NCAR logo

b40.abrupt4xco2.1deg.001.clm2.h0.
and
b40.1850.track1.1deg.006.clm2.h0.

Set 9



TSA modified control Comparison
Model b40.abrupt4xco2.1deg.001.clm2.h0. b40.1850.track1.1deg.006.clm2.h0. Summary
RMSE 4.42 2.54 +1.88
RMSE % Area 21.24 70.11 -48.87
ANN Bias 3.78 -0.81 +2.97
ANN Bias % Area 23.50 75.19 -51.69
DJF Bias 3.32 -1.46 +1.86
DJF Bias % Area 38.43 60.26 -21.83
MAM Bias 3.42 -0.84 +2.58
MAM Bias % Area 27.47 71.22 -43.75
JJA Bias 4.62 -0.06 +4.56
JJA Bias % Area 17.35 81.35 -64.00
SON Bias 3.60 -1.05 +2.55
SON Bias % Area 24.78 73.92 -49.14
% Area with r>0.9 81.71 83.06 --1.35


PREC modified control Comparison
Model b40.abrupt4xco2.1deg.001.clm2.h0. b40.1850.track1.1deg.006.clm2.h0. Summary
RMSE 1.58 1.30 +0.28
RMSE % Area 2.84 21.39 -18.55
ANN Bias 0.62 0.43 +0.19
ANN Bias % Area 8.72 30.38 -21.66
DJF Bias 0.81 0.58 +0.23
DJF Bias % Area 5.04 30.76 -25.72
MAM Bias 0.61 0.46 +0.15
MAM Bias % Area 5.84 21.70 -15.86
JJA Bias 0.28 0.15 +0.13
JJA Bias % Area 8.68 26.75 -18.07
SON Bias 0.78 0.51 +0.27
SON Bias % Area 8.02 32.92 -24.90
% Area with r>0.9 32.28 38.41 --6.13


ASA modified control Comparison
Model b40.abrupt4xco2.1deg.001.clm2.h0. b40.1850.track1.1deg.006.clm2.h0. Summary
RMSE 5.17 5.11 +0.06
RMSE % Area 17.20 22.39 -5.19
ANN Bias -1.87 -0.36 +1.51
ANN Bias % Area 13.35 28.28 -14.93
DJF Bias -0.31 2.21 -1.90
DJF Bias % Area 19.38 24.22 -4.84
MAM Bias -1.34 0.41 +0.93
MAM Bias % Area 14.98 24.27 -9.29
JJA Bias 0.00 0.74 -0.74
JJA Bias % Area 13.70 5.10 +8.60
SON Bias -2.52 -0.71 +1.81
SON Bias % Area 9.75 28.29 -18.54
% Area with r>0.9 17.09 23.71 --6.62


LHEAT modified control Comparison
Model b40.abrupt4xco2.1deg.001.clm2.h0. b40.1850.track1.1deg.006.clm2.h0. Summary
RMSE 20.97 21.77 -0.80
RMSE % Area 20.45 13.58 +6.87
ANN Bias 12.18 14.08 -1.90
ANN Bias % Area 22.51 14.02 +8.49
DJF Bias 13.29 14.33 -1.04
DJF Bias % Area 19.67 16.00 +3.67
MAM Bias 13.50 15.04 -1.54
MAM Bias % Area 22.03 16.90 +5.13
JJA Bias 10.15 13.54 -3.39
JJA Bias % Area 34.58 17.02 +17.56
SON Bias 11.49 13.14 -1.65
SON Bias % Area 20.85 17.58 +3.27
% Area with r>0.9 57.32 60.09 --2.77


GPP modified control Comparison
Model b40.abrupt4xco2.1deg.001.clm2.h0. b40.1850.track1.1deg.006.clm2.h0. Summary
RMSE 2.15 1.40 +0.75
RMSE % Area 1.47 30.42 -28.95
ANN Bias 1.18 0.05 +1.13
ANN Bias % Area 4.99 35.95 -30.96
DJF Bias 1.19 0.28 +0.91
DJF Bias % Area 4.46 27.83 -23.37
MAM Bias 1.39 0.21 +1.18
MAM Bias % Area 4.78 37.85 -33.07
JJA Bias 0.90 -0.47 +0.43
JJA Bias % Area 12.24 33.56 -21.32
SON Bias 1.23 0.18 +1.05
SON Bias % Area 3.96 34.06 -30.10
% Area with r>0.9 37.98 43.85 --5.87

TLAI modified control Comparison
Model b40.abrupt4xco2.1deg.001.clm2.h0. b40.1850.track1.1deg.006.clm2.h0. Summary
RMSE 1.89 1.15 +0.74
RMSE % Area 2.29 42.76 -40.47
ANN Bias 1.52 0.67 +0.85
ANN Bias % Area 8.59 54.13 -45.54
DJF Bias 1.57 0.73 +0.84
DJF Bias % Area 6.18 54.24 -48.06
MAM Bias 1.40 0.60 +0.80
MAM Bias % Area 9.49 49.75 -40.26
JJA Bias 1.45 0.55 +0.90
JJA Bias % Area 12.67 48.14 -35.47
SON Bias 1.63 0.78 +0.85
SON Bias % Area 7.56 52.69 -45.13
% Area with r>0.9 6.32 7.15 --0.83