NCAR logo

b.e15.B1850.f09_g16.pi_control.36_70_99
and
b.e15.B1850G.f09_g16.pi_control.28_70_99

Set 9



TSA modified control Comparison
Model b.e15.B1850.f09_g16.pi_control.36_70_99 b.e15.B1850G.f09_g16.pi_control.28_70_99 Summary
RMSE 2.50 2.52 -0.02
RMSE % Area 8.07 7.48 +0.59
ANN Bias -0.58 -0.72 -0.14
ANN Bias % Area 12.07 10.78 +1.29
DJF Bias -0.80 -0.81 -0.01
DJF Bias % Area 12.74 9.26 +3.48
MAM Bias -1.04 -1.13 -0.09
MAM Bias % Area 11.49 12.88 -1.39
JJA Bias -0.41 -0.69 -0.28
JJA Bias % Area 16.56 12.08 +4.48
SON Bias -0.22 -0.40 -0.18
SON Bias % Area 11.47 11.48 -0.01
% Area with r>0.9 83.29 84.19 --0.90


PREC modified control Comparison
Model b.e15.B1850.f09_g16.pi_control.36_70_99 b.e15.B1850G.f09_g16.pi_control.28_70_99 Summary
RMSE 1.26 1.27 -0.01
RMSE % Area 2.05 1.85 +0.20
ANN Bias 0.13 0.20 -0.07
ANN Bias % Area 5.37 4.01 +1.36
DJF Bias 0.25 0.28 -0.03
DJF Bias % Area 2.18 2.84 -0.66
MAM Bias 0.19 0.24 -0.05
MAM Bias % Area 5.21 3.33 +1.88
JJA Bias 0.02 0.12 -0.10
JJA Bias % Area 7.76 6.41 +1.35
SON Bias 0.07 0.15 -0.08
SON Bias % Area 3.97 4.51 -0.54
% Area with r>0.9 44.93 47.23 --2.30


ASA modified control Comparison
Model b.e15.B1850.f09_g16.pi_control.36_70_99 b.e15.B1850G.f09_g16.pi_control.28_70_99 Summary
RMSE 5.82 5.67 +0.15
RMSE % Area 13.48 16.99 -3.51
ANN Bias 0.18 -0.18 0.00
ANN Bias % Area 11.58 11.75 -0.17
DJF Bias 3.43 2.65 +0.78
DJF Bias % Area 10.79 15.75 -4.96
MAM Bias 1.95 1.44 +0.51
MAM Bias % Area 8.16 13.29 -5.13
JJA Bias 0.34 0.20 +0.14
JJA Bias % Area 10.18 9.02 +1.16
SON Bias -1.53 -1.81 -0.28
SON Bias % Area 12.01 6.55 +5.46
% Area with r>0.9 19.87 18.89 +0.98


LHEAT modified control Comparison
Model b.e15.B1850.f09_g16.pi_control.36_70_99 b.e15.B1850G.f09_g16.pi_control.28_70_99 Summary
RMSE 16.76 17.26 -0.50
RMSE % Area 10.15 5.76 +4.39
ANN Bias -0.16 2.75 -2.59
ANN Bias % Area 12.85 9.85 +3.00
DJF Bias 1.44 3.84 -2.40
DJF Bias % Area 9.12 7.36 +1.76
MAM Bias -0.09 3.04 -2.95
MAM Bias % Area 13.67 11.26 +2.41
JJA Bias -0.99 2.82 -1.83
JJA Bias % Area 18.12 14.72 +3.40
SON Bias -1.24 1.06 +0.18
SON Bias % Area 12.80 7.19 +5.61
% Area with r>0.9 61.75 60.98 +0.77


GPP modified control Comparison
Model b.e15.B1850.f09_g16.pi_control.36_70_99 b.e15.B1850G.f09_g16.pi_control.28_70_99 Summary
RMSE 1.89 1.82 +0.07
RMSE % Area 8.54 11.35 -2.81
ANN Bias -0.47 0.09 +0.38
ANN Bias % Area 10.89 10.85 +0.04
DJF Bias -0.38 0.03 +0.35
DJF Bias % Area 3.75 8.09 -4.34
MAM Bias -0.40 0.21 +0.19
MAM Bias % Area 12.56 10.31 +2.25
JJA Bias -0.66 0.12 +0.54
JJA Bias % Area 13.33 14.74 -1.41
SON Bias -0.45 -0.01 +0.44
SON Bias % Area 8.67 8.24 +0.43
% Area with r>0.9 38.08 40.56 --2.48

TLAI modified control Comparison
Model b.e15.B1850.f09_g16.pi_control.36_70_99 b.e15.B1850G.f09_g16.pi_control.28_70_99 Summary
RMSE 1.32 1.62 -0.30
RMSE % Area 23.72 10.92 +12.80
ANN Bias 0.04 0.76 -0.72
ANN Bias % Area 30.42 20.67 +9.75
DJF Bias 0.13 0.81 -0.68
DJF Bias % Area 29.26 15.61 +13.65
MAM Bias -0.03 0.64 -0.61
MAM Bias % Area 27.05 17.07 +9.98
JJA Bias -0.08 0.69 -0.61
JJA Bias % Area 27.57 24.61 +2.96
SON Bias 0.14 0.87 -0.73
SON Bias % Area 31.84 17.64 +14.20
% Area with r>0.9 5.81 6.84 --1.03