NCAR logo

b.e15.B1850.f09_g16.pi_control.39_10_19
and
b.e15.B1850.f09_g16.pi_control.36_10_19

Set 9



TSA modified control Comparison
Model b.e15.B1850.f09_g16.pi_control.39_10_19 b.e15.B1850.f09_g16.pi_control.36_10_19 Summary
RMSE 2.35 2.54 -0.19
RMSE % Area 29.17 15.34 +13.83
ANN Bias -0.57 -0.33 +0.24
ANN Bias % Area 26.12 18.99 +7.13
DJF Bias -0.87 -0.42 +0.45
DJF Bias % Area 24.49 17.20 +7.29
MAM Bias -0.82 -0.76 +0.06
MAM Bias % Area 29.09 20.16 +8.93
JJA Bias -0.69 -0.28 +0.41
JJA Bias % Area 25.91 22.64 +3.27
SON Bias -0.13 -0.03 +0.10
SON Bias % Area 20.71 13.82 +6.89
% Area with r>0.9 83.91 83.36 +0.55


PREC modified control Comparison
Model b.e15.B1850.f09_g16.pi_control.39_10_19 b.e15.B1850.f09_g16.pi_control.36_10_19 Summary
RMSE 1.31 1.28 +0.03
RMSE % Area 2.90 5.80 -2.90
ANN Bias 0.22 0.14 +0.08
ANN Bias % Area 4.93 6.40 -1.47
DJF Bias 0.29 0.25 +0.04
DJF Bias % Area 5.26 2.53 +2.73
MAM Bias 0.26 0.19 +0.07
MAM Bias % Area 2.96 4.67 -1.71
JJA Bias 0.16 0.02 +0.14
JJA Bias % Area 6.84 6.43 +0.41
SON Bias 0.16 0.10 +0.06
SON Bias % Area 5.03 2.91 +2.12
% Area with r>0.9 41.48 38.80 +2.68


ASA modified control Comparison
Model b.e15.B1850.f09_g16.pi_control.39_10_19 b.e15.B1850.f09_g16.pi_control.36_10_19 Summary
RMSE 4.97 5.70 -0.73
RMSE % Area 33.43 18.90 +14.53
ANN Bias -0.76 -0.20 +0.56
ANN Bias % Area 30.71 20.68 +10.03
DJF Bias 1.82 2.79 -0.97
DJF Bias % Area 29.25 21.80 +7.45
MAM Bias 0.35 1.41 -1.06
MAM Bias % Area 28.13 21.28 +6.85
JJA Bias 0.06 0.16 -0.10
JJA Bias % Area 25.38 22.18 +3.20
SON Bias -2.27 -1.80 +0.47
SON Bias % Area 27.68 16.81 +10.87
% Area with r>0.9 22.94 20.52 +2.42


LHEAT modified control Comparison
Model b.e15.B1850.f09_g16.pi_control.39_10_19 b.e15.B1850.f09_g16.pi_control.36_10_19 Summary
RMSE 15.30 16.82 -1.52
RMSE % Area 21.68 9.50 +12.18
ANN Bias 3.45 0.78 +2.67
ANN Bias % Area 27.68 11.15 +16.53
DJF Bias 4.77 2.11 +2.66
DJF Bias % Area 16.82 10.38 +6.44
MAM Bias 4.04 0.80 +3.24
MAM Bias % Area 24.56 13.86 +10.70
JJA Bias 3.36 0.54 +2.82
JJA Bias % Area 27.14 16.33 +10.81
SON Bias 1.39 -0.49 +0.90
SON Bias % Area 21.32 10.31 +11.01
% Area with r>0.9 64.88 61.07 +3.81

FPSN modified control Comparison
Model b.e15.B1850.f09_g16.pi_control.39_10_19 b.e15.B1850.f09_g16.pi_control.36_10_19 Summary
RMSE 1.47 1.82 -0.35
RMSE % Area 21.84 8.17 +13.67
ANN Bias 0.42 -0.31 +0.11
ANN Bias % Area 29.85 12.69 +17.16
DJF Bias 0.30 -0.28 +0.02
DJF Bias % Area 23.00 8.52 +14.48
MAM Bias 0.52 -0.24 +0.28
MAM Bias % Area 27.03 13.57 +13.46
JJA Bias 0.74 -0.41 +0.33
JJA Bias % Area 30.13 19.78 +10.35
SON Bias 0.09 -0.33 -0.24
SON Bias % Area 28.45 9.47 +18.98
% Area with r>0.9 60.41 37.58 +22.83