Climate Model Assessment Tool (CMAT)

Methodology
CMATv1 CMIP5 Repository
Created: Sun Jan 12 14:55:56 2020
CMAT Version 1: NetCDF output

CMAT 1.0 CMIP5 bcc-csm1-1-m: vs CESM1-CAM5:
(Overall: 0.81-A; Energy: 0.80-B; Water: 0.79-A; Dynamics: 0.85-A)

Summary Comments
Notes	Flags vs Obs	Improvements (vs CESM1-CAM5)	Degradations (vs CESM1-CAM5)
CMIP5	Global Mean rsnt too small. see also swcftoa, ALBDS NHM-SHM rsnt too small. see also swcftoa, ALBDS OM-LM rsnt too large. see also swcftoa, ALBDS Global Mean rlut too small. see also lwcftoa, tas, TMQ OM-LM rlut too large. see also lwcftoa, tas, TMQ Global Mean swcftoa too small. see also ALBDS		rlut PCor-AM degrades. see also lwcftoa, tas, TMQ lwcftoa PCor-AM degrades. lwcftoa PCor-AC degrades. pr PCor-AM degrades. pr PCor-AC degrades. hfls PCor-AC degrades. ep PCor-AM degrades. ep PCor-AC degrades. zg500 PCor-AM degrades. zg500 PCor-AC degrades. hurs PCor-AC degrades. wap500 PCor-AM degrades. wap500 PCor-AC degrades. psl PCor-AC degrades. hur500 PCor-AM degrades. hur500 PCor-AC degrades.

Select Timeseries
Global: tas, RT, rsnt, rlut, swcftoa, lwcftoa, OHC 0-300m, OHC 0-700m, OHC 0-2000, P, CLDTOT, CLDLOW, CLDHGH, TMQ
NH:tas, RT, rsnt, rlut, swcftoa, lwcftoa, OHC 0-300m, OHC 0-700m, OHC 0-2000, P, CLDTOT, CLDLOW, CLDHGH, TMQ
SH: tas, RT, rsnt, rlut, swcftoa, lwcftoa, OHC 0-300m, OHC 0-700m, OHC 0-2000, P, CLDTOT, CLDLOW, CLDHGH, TMQ
Ocean: tas, RT, rsnt, rlut, swcftoa, lwcftoa, P, CLDTOT, CLDLOW, CLDHGH, TMQ
Land: tas, RT, rsnt, rlut, swcftoa, lwcftoa, P, CLDTOT, CLDLOW, CLDHGH, TMQ
Arctic(60N/90N): tas, RT, rsnt, rlut, swcftoa, lwcftoa, OHC 0-300m, OHC 0-700m, OHC 0-2000, P, CLDTOT, CLDLOW, CLDHGH, TMQ
NH Mid(30N/60N): tas, RT, rsnt, rlut, swcftoa, lwcftoa, OHC 0-300m, OHC 0-700m, OHC 0-2000, P, CLDTOT, CLDLOW, CLDHGH, TMQ
Tropics(30/30): tas, RT, rsnt, rlut, swcftoa, lwcftoa, OHC 0-300m, OHC 0-700m, OHC 0-2000, P, CLDTOT, CLDLOW, CLDHGH, TMQ
Ocean(30/30): tas, RT, rsnt, rlut, swcftoa, lwcftoa, P, CLDTOT, CLDLOW, CLDHGH, TMQ
Land(30/30): tas, RT, rsnt, rlut, swcftoa, lwcftoa, P, CLDTOT, CLDLOW, CLDHGH, TMQ
SH Mid(30S/60S): tas, RT, rsnt, rlut, swcftoa, lwcftoa, OHC 0-300m, OHC 0-700m, OHC 0-2000, P, CLDTOT, CLDLOW, CLDHGH, TMQ
SH Ant.(60S/90S): tas, RT, rsnt, rlut, swcftoa, lwcftoa, OHC 0-300m, OHC 0-700m, OHC 0-2000, P, CLDTOT, CLDLOW, CLDHGH, TMQ
Global (by LME member1): tas, rsnt, rlut, swcftoa, lwcftoa, OHC 0-300m, OHC 0-700m, OHC 0-2000, P, CLDTOT, CLDLOW, CLDHGH, TMQ
Ocean Drift: Summary By Basin Nino3.4: TS Forcing Est.rsutcs 30/30 Ocean

Lat/Lon Maps
rsnt 0.88	Annual 0.98	JJA-DJF 0.99	ENSO Tele 0.66	DJF 0.99	MAM 0.98	JJA 0.99	SON 0.99
rlut 0.87	Annual 0.92	JJA-DJF 0.91	ENSO Tele 0.77	DJF 0.91	MAM 0.89	JJA 0.92	SON 0.92
swcftoa 0.79	Annual 0.77	JJA-DJF 0.93	ENSO Tele 0.66	DJF 0.89	MAM 0.69	JJA 0.86	SON 0.81
lwcftoa 0.77	Annual 0.74	JJA-DJF 0.78	ENSO Tele 0.79	DJF 0.76	MAM 0.63	JJA 0.77	SON 0.75
fs 0.73	Annual 0.76	JJA-DJF 0.96	ENSO Tele 0.46	DJF 0.93	MAM 0.85	JJA 0.92	SON 0.85
rtfs 0.77	Annual 0.90	JJA-DJF 0.89	ENSO Tele 0.53	DJF 0.90	MAM 0.89	JJA 0.88	SON 0.89
Key Water Variables	Scored/Graded			Unscored
pr 0.74	Annual 0.73	JJA-DJF 0.72	ENSO Tele 0.78	DJF 0.76	MAM 0.67	JJA 0.69	SON 0.75
prw 0.93	Annual 0.97	JJA-DJF 0.96	ENSO Tele 0.87	DJF 0.97	MAM 0.96	JJA 0.96	SON 0.97
hfls 0.80	Annual 0.95	JJA-DJF 0.85	ENSO Tele 0.61	DJF 0.94	MAM 0.93	JJA 0.92	SON 0.93
ep 0.74	Annual 0.73	JJA-DJF 0.73	ENSO Tele 0.77	DJF 0.73	MAM 0.69	JJA 0.72	SON 0.74
Key Dynamics Variables	Scored/Graded			Unscored
zg500 0.83	Annual 0.88	JJA-DJF 0.79	ENSO Tele 0.81	DJF 0.85	MAM 0.83	JJA 0.89	SON 0.87
wap500 0.58	Annual 0.51	JJA-DJF 0.58	ENSO Tele 0.64	DJF 0.54	MAM 0.46	JJA 0.54	SON 0.54
Other Variables (unscored)

Hovmollers
rsnt	OCEAN	LAND	LAND+OCEAN
rlut	OCEAN	LAND	LAND+OCEAN
swcftoa	OCEAN	LAND	LAND+OCEAN
lwcftoa	OCEAN	LAND	LAND+OCEAN
fs	OCEAN	LAND	LAND+OCEAN
pr	OCEAN	LAND	LAND+OCEAN
prw	OCEAN	LAND	LAND+OCEAN
rsdt	OCEAN	LAND	LAND+OCEAN
albd	OCEAN	LAND	LAND+OCEAN
albs	OCEAN	LAND	LAND+OCEAN
rtmt	OCEAN	LAND	LAND+OCEAN
rsds	OCEAN	LAND	LAND+OCEAN
rlds	OCEAN	LAND	LAND+OCEAN
rsns	OCEAN	LAND	LAND+OCEAN
rlns	OCEAN	LAND	LAND+OCEAN
hfls	OCEAN	LAND	LAND+OCEAN
hfss	OCEAN	LAND	LAND+OCEAN
tas	OCEAN	LAND	LAND+OCEAN
tasa	OCEAN	LAND	LAND+OCEAN
ep	OCEAN	LAND	LAND+OCEAN
rtfs	OCEAN	LAND	LAND+OCEAN
zg500	OCEAN	LAND	LAND+OCEAN
hurs	OCEAN	LAND	LAND+OCEAN
netcf	OCEAN	LAND	LAND+OCEAN
wap500	OCEAN	LAND	LAND+OCEAN
sfcWind	OCEAN	LAND	LAND+OCEAN
psl	OCEAN	LAND	LAND+OCEAN
hur500	OCEAN	LAND	LAND+OCEAN