NCAR logo

GSWP3_controla
and
CRUNCEP_controla

Set 9



TSA modified control Comparison
Model GSWP3_controla CRUNCEP_controla Summary
RMSE 1.42 1.91 -0.49
RMSE % Area 36.53 9.91 +26.62
ANN Bias 0.71 -0.06 +0.65
ANN Bias % Area 35.08 24.31 +10.77
DJF Bias 0.41 -0.94 -0.53
DJF Bias % Area 42.76 18.18 +24.58
MAM Bias 0.81 -0.01 +0.80
MAM Bias % Area 32.59 25.71 +6.88
JJA Bias 0.87 0.59 +0.28
JJA Bias % Area 29.92 21.91 +8.01
SON Bias 0.61 -0.06 +0.55
SON Bias % Area 37.39 19.03 +18.36
% Area with r>0.9 92.49 92.01 +0.48


PREC modified control Comparison
Model GSWP3_controla CRUNCEP_controla Summary
RMSE 0.49 0.52 -0.03
RMSE % Area 5.57 3.31 +2.26
ANN Bias 0.06 -0.07 -0.01
ANN Bias % Area 12.66 18.49 -5.83
DJF Bias 0.13 -0.02 +0.11
DJF Bias % Area 8.35 15.21 -6.86
MAM Bias 0.04 -0.06 -0.02
MAM Bias % Area 9.33 12.34 -3.01
JJA Bias 0.02 -0.13 -0.11
JJA Bias % Area 12.32 11.58 +0.74
SON Bias 0.05 -0.08 -0.03
SON Bias % Area 9.09 14.29 -5.20
% Area with r>0.9 70.97 69.96 +1.01


ASA modified control Comparison
Model GSWP3_controla CRUNCEP_controla Summary
RMSE 4.15 4.36 -0.21
RMSE % Area 15.13 11.31 +3.82
ANN Bias -1.48 -1.18 +0.30
ANN Bias % Area 8.33 12.40 -4.07
DJF Bias 2.15 2.92 -0.77
DJF Bias % Area 13.05 11.77 +1.28
MAM Bias -1.01 -0.53 +0.48
MAM Bias % Area 9.03 11.85 -2.82
JJA Bias 0.28 0.39 -0.11
JJA Bias % Area 3.27 3.71 -0.44
SON Bias -2.04 -1.94 +0.10
SON Bias % Area 5.44 4.10 +1.34
% Area with r>0.9 23.65 24.74 --1.09


LHEAT modified control Comparison
Model GSWP3_controla CRUNCEP_controla Summary
RMSE 11.94 13.62 -1.68
RMSE % Area 22.30 8.36 +13.94
ANN Bias 3.94 5.80 -1.86
ANN Bias % Area 23.77 15.25 +8.52
DJF Bias 3.85 5.43 -1.58
DJF Bias % Area 22.89 8.70 +14.19
MAM Bias 4.15 6.16 -2.01
MAM Bias % Area 25.60 14.51 +11.09
JJA Bias 4.18 6.08 -1.90
JJA Bias % Area 28.59 20.46 +8.13
SON Bias 3.27 5.23 -1.96
SON Bias % Area 22.08 15.20 +6.88
% Area with r>0.9 69.46 71.87 --2.41

FPSN modified control Comparison
Model GSWP3_controla CRUNCEP_controla Summary
RMSE 1.08 1.24 -0.16
RMSE % Area 1.64 1.60 +0.04
ANN Bias 0.56 0.74 -0.18
ANN Bias % Area 3.55 3.28 +0.27
DJF Bias 0.28 0.42 -0.14
DJF Bias % Area 4.64 3.11 +1.53
MAM Bias 0.71 0.79 -0.08
MAM Bias % Area 3.45 2.58 +0.87
JJA Bias 0.84 1.20 -0.36
JJA Bias % Area 17.50 3.78 +13.72
SON Bias 0.36 0.54 -0.18
SON Bias % Area 4.17 5.04 -0.87
% Area with r>0.9 67.54 70.13 --2.59