DIAG SET 1: DJF MEANS NORTHERN EXTRATROPICS (90N-20N) TEST CASE: b.e21.BWHIST.f09_g17.CMIP6-historical-WACCM.002 (yrs 1971-2000) CONTROL CASE: OBS data Variable b.e21.BWHIST.f09_g17.CMIP6-historical-WACCM.002 OBS data b.e21.BWHIST.f09_g17.CMIP6-historical-WACCM.002 RMSE -OBS data RESTOM -111.627 -999.000 -999.000 -999.000 RESSURF -80.176 -999.000 -999.000 -999.000 RESTOA_CERES-EBAF-111.656 -110.493 -1.162 7.269 RESTOA_ERBE -111.656 -105.482 -6.174 8.810 SOLIN_CERES-EBAF 165.204 164.903 0.302 0.749 SOLIN_CERES 165.204 167.165 -1.961 2.709 CLDTOT_ISCCP 72.440 67.029 5.411 13.582 CLDTOT_CLOUDSAT 72.440 64.522 7.918 14.283 FLDS_ISCCP 277.020 278.873 -1.853 16.998 FLNS_ISCCP 56.779 51.100 5.679 12.801 FLUT_CERES-EBAF 217.512 216.747 0.765 4.829 FLUT_CERES 217.512 216.203 1.309 5.049 FLUT_ERBE 217.512 210.878 6.634 8.835 FLUTC_CERES-EBAF 236.800 239.460 -2.660 5.766 FLUTC_CERES 236.800 241.228 -4.428 10.516 FLUTC_ERBE 236.800 235.515 1.286 9.966 FLNT_CAM 217.478 -999.000 -999.000 -999.000 FSDS_ISCCP 86.519 84.595 1.924 12.191 FSNS_ISCCP 69.671 69.084 0.588 9.942 FSNS_LARYEA 69.671 61.648 8.023 26.424 FSNTOA_CERES-EBAF105.856 106.252 -0.397 8.885 FSNTOA_CERES 105.856 108.801 -2.945 10.230 FSNTOA_ERBE 105.856 105.396 0.460 9.572 FSNTOAC_CERES-EBAF129.163 129.200 -0.037 6.061 FSNTOAC_CERES 129.163 135.158 -5.995 10.578 FSNTOAC_ERBE 129.163 131.992 -2.829 9.582 FSNT_CAM 105.851 -999.000 -999.000 -999.000 LHFLX_JRA25 69.207 69.138 0.070 24.574 LHFLX_ERA40 69.207 66.243 2.965 25.699 LHFLX_WHOI 69.207 109.110 -39.903 46.143 LWCF_CERES-EBAF 19.289 22.713 -3.424 5.843 LWCF_CERES 19.289 24.061 -4.772 10.342 LWCF_ERBE 19.289 24.538 -5.250 11.035 PRECT_GPCP 2.210 2.099 0.111 0.686 PREH2O_NVAP 11.295 11.613 -0.319 2.130 PREH2O_AIRS 11.295 8.740 2.554 3.021 PREH2O_JRA25 11.295 8.740 2.554 3.021 PREH2O_ERAI 11.295 10.840 0.454 1.253 PREH2O_ERA40 11.295 11.494 -0.199 1.211 PSL_JRA25 1016.679 1016.119 0.560 1.618 PSL_ERAI 1016.679 1016.229 0.450 1.671 PSL_MERRA 1016.679 1015.526 1.153 2.432 SHFLX_JRA25 23.861 16.299 7.562 17.768 SHFLX_LARYEA 23.861 30.830 -6.969 20.012 STRESS_MAG_ERS 0.079 0.073 0.006 0.023 STRESS_MAG_MERRA 0.079 0.079 0.001 0.022 STRESS_MAG_LARYEA 0.079 0.085 -0.005 0.021 STRESS_MAG_JRA25 0.079 0.102 -0.022 0.032 SWCF_CERES-EBAF -23.307 -22.948 -0.359 7.895 SWCF_CERES -23.307 -25.991 2.684 12.092 SWCF_ERBE -23.307 -26.198 2.891 12.084 AODVIS 0.119 -999.000 -999.000 -999.000 AODDUST 0.016 -999.000 -999.000 -999.000 SST_HADISST 16.220 15.889 0.331 1.294 SST_HADISST_PI 16.205 15.606 0.599 1.442 SST_HADISST_PD 16.178 16.045 0.134 1.303 TREFHT_LEGATES 274.178 274.285 -0.108 3.654 TREFHT_JRA25 274.178 275.012 -0.835 1.612 TS_MERRA 275.240 274.244 0.996 3.003 TS_NCEP 275.240 274.169 1.071 2.819 TS_LAND_NCEP 266.863 265.822 1.040 2.849 U_200_JRA25 25.992 25.608 0.384 2.144 U_200_MERRA 25.992 25.649 0.342 2.401 Z3_500_JRA25 54.790 54.944 -0.154 0.169 Z3_500_MERRA 54.790 54.884 -0.094 0.190