b.e23_alpha17f.BLTHIST.ne30_t232.092_1957_1976
and
b.e21.BHISTcmip6.f09_g17.LE2-1001.001.1995-2014
Set 9
| TSA
| modified
| control
| Comparison
|
| Model
| b.e23_alpha17f.BLTHIST.ne30_t232.092_1957_1976
| b.e21.BHISTcmip6.f09_g17.LE2-1001.001.1995-2014
| Summary
|
| RMSE
| 4.75
| 2.99
| +1.76
|
| RMSE 0X0P+0rea
| 36.84
| 17.95
| +18.89
|
| ANN Bias
| 1.44
| 2.01
| -0.57
|
| ANN Bias 0X0P+0rea
| 40.60
| 18.67
| +21.93
|
| DJF Bias
| 0.79
| 2.21
| -1.42
|
| DJF Bias 0X0P+0rea
| 42.08
| 18.62
| +23.46
|
| MAM Bias
| 1.20
| 1.73
| -0.53
|
| MAM Bias 0X0P+0rea
| 32.93
| 14.49
| +18.44
|
| JJA Bias
| 1.56
| 1.74
| -0.18
|
| JJA Bias 0X0P+0rea
| 34.98
| 23.11
| +11.87
|
| SON Bias
| 2.02
| 2.21
| -0.19
|
| SON Bias 0X0P+0rea
| 33.14
| 31.07
| +2.07
|
| 0X0P+0rea with r>0.9
| 87.08
| 83.66
| +3.42
|
| PREC
| modified
| control
| Comparison
|
| Model
| b.e23_alpha17f.BLTHIST.ne30_t232.092_1957_1976
| b.e21.BHISTcmip6.f09_g17.LE2-1001.001.1995-2014
| Summary
|
| RMSE
| 0.63
| 1.15
| -0.52
|
| RMSE 0X0P+0rea
| 7.79
| 15.57
| -7.78
|
| ANN Bias
| 0.39
| 0.24
| +0.15
|
| ANN Bias 0X0P+0rea
| 13.26
| 33.09
| -19.83
|
| DJF Bias
| 0.38
| 0.44
| -0.06
|
| DJF Bias 0X0P+0rea
| 11.31
| 17.15
| -5.84
|
| MAM Bias
| 0.46
| 0.34
| +0.12
|
| MAM Bias 0X0P+0rea
| 13.06
| 18.79
| -5.73
|
| JJA Bias
| 0.36
| 0.05
| +0.31
|
| JJA Bias 0X0P+0rea
| 19.30
| 26.81
| -7.51
|
| SON Bias
| 0.33
| 0.15
| +0.18
|
| SON Bias 0X0P+0rea
| 11.40
| 24.55
| -13.15
|
| 0X0P+0rea with r>0.9
| 48.61
| 44.08
| +4.53
|
| ASA
| modified
| control
| Comparison
|
| Model
| b.e23_alpha17f.BLTHIST.ne30_t232.092_1957_1976
| b.e21.BHISTcmip6.f09_g17.LE2-1001.001.1995-2014
| Summary
|
| RMSE
| 13.64
| 4.71
| +8.93
|
| RMSE 0X0P+0rea
| 31.99
| 45.15
| -13.16
|
| ANN Bias
| 0.62
| -0.07
| +0.55
|
| ANN Bias 0X0P+0rea
| 34.42
| 48.93
| -14.51
|
| DJF Bias
| 2.49
| 2.26
| +0.23
|
| DJF Bias 0X0P+0rea
| 31.64
| 48.20
| -16.56
|
| MAM Bias
| 0.85
| 0.58
| +0.27
|
| MAM Bias 0X0P+0rea
| 34.94
| 45.23
| -10.29
|
| JJA Bias
| 2.18
| 1.06
| +1.12
|
| JJA Bias 0X0P+0rea
| 31.09
| 54.76
| -23.67
|
| SON Bias
| -0.60
| -1.37
| -0.77
|
| SON Bias 0X0P+0rea
| 30.68
| 50.56
| -19.88
|
| 0X0P+0rea with r>0.9
| 20.85
| 21.53
| --0.68
|
| LHEAT
| modified
| control
| Comparison
|
| Model
| b.e23_alpha17f.BLTHIST.ne30_t232.092_1957_1976
| b.e21.BHISTcmip6.f09_g17.LE2-1001.001.1995-2014
| Summary
|
| RMSE
| 45.48
| 15.20
| +30.28
|
| RMSE 0X0P+0rea
| 15.46
| 22.63
| -7.17
|
| ANN Bias
| 6.73
| 4.36
| +2.37
|
| ANN Bias 0X0P+0rea
| 18.17
| 29.60
| -11.43
|
| DJF Bias
| 5.03
| 3.99
| +1.04
|
| DJF Bias 0X0P+0rea
| 13.51
| 19.11
| -5.60
|
| MAM Bias
| 6.94
| 6.05
| +0.89
|
| MAM Bias 0X0P+0rea
| 23.02
| 24.65
| -1.63
|
| JJA Bias
| 9.39
| 4.48
| +4.91
|
| JJA Bias 0X0P+0rea
| 22.82
| 37.85
| -15.03
|
| SON Bias
| 5.23
| 2.64
| +2.59
|
| SON Bias 0X0P+0rea
| 15.32
| 26.80
| -11.48
|
| 0X0P+0rea with r>0.9
| 58.63
| 56.22
| +2.41
|
| GPP
| modified
| control
| Comparison
|
| Model
| b.e23_alpha17f.BLTHIST.ne30_t232.092_1957_1976
| b.e21.BHISTcmip6.f09_g17.LE2-1001.001.1995-2014
| Summary
|
| RMSE
| 3.14
| 1.51
| +1.63
|
| RMSE 0X0P+0rea
| 5.55
| 14.45
| -8.90
|
| ANN Bias
| 0.03
| -0.03
| 0.00
|
| ANN Bias 0X0P+0rea
| 8.39
| 15.23
| -6.84
|
| DJF Bias
| -0.19
| -0.03
| +0.16
|
| DJF Bias 0X0P+0rea
| 9.24
| 8.56
| +0.68
|
| MAM Bias
| 0.06
| 0.07
| -0.01
|
| MAM Bias 0X0P+0rea
| 12.49
| 13.44
| -0.95
|
| JJA Bias
| 0.57
| 0.05
| +0.52
|
| JJA Bias 0X0P+0rea
| 12.94
| 22.64
| -9.70
|
| SON Bias
| -0.33
| -0.24
| +0.09
|
| SON Bias 0X0P+0rea
| 6.79
| 11.88
| -5.09
|
| 0X0P+0rea with r>0.9
| 37.33
| 37.09
| +0.24
|
| TLAI
| modified
| control
| Comparison
|
| Model
| b.e23_alpha17f.BLTHIST.ne30_t232.092_1957_1976
| b.e21.BHISTcmip6.f09_g17.LE2-1001.001.1995-2014
| Summary
|
| RMSE
| 0.47
| 0.92
| -0.45
|
| RMSE 0X0P+0rea
| 11.18
| 16.53
| -5.35
|
| ANN Bias
| 0.33
| 0.19
| +0.14
|
| ANN Bias 0X0P+0rea
| 22.57
| 28.41
| -5.84
|
| DJF Bias
| 0.23
| 0.14
| +0.09
|
| DJF Bias 0X0P+0rea
| 19.63
| 24.64
| -5.01
|
| MAM Bias
| 0.15
| 0.05
| +0.10
|
| MAM Bias 0X0P+0rea
| 25.04
| 24.77
| +0.27
|
| JJA Bias
| 0.68
| 0.31
| +0.37
|
| JJA Bias 0X0P+0rea
| 23.13
| 33.44
| -10.31
|
| SON Bias
| 0.25
| 0.25
| 0.00
|
| SON Bias 0X0P+0rea
| 26.53
| 24.68
| +1.85
|
| 0X0P+0rea with r>0.9
| 17.28
| 7.91
| +9.37
|