0.11  0.96/0.16  0.89/0.25  0.96/0.05  1.00/0.15  0.99/0.83  0.85/0.10  0.96/0.19  1.00/0.00  ----/0.22
OBS 3                                                                                                                                                                                                     0.73/0.60  0.90/1.32  0.91/0.35  0.88/0.30  0.82/0.39  0.83/0.09  0.96/0.47  0.95/1.43  0.91/0.08  0.95/0.23  0.90/0.16  0.90/0.49
OBS 4                                                                                                                                                                                                     0.75/0.55  0.90/1.34  0.92/0.35  0.87/0.31  0.80/0.39  0.91/0.07  0.97/0.48  0.95/1.37  0.84/0.10  0.95/0.23  0.90/0.16  0.90/0.49
ACCESS1-0_0                                                                                                                                                                                               0.62/0.62  0.71/1.25  0.90/0.25  0.82/0.33  0.77/0.37  0.72/0.11  0.87/0.80  0.96/1.21  0.63/0.14  0.97/0.24  0.81/0.21  0.84/0.50
ACCESS1-3_0                                                                                                                                                                                               0.70/0.53  0.79/1.05  0.84/0.33  0.72/0.38  0.74/0.40  0.80/0.10  0.87/0.85  0.95/1.11  0.69/0.12  0.96/0.24  0.82/0.22  0.83/0.48
bcc-csm1-1_0                                                                                                                                                                                              0.64/0.58  0.75/1.16  0.89/0.31  0.68/0.54  0.77/0.33  0.55/0.14  0.90/0.91  0.97/0.96  0.46/0.16  0.93/0.27  0.79/0.24  0.81/0.51
bcc-csm1-1-m_0                                                                                                                                                                                            0.65/0.73  0.79/1.17  0.88/0.84  0.77/0.63  0.74/0.41  0.71/0.11  0.88/1.07  0.93/1.33  0.55/0.17  0.91/0.29  0.78/0.23  0.81/0.63
BNU-ESM_0                                                                                                                                                                                                 0.68/0.74  0.82/1.52  0.87/0.77  0.79/0.79  0.76/0.40  0.76/0.12  0.92/0.96  0.97/0.78  0.71/0.17  0.95/0.23  0.77/0.23  0.85/0.61
CanCM4_0                                                                                                                                                                                                  0.65/0.90  0.80/1.31  0.83/0.53  0.75/0.68  0.76/0.38  0.84/0.10  0.91/1.03  0.95/1.23  0.72/0.12  0.92/0.29  0.72/0.25  0.83/0.62
CanESM2_0                                                                                                                                                                                                 0.59/0.81  0.73/1.50  0.84/0.51  0.78/0.55  0.76/0.46  0.86/0.09  0.88/0.95  0.95/1.25  0.72/0.11  0.95/0.26  0.73/0.24  0.83/0.61
CCSM4_0                                                                                                                                                                                                   0.63/0.85  0.75/1.81  0.94/0.49  0.92/0.30  0.68/0.46  0.85/0.09  0.89/1.03  0.82/1.87  0.77/0.11  0.90/0.28  0.80/0.21  0.84/0.68
CESM1-BGC_0                                                                                                                                                                                               0.66/0.72  0.77/1.69  0.94/0.25  0.92/0.25  0.58/0.50  0.88/0.08  0.84/1.23  0.91/1.57  0.77/0.10  0.89/0.31  0.81/0.21  0.84/0.63
CESM1-CAM5_0                                                                                                                                                                                              0.49/0.80  0.66/1.46  0.90/0.43  0.86/0.37  0.67/0.45  0.71/0.13  0.89/0.77  0.95/1.27  0.70/0.11  0.95/0.23  0.79/0.22  0.82/0.57
CESM1-CAM5-1-FV2_0                                                                                                                                                                                        0.55/1.05  0.81/2.15  0.92/0.67  0.88/0.52  0.52/0.58  0.80/0.14  0.85/1.47  0.90/1.31  0.71/0.16  0.90/0.28  0.78/0.23  0.81/0.78
CESM1-FASTCHEM_0                                                                                                                                                                                          0.69/0.66  0.75/1.79  0.94/0.36  0.86/0.37  0.67/0.43  0.77/0.10  0.90/0.92  0.80/1.79  0.73/0.11  0.91/0.28  0.81/0.21  0.82/0.64
CESM1-WACCM_0                                                                                                                                                                                             0.49/1.17  0.68/2.27  0.94/0.44  0.86/0.37  0.71/0.41  0.78/0.12  0.76/1.45  0.82/1.90  0.71/0.13  0.88/0.31  0.80/0.21  0.79/0.80
CMCC-CESM_0                                                                                                                                                                                               0.73/0.92  0.85/1.33  0.85/0.77  0.82/0.56  0.73/0.41  0.86/0.11  0.91/0.97  0.97/0.79  0.72/0.16  0.94/0.29  0.78/0.23  0.86/0.59
CMCC-CM_0                                                                                                                                                                                                 0.66/0.56  0.83/1.02  0.81/0.33  0.83/0.31  0.75/0.36  0.85/0.09  0.90/0.74  0.97/1.22  0.62/0.12  0.97/0.18  0.80/0.22  0.85/0.47
CMCC-CMS_0                                                                                                                                                                                                0.80/0.53  0.87/1.03  0.90/0.29  0.89/0.28  0.63/0.48  0.87/0.08  0.97/0.36  0.98/0.89  0.73/0.11  0.96/0.19  0.82/0.21  0.89/0.40
CNRM-CM5_0                                                                                                                                                                                                0.71/0.58  0.78/1.06  0.89/0.57  0.76/0.50  0.78/0.35  0.63/0.13  0.95/0.50  0.97/0.99  0.57/0.13  0.97/0.19  0.81/0.21  0.85/0.47
CNRM-CM5-2_0                                                                                                                                                                                              0.69/0.58  0.76/1.10  0.88/0.60  0.79/0.51  0.80/0.34  0.55/0.14  0.90/0.70  0.97/1.24  0.41/0.17  0.97/0.22  0.81/0.21  0.83/0.53
CSIRO-Mk3-6-0_0                                                                                                                                                                                           0.54/0.76  0.75/1.39  0.52/0.64  0.50/0.64  0.67/0.48  0.72/0.13  0.61/1.53  0.94/1.21  0.60/0.16  0.95/0.23  0.75/0.31  0.74/0.68
EC-EARTH_0                                                                                                                                                                                                0.20/0.91  0.33/2.17  0.78/0.39  0.74/0.39  0.64/0.46  0.48/0.15  0.92/0.62  0.95/1.35  0.50/0.15  0.98/0.21  ----/----  ----/----
FGOALS-g2_0                                                                                                                                                                                               0.65/0.58  0.78/1.10  0.84/0.38  0.82/0.34  0.71/0.44  0.80/0.10  0.79/1.02  0.97/1.05  0.73/0.12  0.96/0.24  0.74/0.25  0.83/0.51
FIO-ESM_0                                                                                                                                                                                                 0.62/0.69  0.68/1.56  0.80/0.65  0.77/0.67  0.72/0.43  0.84/0.09  0.91/0.90  0.95/1.00  0.73/0.13  0.95/0.21  0.77/0.23  0.83/0.60
GFDL-CM2p1_0                                                                                                                                                                                              0.56/1.14  0.74/2.16  0.81/1.15  0.51/1.50  0.65/0.58  0.77/0.14  0.91/0.82  0.96/0.97  0.70/0.18  0.93/0.25  0.76/0.39  0.80/0.84
GFDL-CM3_0                                                                                                                                                                                                0.71/0.63  0.89/0.87  0.86/0.64  0.73/0.69  0.81/0.32  0.83/0.09  0.96/0.50  0.98/0.77  0.59/0.14  0.96/0.19  0.77/0.23  0.87/0.46
GFDL-ESM2G_0                                                                                                                                                                                              0.46/0.80  0.67/1.36  0.78/0.43  0.77/0.35  0.71/0.42  0.71/0.12  0.96/0.67  0.96/1.14  0.57/0.14  0.95/0.24  0.76/0.25  0.81/0.54
GFDL-ESM2M_0                                                                                                                                                                                              0.64/0.95  0.81/1.62  0.78/1.25  0.66/0.84  0.68/0.54  0.78/0.12  0.88/0.89  0.96/0.99  0.64/0.18  0.93/0.26  0.76/0.34  0.81/0.73
GISS-E2-H_0                                                                                                                                                                                               0.45/0.66  0.25/1.72  0.89/0.32  0.75/0.39  0.76/0.35  0.48/0.14  0.93/0.61  0.98/1.05  0.52/0.15  0.96/0.27  0.75/0.26  0.80/0.54
GISS-E2-H-CC_0                                                                                                                                                                                            0.70/0.53  0.78/1.06  0.90/0.33  0.74/0.53  0.74/0.43  0.70/0.12  0.90/0.73  0.97/1.16  0.51/0.14  0.95/0.28  0.75/0.26  0.83/0.51
GISS-E2-R_0                                                                                                                                                                                               0.60/0.62  0.40/1.63  0.92/0.27  0.88/0.29  0.79/0.35  0.61/0.13  0.93/0.60  0.97/0.91  0.54/0.14  0.96/0.27  0.79/0.22  0.83/0.49
GISS-E2-R-CC_0                                                                                                                                                                                            0.68/0.53  0.71/1.21  0.92/0.30  0.83/0.33  0.80/0.32  0.65/0.12  0.89/0.77  0.98/0.90  0.55/0.14  0.96/0.26  0.79/0.22  0.85/0.46
HadCM3_0                                                                                                                                                                                                  0.57/0.71  0.69/1.28  0.84/0.38  0.78/0.41  0.70/0.41  0.63/0.14  0.68/1.37  0.97/1.10  0.65/0.16  0.95/0.23  ----/----  ----/----
HadGEM2-AO_0                                                                                                                                                                                              0.73/0.53  0.85/0.92  0.83/0.32  0.85/0.27  0.70/0.39  0.85/0.08  0.88/0.77  0.96/1.15  0.69/0.13  0.95/0.26  0.82/0.20  0.85/0.46
HadGEM2-CC_0                                                                                                                                                                                              0.60/0.67  0.74/1.15  0.82/0.37  0.84/0.28  0.76/0.35  0.81/0.10  0.91/0.67  0.95/1.24  0.71/0.15  0.97/0.21  0.82/0.20  0.85/0.49
HadGEM2-ES_0                                                                                                                                                                                              0.68/0.58  0.76/1.10  0.79/0.38  0.81/0.29  0.78/0.34  0.86/0.08  0.96/0.50  0.96/1.12  0.69/0.14  0.97/0.22  0.83/0.20  0.86/0.45
inmcm4_0                                                                                                                                                                                                  0.25/0.85  0.44/1.81  0.75/0.38  0.71/0.38  0.56/0.51  0.52/0.14  0.90/0.72  0.93/1.55  0.54/0.15  0.92/0.34  0.71/0.26  0.72/0.64
IPSL-CM5A-LR_0                                                                                                                                                                                            0.65/0.58  0.68/1.26  0.87/0.30  0.83/0.30  0.75/0.35  0.83/0.09  0.97/0.43  0.96/0.88  0.67/0.12  0.94/0.34  0.73/0.26  0.85/0.45
IPSL-CM5A-MR_0                                                                                                                                                                                            0.77/0.46  0.73/1.19  0.83/0.33  0.77/0.32  0.71/0.39  0.85/0.09  0.86/1.04  0.98/0.74  0.73/0.10  0.96/0.23  0.74/0.24  0.85/0.47
IPSL-CM5B-LR_0                                                                                                                                                                                            0.59/0.64  0.66/1.34  0.81/0.34  0.81/0.39  0.65/0.41  0.71/0.11  0.95/0.54  0.96/0.88  0.46/0.16  0.96/0.20  0.77/0.27  0.82/0.48
MIROC4h_0                                                                                                                                                                                                 0.65/0.58  0.76/1.12  0.83/0.33  0.80/0.30  0.57/0.47  0.82/0.09  0.81/1.07  0.96/1.16  0.62/0.12  0.96/0.22  0.79/0.22  0.82/0.52
MIROC5_0                                                                                                                                                                                                  0.67/0.86  0.83/1.39  0.80/1.06  0.64/0.85  0.71/0.45  0.82/0.14  0.82/0.93  0.98/1.19  0.69/0.16  0.96/0.19  0.80/0.24  0.83/0.68
MIROC-ESM_0                                                                                                                                                                                               0.60/0.59  0.50/1.50  0.71/0.45  0.72/0.40  0.69/0.38  0.74/0.11  0.88/0.82  0.97/0.88  0.62/0.13  0.95/0.24  0.71/0.27  0.79/0.52
MIROC-ESM-CHEM_0                                                                                                                                                                                          0.43/0.71  0.30/1.90  0.70/0.46  0.72/0.37  0.77/0.33  0.79/0.10  0.89/0.80  0.97/1.00  0.66/0.12  0.94/0.24  0.71/0.27  0.78/0.57
MPI-ESM-LR_0                                                                                                                                                                                              0.38/0.86  0.38/1.79  0.78/0.46  0.79/0.34  0.76/0.35  0.70/0.12  0.96/0.42  0.97/1.10  0.68/0.14  0.97/0.17  0.78/0.23  0.82/0.54
MPI-ESM-MR_0                                                                                                                                                                                              0.64/0.57  0.62/1.37  0.77/0.39  0.80/0.31  0.72/0.38  0.76/0.11  0.96/0.43  0.97/0.99  0.70/0.12  0.97/0.18  0.81/0.21  0.85/0.46
MPI-ESM-P_0                                                                                                                                                                                               0.68/0.57  0.70/1.34  0.84/0.37  0.73/0.39  0.73/0.40  0.67/0.13  0.94/0.57  0.97/1.03  0.66/0.15  0.97/0.17  0.79/0.22  0.84/0.49
MRI-CGCM3_0                                                                                                                                                                                               0.51/0.67  0.47/1.65  0.89/0.29  0.78/0.32  0.64/0.43  0.72/0.11  0.88/0.91  0.97/0.95  0.51/0.15  0.93/0.31  0.80/0.23  0.80/0.55
MRI-ESM1_0                                                                                                                                                                                                0.62/0.62  0.70/1.35  0.88/0.28  0.81/0.32  0.74/0.37  0.69/0.12  0.90/0.91  0.97/0.85  0.51/0.15  0.94/0.31  0.80/0.23  0.82/0.50
NorESM1-M_0                                                                                                                                                                                               0.66/0.74  0.70/1.75  0.89/0.51  0.87/0.37  0.65/0.46  0.81/0.10  0.92/0.90  0.92/1.43  0.74/0.11  0.93/0.25  0.78/0.22  0.83/0.62
NorESM1-ME_0                                                                                                                                                                                              0.70/0.75  0.80/1.58  0.92/0.37  0.88/0.31  0.66/0.51  0.77/0.11  0.95/0.66  0.92/1.50  0.77/0.11  0.90/0.29  0.78/0.22  0.85/0.58
ACCESS1-0_1                                                                                                                                                                                               0.70/0.56  0.79/1.04  0.88/0.29  0.73/0.50  0.76/0.37  0.78/0.10  0.95/0.47  0.96/1.13  0.64/0.14  0.97/0.21  0.81/0.21  0.86/0.46
ACCESS1-3_1                                                                                                                                                                                               0.63/0.57  0.44/1.56  0.85/0.30  0.72/0.39  0.78/0.37  0.70/0.12  0.96/0.49  0.97/1.03  0.66/0.13  0.97/0.23  0.82/0.22  0.84/0.49
bcc-csm1-1_1                                                                                                                                                                                              0.50/0.68  0.67/1.27  0.90/0.25  0.77/0.40  0.73/0.36  0.70/0.12  0.93/0.77  0.98/0.92  0.43/0.17  0.93/0.25  0.80/0.24  0.82/0.49
bcc-csm1-1-m_1                                                                                                                                                                                            0.71/0.68  0.84/1.09  0.88/0.67  0.70/0.83  0.70/0.50  0.76/0.11  0.88/1.14  0.92/1.32  0.58/0.15  0.91/0.30  0.79/0.22  0.81/0.64
CanCM4_1                                                                                                                                                                                                  0.60/0.77  0.79/1.34  0.81/0.38  0.73/0.59  0.66/0.42  0.82/0.10  0.90/0.94  0.95/1.16  0.70/0.11  0.94/0.28  0.73/0.24  0.82/0.58
CanESM2_1                                                                                                                                                                                                 0.64/0.75  0.77/1.19  0.85/0.56  0.77/0.61  0.83/0.32  0.83/0.10  0.86/1.05  0.96/1.24  0.73/0.11  0.96/0.22  0.74/0.24  0.84/0.58
CCSM4_1                                                                                                                                                                                                   0.58/0.86  0.69/2.18  0.93/0.41  0.91/0.34  0.64/0.49  0.85/0.09  0.91/1.06  0.88/1.64  0.75/0.11  0.92/0.28  0.81/0.21  0.84/0.70
CESM1-CAM5_1                                                                                                                                                                                              0.52/0.90  0.76/2.03  0.93/0.41  0.85/0.38  0.68/0.44  0.83/0.09  0.90/0.81  0.94/1.31  0.75/0.10  0.93/0.25  0.80/0.21  0.84/0.63
CESM1-CAM5-1-FV2_1                                                                                                                                                                                        0.54/0.93  0.77/1.60  0.90/0.76  0.89/0.53  0.52/0.59  0.74/0.16  0.92/0.86  0.94/1.21  0.69/0.17  0.89/0.29  0.78/0.23  0.82/0.67
CESM1-FASTCHEM_1                                                                                                                                                                                          0.65/0.69  0.74/1.81  0.94/0.37  0.90/0.30  0.55/0.54  0.81/0.10  0.88/1.12  0.85/1.59  0.73/0.12  0.89/0.31  0.80/0.21  0.82/0.65
CESM1-WACCM_1                                                                                                                                                                                             0.56/1.36  0.70/2.68  0.92/0.78  0.88/0.57  0.64/0.52  0.83/0.12  0.72/1.71  0.76/2.07  0.72/0.14  0.81/0.38  0.79/0.22  0.78/0.96
CNRM-CM5_1                                                                                                                                                                                                0.67/0.57  0.84/0.93  0.88/0.59  0.80/0.46  0.76/0.35  0.67/0.12  0.90/0.69  0.97/1.03  0.61/0.13  0.97/0.23  0.81/0.21  0.85/0.48
CSIRO-Mk3-6-0_1                                                                                                                                                                                           0.53/0.68  0.74/1.16  0.55/0.54  0.38/0.56  0.70/0.45  0.77/0.11  0.73/1.21  0.96/1.27  0.61/0.15  0.94/0.29  0.76/0.28  0.75/0.61
EC-EARTH_1                                                                                                                                                                                                ----/----  ----/----  ----/----  ----/----  ----/----  ----/----  0.91/0.65  0.97/1.13  ----/----  0.97/0.19  0.77/0.25  ----/----
FGOALS-g2_1                                                                                                                                                                                               0.64/0.58  0.70/1.33  0.88/0.34  0.80/0.37  0.72/0.37  0.82/0.10  0.71/1.21  0.96/1.10  0.72/0.13  0.95/0.26  0.75/0.25  0.82/0.55
FIO-ESM_1                                                                                                                                                                                                 0.67/0.63  0.70/1.62  0.77/0.72  0.74/0.72  0.68/0.51  0.84/0.09  0.89/0.82  0.95/1.01  0.75/0.12  0.94/0.23  0.76/0.23  0.82/0.61
GFDL-CM2p1_1                                                                                                                                                                                              0.61/0.97  0.69/2.00  0.81/1.09  0.59/1.13  0.73/0.44  0.82/0.11  0.94/0.60  0.97/0.73  0.68/0.16  0.94/0.22  0.77/0.35  0.82/0.71
GFDL-CM3_1                                                                                                                                                                                                0.67/0.70  0.79/1.41  0.81/0.91  0.76/0.68  0.67/0.49  0.78/0.10  0.96/0.64  0.98/0.82  0.51/0.15  0.96/0.18  0.76/0.23  0.84/0.57
GISS-E2-H_1                                                                                                                                                                                               0.39/0.69  0.47/1.50  0.86/0.33  0.74/0.46  0.73/0.38  0.67/0.12  0.84/0.85  0.97/1.14  0.54/0.15  0.96/0.30  0.75/0.25  0.79/0.56
GISS-E2-R_1                                                                                                                                                                                               0.58/0.62  0.62/1.34  0.90/0.31  0.81/0.35  0.78/0.34  0.75/0.11  0.91/0.66  0.97/0.90  0.47/0.14  0.96/0.26  0.79/0.22  0.83/0.48
HadCM3_1                                                                                                                                                                                                  0.49/0.78  0.65/1.35  0.85/0.36  0.73/0.37  0.79/0.33  0.63/0.15  0.75/1.24  0.97/1.07  0.63/0.15  0.95/0.24  ----/----  ----/----
HadGEM2-CC_1                                                                                                                                                                                              0.50/0.93  0.63/1.62  0.74/0.50  0.68/0.42  0.69/0.42  0.65/0.13  0.90/0.71  0.96/1.18  0.65/0.14  0.96/0.21  0.82/0.20  0.80/0.59
HadGEM2-ES_1                                                                                                                                                                                              0.68/0.72  0.77/1.15  0.81/0.38  0.87/0.36  0.77/0.35  0.87/0.09  0.94/0.56  0.95/1.26  0.73/0.15  0.97/0.17  0.82/0.21  0.86/0.49
IPSL-CM5A-LR_1                                                                                                                                                                                            0.62/0.60  0.67/1.47  0.84/0.32  0.74/0.35  0.68/0.42  0.77/0.11  0.97/0.43  0.96/0.87  0.67/0.12  0.95/0.32  0.73/0.25  0.83/0.48
IPSL-CM5A-MR_1                                                                                                                                                                                            0.68/0.54  0.81/1.09  0.84/0.31  0.75/0.36  0.70/0.39  0.84/0.09  0.81/1.14  0.98/0.81  0.74/0.10  0.95/0.26  0.73/0.25  0.84/0.49
MIROC4h_1                                                                                                                                                                                                 0.67/0.59  0.83/1.04  0.86/0.33  0.71/0.42  0.67/0.43  0.79/0.10  0.85/0.84  0.97/1.30  0.57/0.12  0.97/0.23  ----/----  ----/----
MIROC5_1                                                                                                                                                                                                  0.65/0.84  0.81/1.54  0.74/0.96  0.53/0.91  0.73/0.45  0.86/0.12 -0.11/2.13  0.98/1.20  0.71/0.15  0.94/0.23  0.80/0.23  0.78/0.80
MIROC-ESM_1                                                                                                                                                                                               0.48/0.66  0.39/1.65  0.66/0.48  0.70/0.38  0.75/0.34  0.70/0.12  0.89/0.74  0.97/0.96  0.66/0.12  0.95/0.23  0.70/0.27  0.78/0.54
MPI-ESM-LR_1                                                                                                                                                                                              0.61/0.67  0.68/1.27  0.75/0.54  0.78/0.36  0.77/0.35  0.74/0.11  0.98/0.34  0.97/1.09  0.70/0.15  0.97/0.16  0.79/0.22  0.85/0.48
MPI-ESM-MR_1                                                                                                                                                                                              0.57/0.66  0.55/1.55  0.71/0.47  0.82/0.30  0.67/0.41  0.79/0.10  0.90/0.78  0.98/0.79  0.71/0.12  0.97/0.16  0.81/0.21  0.83/0.50
MPI-ESM-P_1                                                                                                                                                                                               0.61/0.63  0.52/1.46  0.76/0.39  0.77/0.39  0.76/0.34  0.75/0.11  0.94/0.52  0.98/1.23  0.67/0.14  0.96/0.21  0.78/0.22  0.83/0.51
MRI-CGCM3_1                                                                                                                                                                                               0.62/0.60  0.75/1.21  0.89/0.30  0.83/0.30  0.76/0.35  0.75/0.11  0.90/1.02  0.98/0.98  0.51/0.15  0.91/0.33  0.80/0.23  0.83/0.51
NorESM1-M_1                                                                                                                                                                                               0.61/0.73  0.74/1.45  0.93/0.25  0.85/0.37  0.66/0.51  0.83/0.10  0.92/0.90  0.92/1.45  0.75/0.11  0.92/0.27  0.78/0.22  0.84/0.58
ACCESS1-3_2                                                                                                                                                                                               0.71/0.52  0.80/1.03  0.85/0.31  0.77/0.34  0.80/0.33  0.79/0.10  0.88/0.83  0.95/1.02  0.67/0.12  0.96/0.24  0.82/0.22  0.84/0.46
bcc-csm1-1_2                                                                                                                                                                                              0.52/0.69  0.60/1.38  0.89/0.29  0.69/0.59  0.75/0.35  0.63/0.13  0.93/0.78  0.98/1.08  0.53/0.15  0.93/0.28  0.79/0.24  0.81/0.54
bcc-csm1-1-m_2                                                                                                                                                                                            0.69/0.76  0.84/1.29  0.88/0.75  0.77/0.69  0.72/0.50  0.77/0.11  0.89/1.10  0.92/1.33  0.55/0.17  0.91/0.30  0.79/0.22  0.82/0.66
CanCM4_2                                                                                                                                                                                                  0.44/1.04  0.59/2.21  0.74/0.64  0.80/0.52  0.64/0.44  0.85/0.10  0.86/1.48  0.94/1.30  0.69/0.12  0.90/0.32  0.72/0.25  0.78/0.77
CanESM2_2                                                                                                                                                                                                 0.58/0.93  0.67/1.78  0.84/0.54  0.77/0.61  0.77/0.37  0.84/0.09  0.88/1.05  0.96/1.22  0.70/0.11  0.95/0.25  0.74/0.24  0.83/0.65
CCSM4_2                                                                                                                                                                                                   0.67/0.70  0.72/1.70  0.92/0.57  0.88/0.43  0.64/0.48  0.87/0.08  0.87/1.04  0.86/1.70  0.76/0.11  0.92/0.25  0.79/0.22  0.83/0.66
CESM1-CAM5_2                                                                                                                                                                                              0.53/0.87  0.72/1.66  0.92/0.52  0.87/0.54  0.65/0.50  0.80/0.12  0.87/0.94  0.94/1.38  0.73/0.12  0.95/0.21  0.79/0.23  0.83/0.64
CESM1-CAM5-1-FV2_2                                                                                                                                                                                        0.58/0.83  0.82/1.72  0.93/0.53  0.90/0.28  0.55/0.54  0.86/0.10  0.85/1.13  0.95/1.11  0.74/0.12  0.93/0.24  0.78/0.22  0.84/0.62
CESM1-FASTCHEM_2                                                                                                                                                                                          0.65/0.71  0.78/1.55  0.95/0.46  0.91/0.45  0.62/0.51  0.85/0.09  0.90/1.07  0.79/1.83  0.76/0.12  0.92/0.26  0.80/0.22  0.84/0.66
CESM1-WACCM_2                                                                                                                                                                                             0.42/1.13  0.65/2.34  0.93/0.67  0.83/0.43  0.62/0.54  0.74/0.12  0.75/1.39  0.77/2.00  0.71/0.13  0.85/0.35  0.79/0.21  0.76/0.85
CNRM-CM5_2                                                                                                                                                                                                0.57/0.65  0.54/1.49  0.89/0.42  0.80/0.42  0.77/0.34  0.66/0.12  0.91/0.67  0.97/1.23  0.59/0.13  0.96/0.25  0.81/0.21  0.83/0.54
CSIRO-Mk3-6-0_2                                                                                                                                                                                           0.46/0.78  0.73/1.19  0.51/0.63  0.52/0.49  0.80/0.33  0.78/0.11  0.74/1.18  0.95/1.46  0.60/0.16  0.96/0.23  0.76/0.30  0.77/0.62
FGOALS-g2_2                                                                                                                                                                                               0.63/0.68  0.65/1.42  0.87/0.39  0.81/0.41  0.82/0.30  0.82/0.09  0.80/1.02  0.97/1.12  0.72/0.13  0.96/0.25  0.75/0.25  0.84/0.55
FIO-ESM_2                                                                                                                                                                                                 0.60/0.76  0.60/2.02  0.75/0.63  0.75/0.68  0.68/0.55  0.81/0.10  0.90/0.89  0.95/1.01  0.74/0.13  0.95/0.21  0.77/0.23  0.81/0.66
GFDL-CM2p1_2                                                                                                                                                                                              0.55/1.08  0.73/2.04  0.82/1.23  0.51/1.24  0.71/0.44  0.82/0.12  0.94/0.64  0.97/0.85  0.71/0.15  0.94/0.22  0.77/0.36  0.82/0.76
GFDL-CM3_2                                                                                                                                                                                                0.64/0.68  0.84/1.11  0.83/0.65  0.77/0.55  0.83/0.29  0.80/0.10  0.88/0.81  0.96/0.99  0.45/0.15  0.97/0.17  0.76/0.24  0.84/0.52
GISS-E2-H_2                                                                                                                                                                                               0.60/0.59  0.53/1.46  0.88/0.33  0.75/0.38  0.76/0.36  0.67/0.12  0.86/0.83  0.98/1.13  0.51/0.15  0.96/0.25  0.74/0.26  0.81/0.53
GISS-E2-R_2                                                                                                                                                                                               0.61/0.58  0.69/1.25  0.88/0.35  0.78/0.40  0.76/0.34  0.56/0.14  0.88/0.81  0.97/0.91  0.52/0.14  0.96/0.27  0.79/0.22  0.82/0.49
HadCM3_2                                                                                                                                                                                                  0.38/0.81  0.51/1.68  0.84/0.35  0.76/0.41  0.74/0.36  0.63/0.13  0.87/0.85  0.96/1.30  0.63/0.14  0.94/0.28  ----/----  ----/----
HadGEM2-CC_2                                                                                                                                                                                              0.59/0.72  0.74/1.34  0.80/0.36  0.68/0.38  0.68/0.41  0.77/0.10  0.91/0.74  0.95/1.10  0.62/0.14  0.94/0.27  0.82/0.20  0.81/0.52
HadGEM2-ES_2                                                                                                                                                                                              0.56/0.68  0.75/1.13  0.80/0.36  0.76/0.34  0.78/0.34  0.88/0.08  0.92/0.63  0.96/1.27  0.70/0.13  0.96/0.22  0.82/0.20  0.85/0.49
IPSL-CM5A-LR_2                                                                                                                                                                                            0.60/0.67  0.57/1.81  0.86/0.32  0.80/0.31  0.66/0.42  0.82/0.10  0.91/0.81  0.96/0.98  0.63/0.14  0.94/0.33  0.74/0.25  0.82/0.56
IPSL-CM5A-MR_2                                                                                                                                                                                            0.55/0.64  0.74/1.16  0.84/0.32  0.78/0.33  0.72/0.39  0.86/0.09  0.84/1.09  0.98/0.83  0.74/0.10  0.96/0.24  0.74/0.25  0.84/0.49
MIROC4h_2                                                                                                                                                                                                 0.51/0.67  0.52/1.49  0.79/0.39  0.52/0.58  0.63/0.48  0.71/0.11  0.66/1.23  0.95/1.25  0.54/0.13  0.96/0.23  ----/----  ----/----
MIROC5_2                                                                                                                                                                                                  0.61/0.94  0.81/1.31  0.82/0.96  0.63/0.76  0.71/0.43  0.84/0.12  0.89/0.75  0.98/1.28  0.67/0.14  0.95/0.21  0.80/0.23  0.84/0.65
MIROC-ESM_2                                                                                                                                                                                               0.50/0.66  0.36/1.75  0.52/0.54  0.74/0.37  0.72/0.39  0.76/0.11  0.91/0.67  0.97/0.95  0.63/0.12  0.94/0.24  0.72/0.26  0.78/0.55
MPI-ESM-LR_2                                                                                                                                                                                              0.56/0.72  0.55/1.49  0.82/0.43  0.74/0.43  0.69/0.45  0.76/0.11  0.96/0.44  0.97/1.07  0.70/0.14  0.97/0.16  0.78/0.23  0.83/0.52
MPI-ESM-MR_2                                                                                                                                                                                              0.71/0.52  0.74/1.15  0.75/0.41  0.77/0.36  0.68/0.43  0.72/0.12  0.92/0.74  0.98/0.93  0.63/0.13  0.97/0.17  0.81/0.21  0.84/0.47
MRI-CGCM3_2                                                                                                                                                                                               0.73/0.50  0.77/1.16  0.88/0.30  0.81/0.32  0.71/0.38  0.58/0.13  0.89/0.98  0.97/0.91  0.45/0.16  0.94/0.28  0.80/0.24  0.82/0.49
NorESM1-M_2                                                                                                                                                                                               0.67/0.74  0.79/1.64  0.91/0.48  0.85/0.37  0.61/0.54  0.79/0.10  0.92/0.86  0.91/1.39  0.76/0.11  0.94/0.24  0.79/0.22  0.84/0.61
CanCM4_3                                                                                                                                                                                                  0.61/0.83  0.70/1.44  0.85/0.35  0.77/0.55  0.69/0.43  0.85/0.10  0.88/0.89  0.95/1.31  0.75/0.11  0.94/0.25  0.72/0.25  0.82/0.59
CanESM2_3                                                                                                                                                                                                 0.56/0.88  0.73/1.53  0.86/0.49  0.75/0.55  0.80/0.36  0.84/0.09  0.90/0.90  0.95/1.25  0.73/0.11  0.95/0.26  0.73/0.24  0.83/0.61
CCSM4_3                                                                                                                                                                                                   0.54/0.78  0.65/1.69  0.94/0.28  0.90/0.27  0.38/0.64  0.78/0.10  0.87/1.03  0.88/1.68  0.73/0.11  0.90/0.30  0.80/0.21  0.81/0.64
CESM1-CAM5-1-FV2_3                                                                                                                                                                                        0.48/1.05  0.74/1.87  0.92/0.55  0.88/0.61  0.78/0.35  0.80/0.13  0.88/1.13  0.92/1.30  0.70/0.16  0.89/0.29  0.77/0.23  0.82/0.70
CESM1-WACCM_3                                                                                                                                                                                             0.53/1.19  0.70/2.28  0.90/0.89  0.89/0.41  0.63/0.76  0.79/0.12  0.76/1.40  0.39/2.44  0.70/0.14  0.89/0.30  0.79/0.22  0.76/0.92
CNRM-CM5_3                                                                                                                                                                                                0.73/0.52  0.68/1.27  0.88/0.43  0.80/0.45  0.78/0.33  0.51/0.14  0.91/0.64  0.97/1.24  0.60/0.12  0.97/0.23  0.81/0.21  0.84/0.51
CSIRO-Mk3-6-0_3                                                                                                                                                                                           0.42/0.80  0.60/1.38  0.47/0.66  0.59/0.51  0.75/0.41  0.68/0.12  0.70/1.28  0.96/1.22  0.62/0.15  0.96/0.24  0.77/0.28  0.75/0.64
FGOALS-g2_3                                                                                                                                                                                               0.63/0.63  0.68/1.30  0.89/0.33  0.81/0.41  0.69/0.39  0.84/0.09  0.77/1.03  0.96/1.08  0.73/0.13  0.95/0.29  0.75/0.25  0.82/0.54
GFDL-CM2p1_3                                                                                                                                                                                              0.59/1.25  0.72/2.26  0.83/0.99  0.60/1.51  0.76/0.38  0.81/0.12  0.95/0.64  0.96/0.95  0.69/0.16  0.92/0.25  0.77/0.35  0.82/0.81
GFDL-CM3_3                                                                                                                                                                                                0.59/0.78  0.84/1.30  0.84/0.74  0.77/0.62  0.79/0.36  0.83/0.09  0.89/0.83  0.97/0.93  0.53/0.15  0.97/0.15  0.77/0.23  0.84/0.56
GISS-E2-H_3                                                                                                                                                                                               0.55/0.61  0.53/1.44  0.88/0.32  0.72/0.47  0.68/0.42  0.56/0.13  0.88/0.75  0.99/0.98  0.53/0.15  0.96/0.26  0.74/0.26  0.81/0.53
GISS-E2-R_3                                                                                                                                                                                               0.59/0.59  0.72/1.22  0.91/0.30  0.88/0.28  0.78/0.35  0.61/0.13  0.91/0.70  0.98/0.84  0.58/0.13  0.96/0.25  0.79/0.22  0.85/0.46
HadCM3_3                                                                                                                                                                                                  0.50/0.83  0.71/1.35  0.84/0.46  0.77/0.39  0.80/0.33  0.67/0.13  0.79/1.05  0.97/0.99  0.70/0.15  0.95/0.23  ----/----  ----/----
HadGEM2-ES_3                                                                                                                                                                                              0.65/0.59  0.82/0.99  0.79/0.37  0.78/0.33  0.77/0.34  0.82/0.09  0.88/0.74  0.96/1.26  0.71/0.13  0.97/0.19  0.82/0.20  0.85/0.48
IPSL-CM5A-LR_3                                                                                                                                                                                            0.68/0.56  0.65/1.57  0.84/0.32  0.78/0.31  0.68/0.41  0.79/0.10  0.88/1.08  0.96/0.87  0.68/0.12  0.95/0.30  0.73/0.26  0.82/0.54
MIROC5_3                                                                                                                                                                                                  0.77/0.68  0.84/1.33  0.79/1.03  0.64/0.81  0.73/0.44  0.84/0.15  0.75/1.11  0.98/1.16  0.69/0.16  0.94/0.22  0.80/0.24  0.83/0.67
CanCM4_4                                                                                                                                                                                                  0.69/0.98  0.76/1.59  0.83/0.61  0.67/0.95  0.70/0.54  0.86/0.10  0.83/1.17  0.94/1.34  0.73/0.11  0.92/0.28  0.74/0.24  0.81/0.72
CanESM2_4                                                                                                                                                                                                 0.59/0.91  0.78/1.31  0.86/0.47  0.78/0.62  0.76/0.37  0.85/0.09  0.89/0.81  0.96/1.14  0.70/0.11  0.95/0.25  0.74/0.24  0.84/0.57
CCSM4_4                                                                                                                                                                                                   0.67/0.72  0.76/1.83  0.93/0.61  0.90/0.34  0.65/0.47  0.87/0.09  0.86/1.16  0.85/1.77  0.77/0.11  0.91/0.29  0.80/0.22  0.83/0.69
CESM1-WACCM_4                                                                                                                                                                                             0.42/1.33  0.70/2.07  0.90/0.74  0.87/0.45  0.64/0.47  0.70/0.15  0.77/1.43  0.47/2.34  0.70/0.13  0.83/0.38  0.79/0.21  0.74/0.88
CNRM-CM5_4                                                                                                                                                                                                0.66/0.59  0.79/1.05  0.88/0.52  0.80/0.47  0.74/0.36  0.59/0.13  0.88/0.78  0.97/1.05  0.67/0.11  0.97/0.20  0.81/0.21  0.84/0.50
CSIRO-Mk3-6-0_4                                                                                                                                                                                           0.42/0.84  0.68/1.46  0.61/0.59  0.46/0.57  0.72/0.45  0.69/0.12  0.60/1.46  0.94/1.37  0.62/0.16  0.95/0.25  0.76/0.30  0.73/0.69
FGOALS-g2_4                                                                                                                                                                                               0.61/0.65  0.70/1.30  0.86/0.47  0.84/0.33  0.69/0.38  0.82/0.10  0.80/0.98  0.96/1.20  0.73/0.13  0.96/0.25  0.74/0.25  0.83/0.55
GFDL-CM2p1_4                                                                                                                                                                                              0.51/1.26  0.69/2.40  0.83/1.32  0.65/1.14  0.71/0.50  0.80/0.14  0.95/0.49  0.96/0.92  0.69/0.18  0.90/0.29  0.76/0.40  0.81/0.82
GFDL-CM3_4                                                                                                                                                                                                0.72/0.62  0.87/1.26  0.83/0.73  0.78/0.65  0.76/0.39  0.81/0.10  0.90/0.89  0.97/0.82  0.48/0.17  0.96/0.20  0.76/0.23  0.85/0.55
GISS-E2-H_4                                                                                                                                                                                               0.46/0.66  0.31/1.63  0.87/0.31  0.76/0.36  0.69/0.47  0.66/0.12  0.86/0.82  0.98/0.97  0.53/0.15  0.96/0.28  0.75/0.25  0.79/0.55
GISS-E2-R_4                                                                                                                                                                                               0.68/0.53  0.69/1.24  0.93/0.32  0.81/0.40  0.75/0.35  0.65/0.12  0.92/0.62  0.97/1.14  0.42/0.15  0.96/0.27  0.79/0.22  0.84/0.49
HadCM3_4                                                                                                                                                                                                  0.60/0.72  0.74/1.26  0.86/0.39  0.74/0.37  0.75/0.37  0.66/0.13  0.94/0.60  0.95/1.16  0.66/0.15  0.94/0.27  ----/----  ----/----
HadGEM2-ES_4                                                                                                                                                                                              0.59/0.69  0.73/1.16  0.73/0.40  0.85/0.26  0.68/0.40  0.67/0.12  0.95/0.52  0.95/1.21  0.68/0.13  0.97/0.21  0.82/0.20  0.83/0.48
IPSL-CM5A-LR_4                                                                                                                                                                                            0.63/0.62  0.71/1.39  0.83/0.34  0.82/0.30  0.68/0.41  0.82/0.10  0.85/1.08  0.95/0.89  0.70/0.12  0.94/0.37  0.73/0.26  0.82/0.53
MIROC5_4                                                                                                                                                                                                  0.67/0.66  0.79/1.21  0.75/0.63  0.71/0.56  0.76/0.39  0.86/0.11  0.41/1.65  0.98/1.05  0.68/0.13  0.95/0.25  0.79/0.23  0.81/0.62
CanCM4_5                                                                                                                                                                                                  0.45/1.22  0.61/2.92  0.84/0.69  0.72/0.86  0.69/0.44  0.84/0.11  0.86/1.51  0.96/1.15  0.71/0.12  0.92/0.30  0.74/0.24  0.80/0.87
CCSM4_5                                                                                                                                                                                                   0.53/0.96  0.62/2.32  0.92/0.71  0.91/0.38  0.62/0.57  0.87/0.10  0.91/0.97  0.90/1.66  0.75/0.12  0.91/0.27  0.79/0.22  0.83/0.75
CESM1-WACCM_5                                                                                                                                                                                             0.43/1.49  0.60/2.83  0.90/0.60  0.86/0.58  0.69/0.41  0.76/0.12  0.85/1.13  0.76/1.94  0.69/0.12  0.88/0.34  0.78/0.22  0.77/0.89
CNRM-CM5_5                                                                                                                                                                                                0.70/0.59  0.82/0.99  0.89/0.58  0.79/0.41  0.82/0.30  0.66/0.12  0.90/0.71  0.96/1.24  0.61/0.13  0.97/0.20  0.82/0.21  0.85/0.50
CSIRO-Mk3-6-0_5                                                                                                                                                                                           0.36/0.94  0.62/1.54  0.45/0.74  0.49/0.55  0.68/0.50  0.70/0.12  0.70/1.28  0.96/1.19  0.60/0.16  0.95/0.25  0.76/0.31  0.73/0.69
EC-EARTH_5                                                                                                                                                                                                ----/----  ----/----  ----/----  ----/----  ----/----  ----/----  0.98/0.29  0.97/1.32  ----/----  0.98/0.19  ----/----  ----/----
GFDL-CM2p1_5                                                                                                                                                                                              0.52/1.15  0.64/2.16  0.79/1.35  0.57/1.52  0.67/0.63  0.78/0.12  0.94/0.84  0.96/0.99  0.69/0.17  0.92/0.27  0.77/0.38  0.80/0.87
GISS-E2-R_5                                                                                                                                                                                               0.71/0.54  0.78/1.10  0.93/0.27  0.86/0.30  0.76/0.36  0.80/0.10  0.88/0.80  0.98/0.94  0.53/0.14  0.96/0.25  0.79/0.22  0.86/0.46
HadCM3_5                                                                                                                                                                                                  0.50/0.82  0.62/1.40  0.88/0.38  0.71/0.45  0.78/0.34  0.76/0.11  0.80/1.10  0.96/1.35  0.67/0.15  0.95/0.25  ----/----  ----/----
IPSL-CM5A-LR_5                                                                                                                                                                                            0.65/0.57  0.59/1.47  0.84/0.31  0.76/0.37  0.57/0.48  0.79/0.10  0.89/0.79  0.96/0.95  0.64/0.13  0.95/0.32  0.73/0.25  0.81/0.52
CanCM4_6                                                                                                                                                                                                  0.42/1.01  0.66/1.48  0.75/0.83  0.76/0.51  0.62/0.58  0.84/0.09  0.80/1.14  0.92/1.41  0.70/0.11  0.94/0.27  0.73/0.24  0.78/0.70
CESM1-WACCM_6                                                                                                                                                                                             0.46/1.23  0.68/2.24  0.95/0.49  0.84/0.43  0.55/0.71  0.79/0.14  0.70/1.66  0.78/2.03  0.71/0.14  0.83/0.36  0.79/0.22  0.77/0.88
CNRM-CM5_6                                                                                                                                                                                                0.69/0.56  0.84/0.93  0.89/0.46  0.80/0.47  0.83/0.29  0.66/0.12  0.92/0.62  0.97/1.14  0.58/0.13  0.96/0.25  0.81/0.22  0.85/0.47
CSIRO-Mk3-6-0_6                                                                                                                                                                                           0.33/0.89  0.62/1.49  0.48/0.69  0.50/0.54  0.68/0.45  0.71/0.13  0.56/1.57  0.96/1.28  0.62/0.16  0.94/0.27  0.76/0.30  0.72/0.71
EC-EARTH_6                                                                                                                                                                                                0.33/0.76  0.21/1.81  0.83/0.37  0.79/0.33  0.74/0.37  0.72/0.11  0.90/0.73  0.98/0.95  0.56/0.14  0.98/0.17  0.78/0.25  0.81/0.54
GFDL-CM2p1_6                                                                                                                                                                                              0.55/1.23  0.70/2.46  0.82/1.02  0.52/1.59  0.70/0.44  0.79/0.12  0.95/0.66  0.97/0.75  0.69/0.15  0.94/0.22  0.76/0.38  0.82/0.82
HadCM3_6                                                                                                                                                                                                  0.49/0.79  0.61/1.56  0.87/0.35  0.77/0.37  0.74/0.36  0.46/0.16  0.90/0.72  0.96/1.21  0.65/0.14  0.96/0.22  ----/----  ----/----
CanCM4_7                                                                                                                                                                                                  0.60/1.06  0.62/2.21  0.83/0.45  0.62/0.77  0.62/0.58  0.88/0.09  0.72/1.48  0.96/1.29  0.74/0.11  0.94/0.24  0.72/0.25  0.79/0.78
CNRM-CM5_7                                                                                                                                                                                                0.60/0.64  0.68/1.27  0.88/0.48  0.79/0.51  0.82/0.30  0.58/0.13  0.86/0.84  0.97/1.09  0.56/0.13  0.96/0.23  0.81/0.21  0.82/0.53
CSIRO-Mk3-6-0_7                                                                                                                                                                                           0.49/0.78  0.62/1.38  0.53/0.56  0.44/0.56  0.77/0.40  0.81/0.10  0.69/1.27  0.94/1.50  0.61/0.15  0.96/0.24  0.76/0.29  0.75/0.66
EC-EARTH_7                                                                                                                                                                                                0.33/0.78  0.42/1.67  0.85/0.32  0.80/0.32  0.68/0.42  0.78/0.10  0.95/0.47  0.96/1.21  0.53/0.14  0.98/0.19  0.77/0.25  0.82/0.53
GFDL-CM2p1_7                                                                                                                                                                                              0.55/1.13  0.72/2.20  0.83/1.30  0.62/1.01  0.77/0.40  0.83/0.11  0.93/0.72  0.97/0.81  0.68/0.16  0.95/0.21  0.77/0.36  0.83/0.76
HadCM3_7                                                                                                                                                                                                  0.58/0.74  0.71/1.35  0.84/0.37  0.77/0.38  0.79/0.35  0.71/0.13  0.79/1.15  0.97/1.00  0.66/0.15  0.95/0.23  ----/----  ----/----
GISS-E2-H_8                                                                                                                                                                                               0.50/0.65  0.52/1.46  0.90/0.27  0.77/0.40  0.75/0.36  0.73/0.12  0.85/0.84  0.98/1.01  0.53/0.14  0.96/0.25  0.74/0.26  0.82/0.52
GISS-E2-R_8                                                                                                                                                                                               0.67/0.53  0.76/1.14  0.88/0.36  0.77/0.38  0.67/0.43  0.57/0.13  0.90/0.72  0.99/0.83  0.41/0.16  0.97/0.25  0.78/0.23  0.84/0.47
GISS-E2-H_9                                                                                                                                                                                               0.60/0.58  0.28/1.69  0.88/0.31  0.79/0.33  0.62/0.44  0.61/0.13  0.89/0.77  0.98/1.07  0.57/0.14  0.96/0.28  0.75/0.26  0.80/0.55
GISS-E2-R_9                                                                                                                                                                                               0.60/0.59  0.54/1.44  0.93/0.29  0.81/0.37  0.72/0.38  0.62/0.13  0.91/0.68  0.98/0.89  0.39/0.16  0.96/0.24  0.78/0.22  0.83/0.49
GISS-E2-H_10                                                                                                                                                                                              0.52/0.63  0.58/1.39  0.88/0.33  0.78/0.37  0.71/0.41  0.63/0.13  0.92/0.64  0.98/0.86  0.52/0.15  0.96/0.24  0.75/0.25  0.82/0.49
GISS-E2-R_10                                                                                                                                                                                              0.54/0.72  0.73/1.23  0.91/0.29  0.79/0.40  0.66/0.46  0.68/0.12  0.92/0.64  0.98/0.86  0.48/0.15  0.96/0.24  0.77/0.23  0.83/0.49
GISS-E2-H_11                                                                                                                                                                                              0.55/0.62  0.64/1.31  0.88/0.29  0.79/0.35  0.71/0.39  0.56/0.14  0.85/0.83  0.98/1.01  0.45/0.15  0.96/0.24  0.75/0.26  0.81/0.51
GISS-E2-R_11                                                                                                                                                                                              0.57/0.60  0.57/1.40  0.92/0.34  0.82/0.33  0.78/0.34  0.59/0.13  0.92/0.62  0.99/0.87  0.43/0.15  0.96/0.26  0.79/0.22  0.84/0.48
MRI-CGCM3_11                                                                                                                                                                                              0.53/0.68  0.82/1.08  0.85/0.31  0.84/0.28  0.76/0.35  0.63/0.13  0.91/0.79  0.97/0.94  0.53/0.14  0.94/0.29  0.80/0.23  0.83/0.47
CanCM4_12                                                                                                                                                                                                 0.52/1.03  0.78/1.74  0.81/0.71  0.73/0.82  0.68/0.51  0.82/0.10  0.82/1.42  0.93/1.27  0.72/0.11  0.94/0.26  0.73/0.24  0.80/0.75
CNRM-CM5_12                                                                                                                                                                                               0.70/0.55  0.72/1.19  0.89/0.49  0.77/0.44  0.77/0.34  0.74/0.11  0.92/0.67  0.96/1.22  0.62/0.12  0.95/0.28  0.81/0.21  0.84/0.51
CSIRO-Mk3-6-0_12                                                                                                                                                                                          0.53/0.67  0.73/1.20  0.56/0.53  0.48/0.55  0.72/0.40  0.78/0.11  0.75/1.20  0.94/1.33  0.62/0.15  0.95/0.24  0.75/0.32  0.76/0.61
EC-EARTH_12                                                                                                                                                                                               ----/----  ----/----  ----/----  ----/----  ----/----  ----/----  0.94/0.67  0.97/1.11  ----/----  0.97/0.20  0.77/0.25  ----/----
GFDL-CM2p1_12                                                                                                                                                                                             0.53/1.08  0.65/2.05  0.84/0.86  0.58/1.09  0.69/0.52  0.79/0.11  0.93/0.74  0.97/0.82  0.70/0.15  0.95/0.21  0.77/0.35  0.82/0.73
HadCM3_12                                                                                                                                                                                                 0.49/0.75  0.63/1.39  0.87/0.33  0.74/0.36  0.70/0.44  0.67/0.13  0.83/0.95  0.96/1.12  0.65/0.15  0.95/0.25  ----/----  ----/----
GISS-E2-H_13                                                                                                                                                                                              0.52/0.63  0.47/1.50  0.87/0.34  0.75/0.40  0.75/0.36  0.34/0.16  0.87/0.78  0.97/1.12  0.52/0.15  0.96/0.27  0.74/0.25  0.78/0.54
GISS-E2-R_13                                                                                                                                                                                              0.36/0.73  0.12/2.09  0.90/0.34  0.81/0.36  0.66/0.42  0.21/0.17  0.95/0.52  0.98/0.73  0.39/0.16  0.96/0.24  0.78/0.23  0.78/0.54
GISS-E2-H_14                                                                                                                                                                                              0.44/0.68  0.46/1.58  0.89/0.28  0.76/0.39  0.71/0.43  0.56/0.14  0.93/0.59  0.97/1.01  0.26/0.19  0.95/0.27  0.76/0.26  0.79/0.53
GISS-E2-R_14                                                                                                                                                                                              0.56/0.61  0.55/1.42  0.91/0.33  0.77/0.41  0.73/0.37  0.67/0.12  0.94/0.52  0.98/0.71  0.40/0.16  0.96/0.28  0.79/0.22  0.83/0.47
CCSM4_15                                                                                                                                                                                                  0.62/0.86  0.74/1.94  0.93/0.61  0.85/0.51  0.55/0.52  0.81/0.11  0.86/1.16  0.86/1.76  0.75/0.12  0.89/0.30  0.79/0.22  0.81/0.74
CSIRO-Mk3L-1-2_15                                                                                                                                                                                         0.36/0.78  0.52/1.61  0.70/0.45  0.82/0.32  0.71/0.44  0.83/0.09  0.79/1.12  0.97/0.79  0.66/0.11  0.94/0.29  0.78/0.22  0.79/0.57
GISS-E2-H_16                                                                                                                                                                                              0.50/0.65  0.66/1.28  0.88/0.29  0.76/0.39  0.64/0.58  0.46/0.15  0.88/0.75  0.97/0.93  0.37/0.17  0.96/0.24  0.75/0.25  0.79/0.52
GISS-E2-R_16                                                                                                                                                                                              0.62/0.57  0.53/1.46  0.90/0.33  0.79/0.39  0.60/0.50  0.45/0.15  0.82/0.96  0.98/0.93  0.46/0.16  0.96/0.23  0.78/0.22  0.80/0.54
GISS-E2-H_17                                                                                                                                                                                              0.58/0.60  0.49/1.53  0.88/0.36  0.73/0.48  0.76/0.37  0.71/0.12  0.89/0.72  0.97/0.97  0.39/0.16  0.96/0.28  0.75/0.26  0.80/0.53
GISS-E2-R_17                                                                                                                                                                                              0.68/0.55  0.76/1.11  0.91/0.30  0.78/0.40  0.80/0.32  0.59/0.13  0.85/0.89  0.98/0.94  0.51/0.14  0.96/0.27  0.79/0.22  0.84/0.48
GISS-E2-H_18                                                                                                                                                                                              0.58/0.60  0.65/1.31  0.87/0.35  0.73/0.42  0.74/0.37  0.64/0.13  0.89/0.71  0.97/1.16  0.51/0.15  0.96/0.26  0.75/0.25  0.81/0.52
GISS-E2-R_18                                                                                                                                                                                              0.71/0.52  0.80/1.02  0.88/0.35  0.79/0.39  0.67/0.45  0.56/0.14  0.89/0.75  0.98/0.83  0.45/0.16  0.95/0.28  0.77/0.23  0.83/0.47
GISS-E2-H_19                                                                                                                                                                                              0.42/0.69  0.52/1.46  0.87/0.35  0.79/0.39  0.77/0.34  0.52/0.14  0.88/0.75  0.98/1.07  0.52/0.15  0.96/0.25  0.75/0.26  0.80/0.53
GISS-E2-R_19                                                                                                                                                                                              0.38/0.71  0.40/1.61  0.91/0.33  0.85/0.35  0.66/0.43  0.50/0.14  0.91/0.67  0.98/0.85  0.41/0.16  0.96/0.25  0.78/0.22  0.80/0.52
MRI-CGCM3_19                                                                                                                                                                                              0.62/0.58  0.80/1.03  0.84/0.33  0.87/0.29  0.76/0.35  0.73/0.11  0.91/0.82  0.97/1.04  0.50/0.15  0.93/0.31  0.81/0.23  0.84/0.48

Observations Used

Created Sat Nov 2 23:22:29 MDT 2019

CVDP Version 5.1.1