ctsm51_ctsm51d160_1deg_CRUJRA_FLDS_ABCDE_blk_A5BCD_1850AD_471_480
and
ctsm51_ctsm51d160_1deg_GSWP3V1_ABCDE_blk_A5BCD_1850AD_311_320
Set 9
| TSA
| modified
| control
| Comparison
|
| Model
| ctsm51_ctsm51d160_1deg_CRUJRA_FLDS_ABCDE_blk_A5BCD_1850AD_471_480
| ctsm51_ctsm51d160_1deg_GSWP3V1_ABCDE_blk_A5BCD_1850AD_311_320
| Summary
|
| RMSE
| 1.74
| 1.46
| +0.28
|
| RMSE 0X0P+0rea
| 13.87
| 36.60
| -22.73
|
| ANN Bias
| -1.00
| -0.12
| +0.88
|
| ANN Bias 0X0P+0rea
| 23.55
| 45.74
| -22.19
|
| DJF Bias
| -1.63
| -0.63
| +1.00
|
| DJF Bias 0X0P+0rea
| 19.43
| 33.68
| -14.25
|
| MAM Bias
| -1.08
| -0.13
| +0.95
|
| MAM Bias 0X0P+0rea
| 22.32
| 38.17
| -15.85
|
| JJA Bias
| -0.60
| 0.23
| +0.37
|
| JJA Bias 0X0P+0rea
| 25.68
| 38.34
| -12.66
|
| SON Bias
| -0.85
| -0.12
| +0.73
|
| SON Bias 0X0P+0rea
| 23.51
| 31.01
| -7.50
|
| 0X0P+0rea with r>0.9
| 89.44
| 93.49
| --4.05
|
| PREC
| modified
| control
| Comparison
|
| Model
| ctsm51_ctsm51d160_1deg_CRUJRA_FLDS_ABCDE_blk_A5BCD_1850AD_471_480
| ctsm51_ctsm51d160_1deg_GSWP3V1_ABCDE_blk_A5BCD_1850AD_311_320
| Summary
|
| RMSE
| 0.48
| 0.61
| -0.13
|
| RMSE 0X0P+0rea
| 8.49
| 2.94
| +5.55
|
| ANN Bias
| -0.02
| 0.02
| 0.00
|
| ANN Bias 0X0P+0rea
| 14.05
| 5.62
| +8.43
|
| DJF Bias
| -0.01
| 0.05
| -0.04
|
| DJF Bias 0X0P+0rea
| 11.88
| 3.55
| +8.33
|
| MAM Bias
| -0.02
| 0.01
| +0.01
|
| MAM Bias 0X0P+0rea
| 10.87
| 3.91
| +6.96
|
| JJA Bias
| -0.01
| 0.02
| -0.01
|
| JJA Bias 0X0P+0rea
| 8.61
| 5.14
| +3.47
|
| SON Bias
| -0.05
| -0.01
| +0.04
|
| SON Bias 0X0P+0rea
| 9.23
| 3.43
| +5.80
|
| 0X0P+0rea with r>0.9
| 70.15
| 56.68
| +13.47
|
| ASA
| modified
| control
| Comparison
|
| Model
| ctsm51_ctsm51d160_1deg_CRUJRA_FLDS_ABCDE_blk_A5BCD_1850AD_471_480
| ctsm51_ctsm51d160_1deg_GSWP3V1_ABCDE_blk_A5BCD_1850AD_311_320
| Summary
|
| RMSE
| 5.62
| 5.05
| +0.57
|
| RMSE 0X0P+0rea
| 14.03
| 53.88
| -39.85
|
| ANN Bias
| 1.54
| 0.76
| +0.78
|
| ANN Bias 0X0P+0rea
| 16.06
| 48.42
| -32.36
|
| DJF Bias
| 4.53
| 4.06
| +0.47
|
| DJF Bias 0X0P+0rea
| 13.95
| 42.18
| -28.23
|
| MAM Bias
| 2.50
| 1.64
| +0.86
|
| MAM Bias 0X0P+0rea
| 12.78
| 47.77
| -34.99
|
| JJA Bias
| 3.01
| 2.25
| +0.76
|
| JJA Bias 0X0P+0rea
| 12.16
| 53.64
| -41.48
|
| SON Bias
| 0.17
| -0.18
| -0.01
|
| SON Bias 0X0P+0rea
| 8.15
| 47.58
| -39.43
|
| 0X0P+0rea with r>0.9
| 21.39
| 24.55
| --3.16
|
| LHEAT
| modified
| control
| Comparison
|
| Model
| ctsm51_ctsm51d160_1deg_CRUJRA_FLDS_ABCDE_blk_A5BCD_1850AD_471_480
| ctsm51_ctsm51d160_1deg_GSWP3V1_ABCDE_blk_A5BCD_1850AD_311_320
| Summary
|
| RMSE
| 13.32
| 13.83
| -0.51
|
| RMSE 0X0P+0rea
| 18.34
| 14.23
| +4.11
|
| ANN Bias
| 1.44
| 0.35
| +1.09
|
| ANN Bias 0X0P+0rea
| 17.23
| 14.68
| +2.55
|
| DJF Bias
| 0.53
| -0.10
| +0.43
|
| DJF Bias 0X0P+0rea
| 15.01
| 11.70
| +3.31
|
| MAM Bias
| 0.44
| -1.67
| -1.23
|
| MAM Bias 0X0P+0rea
| 20.53
| 17.24
| +3.29
|
| JJA Bias
| 3.60
| 3.38
| +0.22
|
| JJA Bias 0X0P+0rea
| 28.00
| 19.76
| +8.24
|
| SON Bias
| 0.84
| -0.57
| +0.27
|
| SON Bias 0X0P+0rea
| 18.14
| 16.03
| +2.11
|
| 0X0P+0rea with r>0.9
| 61.19
| 60.73
| +0.46
|
| GPP
| modified
| control
| Comparison
|
| Model
| ctsm51_ctsm51d160_1deg_CRUJRA_FLDS_ABCDE_blk_A5BCD_1850AD_471_480
| ctsm51_ctsm51d160_1deg_GSWP3V1_ABCDE_blk_A5BCD_1850AD_311_320
| Summary
|
| RMSE
| 1.42
| 1.47
| -0.05
|
| RMSE 0X0P+0rea
| 12.73
| 10.00
| +2.73
|
| ANN Bias
| 0.39
| -0.29
| +0.10
|
| ANN Bias 0X0P+0rea
| 17.98
| 10.50
| +7.48
|
| DJF Bias
| 0.12
| -0.39
| -0.27
|
| DJF Bias 0X0P+0rea
| 12.81
| 8.68
| +4.13
|
| MAM Bias
| 0.27
| -0.31
| -0.04
|
| MAM Bias 0X0P+0rea
| 16.59
| 10.21
| +6.38
|
| JJA Bias
| 1.05
| -0.03
| +1.02
|
| JJA Bias 0X0P+0rea
| 23.81
| 24.06
| -0.25
|
| SON Bias
| 0.12
| -0.47
| -0.35
|
| SON Bias 0X0P+0rea
| 16.96
| 7.69
| +9.27
|
| 0X0P+0rea with r>0.9
| 47.43
| 42.41
| +5.02
|
| TLAI
| modified
| control
| Comparison
|
| Model
| ctsm51_ctsm51d160_1deg_CRUJRA_FLDS_ABCDE_blk_A5BCD_1850AD_471_480
| ctsm51_ctsm51d160_1deg_GSWP3V1_ABCDE_blk_A5BCD_1850AD_311_320
| Summary
|
| RMSE
| 1.13
| 0.77
| +0.36
|
| RMSE 0X0P+0rea
| 5.97
| 30.82
| -24.85
|
| ANN Bias
| 0.73
| 0.10
| +0.63
|
| ANN Bias 0X0P+0rea
| 16.58
| 39.43
| -22.85
|
| DJF Bias
| 0.62
| 0.06
| +0.56
|
| DJF Bias 0X0P+0rea
| 12.57
| 32.15
| -19.58
|
| MAM Bias
| 0.53
| -0.04
| +0.49
|
| MAM Bias 0X0P+0rea
| 17.23
| 30.48
| -13.25
|
| JJA Bias
| 1.06
| 0.29
| +0.77
|
| JJA Bias 0X0P+0rea
| 18.06
| 42.63
| -24.57
|
| SON Bias
| 0.71
| 0.08
| +0.63
|
| SON Bias 0X0P+0rea
| 15.81
| 36.84
| -21.03
|
| 0X0P+0rea with r>0.9
| 16.46
| 17.86
| --1.40
|