Climate Model Assessment Tool (CMAT)

Created: Thu Feb 16 09:25:17 2023
CMAT Version 1; Methodology

CMAT 1.0 CESM1LE Repository

Overall, {sorted by Energy,Water,Dynamics scores*.}
*Scoring is based on mean of the pattern correlations for the annual mean, seasonal contrast, and ENSO teleconnections. COLOR TABLE SUMMARY

CESM1LE Archive
Case ID	Benchmark Case	Notes	Flags	Improvements	Degradations
31 0.82: 0.82; 0.78; 0.87 A; A; A		CESM1LE	Global Mean FSNTOA too small. OM-LM FSNTOA too small. Global Mean FLNT too small. see also LWCF, TREFHT, TMQ OM-LM SWCF too small. see also ALBDS Global Mean LWCF too small.	Z500 PCor-ENSO, RELHUM992 PCor-ENSO, PSL PCor-ENSO,
38 0.82: 0.83; 0.78; 0.86 A; A; A		CESM1LE	OM-LM FSNTOA too small. Global Mean FLNT too small. see also LWCF, TREFHT, TMQ OM-LM SWCF too small. see also ALBDS Global Mean LWCF too small.	FLNT PCor-ENSO, see also LWCF, TREFHT, TMQ LWCF PCor-ENSO, Z500 PCor-ENSO, PSL PCor-ENSO,
24 0.82: 0.82; 0.78; 0.86 A; A; A		CESM1LE	OM-LM FSNTOA too small. Global Mean FLNT too small. see also LWCF, TREFHT, TMQ OM-LM SWCF too small. see also ALBDS Global Mean LWCF too small.	Z500 PCor-ENSO, PSL PCor-ENSO,
28 0.81: 0.81; 0.77; 0.86 A; A; A		CESM1LE	OM-LM FSNTOA too small. Global Mean FLNT too small. see also LWCF, TREFHT, TMQ OM-LM SWCF too small. see also ALBDS Global Mean LWCF too small.	Z500 PCor-ENSO, PSL PCor-ENSO,
12 0.82: 0.82; 0.77; 0.85 A; A; A		CESM1LE	OM-LM FSNTOA too small. Global Mean FLNT too small. see also LWCF, TREFHT, TMQ OM-LM SWCF too small. see also ALBDS Global Mean LWCF too small.	PSL PCor-ENSO,
10 0.82: 0.82; 0.77; 0.85 A; A; A		CESM1LE	OM-LM FSNTOA too small. Global Mean FLNT too small. see also LWCF, TREFHT, TMQ OM-LM SWCF too small. see also ALBDS Global Mean LWCF too small.	PSL PCor-ENSO,
20 0.82: 0.82; 0.77; 0.85 A; A; A		CESM1LE	OM-LM FSNTOA too small. Global Mean FLNT too small. see also LWCF, TREFHT, TMQ OM-LM SWCF too small. see also ALBDS Global Mean LWCF too small.	PSL PCor-ENSO,
6 0.81: 0.81; 0.76; 0.85 A; A; A		CESM1LE	OM-LM FSNTOA too small. Global Mean FLNT too small. see also LWCF, TREFHT, TMQ OM-LM SWCF too small. see also ALBDS Global Mean LWCF too small.	PSL PCor-ENSO,
27 0.80: 0.80; 0.76; 0.85 A; A; A		CESM1LE	OM-LM FSNTOA too small. Global Mean FLNT too small. see also LWCF, TREFHT, TMQ OM-LM SWCF too small. see also ALBDS Global Mean LWCF too small.	Z500 PCor-ENSO, PSL PCor-ENSO,
4 0.81: 0.82; 0.77; 0.85 A; A; A		CESM1LE	OM-LM FSNTOA too small. Global Mean FLNT too small. see also LWCF, TREFHT, TMQ OM-LM SWCF too small. see also ALBDS Global Mean LWCF too small.
37 0.81: 0.82; 0.77; 0.85 A; A; A		CESM1LE	OM-LM FSNTOA too small. Global Mean FLNT too small. see also LWCF, TREFHT, TMQ OM-LM SWCF too small. see also ALBDS Global Mean LWCF too small. Global Mean LHFLX too large.	PSL PCor-ENSO,
15 0.81: 0.81; 0.76; 0.85 A; A; A		CESM1LE	OM-LM FSNTOA too small. Global Mean FLNT too small. see also LWCF, TREFHT, TMQ OM-LM SWCF too small. see also ALBDS Global Mean LWCF too small.	PSL PCor-ENSO,
17 0.81: 0.81; 0.76; 0.84 A; A; A		CESM1LE	OM-LM FSNTOA too small. Global Mean FLNT too small. see also LWCF, TREFHT, TMQ OM-LM SWCF too small. see also ALBDS Global Mean LWCF too small.	PSL PCor-ENSO,
34 0.81: 0.81; 0.76; 0.84 A; A; A		CESM1LE	OM-LM FSNTOA too small. Global Mean FLNT too small. see also LWCF, TREFHT, TMQ OM-LM SWCF too small. see also ALBDS Global Mean LWCF too small.	PSL PCor-ENSO,
30 0.80: 0.80; 0.76; 0.84 A; B; A		CESM1LE	OM-LM FSNTOA too small. Global Mean FLNT too small. see also LWCF, TREFHT, TMQ OM-LM SWCF too small. see also ALBDS Global Mean LWCF too small.	PSL PCor-ENSO,
8 0.81: 0.81; 0.77; 0.84 A; A; A		CESM1LE	OM-LM FSNTOA too small. Global Mean FLNT too small. see also LWCF, TREFHT, TMQ OM-LM SWCF too small. see also ALBDS Global Mean LWCF too small.	PSL PCor-ENSO,
23 0.79: 0.79; 0.75; 0.84 A; A; A		CESM1LE	OM-LM FSNTOA too small. Global Mean FLNT too small. see also LWCF, TREFHT, TMQ OM-LM SWCF too small. see also ALBDS Global Mean LWCF too small.	Z500 PCor-ENSO, PSL PCor-ENSO,
40 0.80: 0.81; 0.76; 0.84 A; A; A		CESM1LE	OM-LM FSNTOA too small. Global Mean FLNT too small. see also LWCF, TREFHT, TMQ OM-LM SWCF too small. see also ALBDS Global Mean LWCF too small. Global Mean LHFLX too large.
13 0.80: 0.80; 0.76; 0.84 A; A; A		CESM1LE	OM-LM FSNTOA too small. Global Mean FLNT too small. see also LWCF, TREFHT, TMQ OM-LM SWCF too small. see also ALBDS Global Mean LWCF too small.
21 0.81: 0.82; 0.77; 0.84 A; A; A		CESM1LE	OM-LM FSNTOA too small. Global Mean FLNT too small. see also LWCF, TREFHT, TMQ OM-LM SWCF too small. see also ALBDS Global Mean LWCF too small.	PSL PCor-ENSO,
25 0.80: 0.81; 0.75; 0.84 A; A; A		CESM1LE	OM-LM FSNTOA too small. Global Mean FLNT too small. see also LWCF, TREFHT, TMQ OM-LM SWCF too small. see also ALBDS Global Mean LWCF too small.
3 0.81: 0.81; 0.77; 0.84 A; A; A		CESM1LE	OM-LM FSNTOA too small. Global Mean FLNT too small. see also LWCF, TREFHT, TMQ OM-LM SWCF too small. see also ALBDS Global Mean LWCF too small.	PSL PCor-ENSO,
22 0.79: 0.79; 0.76; 0.84 A; A; A		CESM1LE	OM-LM FSNTOA too small. Global Mean FLNT too small. see also LWCF, TREFHT, TMQ OM-LM SWCF too small. see also ALBDS Global Mean LWCF too small.	PSL PCor-ENSO,
33 0.81: 0.82; 0.77; 0.84 A; A; A		CESM1LE	Global Mean FSNTOA too small. OM-LM FSNTOA too small. Global Mean FLNT too small. see also LWCF, TREFHT, TMQ OM-LM SWCF too small. see also ALBDS Global Mean LWCF too small.
32 0.79: 0.80; 0.75; 0.84 A; B; A		CESM1LE	OM-LM FSNTOA too small. Global Mean FLNT too small. see also LWCF, TREFHT, TMQ OM-LM SWCF too small. see also ALBDS Global Mean LWCF too small.	PSL PCor-ENSO,
26 0.80: 0.80; 0.75; 0.83 A; A; A		CESM1LE	OM-LM FSNTOA too small. Global Mean FLNT too small. see also LWCF, TREFHT, TMQ OM-LM SWCF too small. see also ALBDS Global Mean LWCF too small.
14 0.80: 0.80; 0.76; 0.83 A; A; A		CESM1LE	OM-LM FSNTOA too small. Global Mean FLNT too small. see also LWCF, TREFHT, TMQ OM-LM SWCF too small. see also ALBDS Global Mean LWCF too small.
7 0.81: 0.82; 0.77; 0.83 A; A; A		CESM1LE	OM-LM FSNTOA too small. Global Mean FLNT too small. see also LWCF, TREFHT, TMQ OM-LM SWCF too small. see also ALBDS Global Mean LWCF too small.
29 0.80: 0.81; 0.76; 0.83 A; A; A		CESM1LE	OM-LM FSNTOA too small. Global Mean FLNT too small. see also LWCF, TREFHT, TMQ OM-LM SWCF too small. see also ALBDS Global Mean LWCF too small.
2 0.80: 0.80; 0.76; 0.83 A; A; A		CESM1LE	OM-LM FSNTOA too small. Global Mean FLNT too small. see also LWCF, TREFHT, TMQ OM-LM SWCF too small. see also ALBDS Global Mean LWCF too small.
5 0.78: 0.78; 0.74; 0.83 A; A; A		CESM1LE	OM-LM FSNTOA too small. Global Mean FLNT too small. see also LWCF, TREFHT, TMQ OM-LM SWCF too small. see also ALBDS Global Mean LWCF too small.		FS PCor-ENSO, PR PCor-ENSO, RTFS PCor-ENSO,
36 0.79: 0.80; 0.75; 0.83 A; A; A		CESM1LE	OM-LM FSNTOA too small. Global Mean FLNT too small. see also LWCF, TREFHT, TMQ OM-LM SWCF too small. see also ALBDS Global Mean LWCF too small. Global Mean LHFLX too large.
35 0.79: 0.80; 0.75; 0.83 A; A; A		CESM1LE	OM-LM FSNTOA too small. Global Mean FLNT too small. see also LWCF, TREFHT, TMQ OM-LM SWCF too small. see also ALBDS Global Mean LWCF too small.
19 0.79: 0.79; 0.75; 0.83 A; A; A		CESM1LE	OM-LM FSNTOA too small. Global Mean FLNT too small. see also LWCF, TREFHT, TMQ OM-LM SWCF too small. see also ALBDS Global Mean LWCF too small.
18 0.80: 0.80; 0.76; 0.82 A; A; A		CESM1LE	OM-LM FSNTOA too small. Global Mean FLNT too small. see also LWCF, TREFHT, TMQ OM-LM SWCF too small. see also ALBDS Global Mean LWCF too small.
39 0.79: 0.79; 0.75; 0.82 A; A; A		CESM1LE	OM-LM FSNTOA too small. Global Mean FLNT too small. see also LWCF, TREFHT, TMQ OM-LM SWCF too small. see also ALBDS Global Mean LWCF too small. Global Mean LHFLX too large.
11 0.80: 0.82; 0.76; 0.82 A; A; A		CESM1LE	OM-LM FSNTOA too small. Global Mean FLNT too small. see also LWCF, TREFHT, TMQ OM-LM SWCF too small. see also ALBDS Global Mean LWCF too small.
16 0.79: 0.79; 0.75; 0.81 A; B; A		CESM1LE	OM-LM FSNTOA too small. Global Mean FLNT too small. see also LWCF, TREFHT, TMQ OM-LM SWCF too small. see also ALBDS Global Mean LWCF too small.
9 0.77: 0.77; 0.73; 0.80 A; A; A		CESM1LE	OM-LM FSNTOA too small. Global Mean FLNT too small. see also LWCF, TREFHT, TMQ OM-LM SWCF too small. see also ALBDS Global Mean LWCF too small.		FSNTOA PCor-ENSO, SWCF PCor-ENSO, see also ALBDS FS PCor-ENSO, PR PCor-ENSO, EP PCor-ENSO, Z500 PCor-ENSO, OMEGA500 PCor-ENSO,