CMAT logo

Created: Wed Jan 22 14:13:17 2020
CMAT Version 1; Methodology

CMAT 1.0 CESM1LE Repository



Overall, {sorted by Energy,Water,Dynamics scores*.}
*Scoring is based on mean of the pattern correlations for the annual mean, seasonal contrast, and ENSO teleconnections. COLOR TABLE SUMMARY

CESM1LE Archive
Case IDBenchmark CaseNotesFlagsImprovementsDegradations
38
0.82: 0.83; 0.78; 0.86
A; A; A
CESM1LE OM-LM FSNTOA too small.
Global Mean FLNT too small.
see also LWCF, TREFHT, TMQ
OM-LM SWCF too small.
see also ALBDS
Global Mean LWCF too small.
Global Mean LHFLX too large.


FLNT PCor-ENSO,
see also LWCF, TREFHT, TMQ
LWCF PCor-ENSO,
Z500 PCor-ENSO,
PSL PCor-ENSO,



31
0.82: 0.82; 0.78; 0.87
A; A; A
CESM1LE Global Mean FSNTOA too small.
OM-LM FSNTOA too small.
Global Mean FLNT too small.
see also LWCF, TREFHT, TMQ
OM-LM SWCF too small.
see also ALBDS
Global Mean LWCF too small.


Z500 PCor-ENSO,
RELHUM992 PCor-ENSO,
PSL PCor-ENSO,



24
0.82: 0.82; 0.78; 0.86
A; A; A
CESM1LE OM-LM FSNTOA too small.
Global Mean FLNT too small.
see also LWCF, TREFHT, TMQ
OM-LM SWCF too small.
see also ALBDS
Global Mean LWCF too small.


Z500 PCor-ENSO,
PSL PCor-ENSO,



12
0.82: 0.82; 0.77; 0.85
A; A; A
CESM1LE OM-LM FSNTOA too small.
Global Mean FLNT too small.
see also LWCF, TREFHT, TMQ
OM-LM SWCF too small.
see also ALBDS
Global Mean LWCF too small.


PSL PCor-ENSO,



20
0.82: 0.82; 0.77; 0.85
A; A; A
CESM1LE OM-LM FSNTOA too small.
Global Mean FLNT too small.
see also LWCF, TREFHT, TMQ
OM-LM SWCF too small.
see also ALBDS
Global Mean LWCF too small.


PSL PCor-ENSO,



10
0.82: 0.82; 0.77; 0.85
A; A; A
CESM1LE OM-LM FSNTOA too small.
Global Mean FLNT too small.
see also LWCF, TREFHT, TMQ
OM-LM SWCF too small.
see also ALBDS
Global Mean LWCF too small.


PSL PCor-ENSO,



33
0.81: 0.82; 0.77; 0.84
A; A; A
CESM1LE Global Mean FSNTOA too small.
OM-LM FSNTOA too small.
Global Mean FLNT too small.
see also LWCF, TREFHT, TMQ
OM-LM SWCF too small.
see also ALBDS
Global Mean LWCF too small.





28
0.81: 0.81; 0.77; 0.86
A; A; A
CESM1LE OM-LM FSNTOA too small.
Global Mean FLNT too small.
see also LWCF, TREFHT, TMQ
OM-LM SWCF too small.
see also ALBDS
Global Mean LWCF too small.


Z500 PCor-ENSO,
PSL PCor-ENSO,



4
0.81: 0.82; 0.77; 0.85
A; A; A
CESM1LE OM-LM FSNTOA too small.
Global Mean FLNT too small.
see also LWCF, TREFHT, TMQ
OM-LM SWCF too small.
see also ALBDS
Global Mean LWCF too small.





7
0.81: 0.82; 0.77; 0.83
A; A; A
CESM1LE OM-LM FSNTOA too small.
Global Mean FLNT too small.
see also LWCF, TREFHT, TMQ
OM-LM SWCF too small.
see also ALBDS
Global Mean LWCF too small.





21
0.81: 0.82; 0.77; 0.84
A; A; A
CESM1LE OM-LM FSNTOA too small.
Global Mean FLNT too small.
see also LWCF, TREFHT, TMQ
OM-LM SWCF too small.
see also ALBDS
Global Mean LWCF too small.


PSL PCor-ENSO,



37
0.81: 0.82; 0.77; 0.85
A; A; A
CESM1LE OM-LM FSNTOA too small.
Global Mean FLNT too small.
see also LWCF, TREFHT, TMQ
OM-LM SWCF too small.
see also ALBDS
Global Mean LWCF too small.
Global Mean LHFLX too large.


PSL PCor-ENSO,



3
0.81: 0.81; 0.77; 0.84
A; A; A
CESM1LE OM-LM FSNTOA too small.
Global Mean FLNT too small.
see also LWCF, TREFHT, TMQ
OM-LM SWCF too small.
see also ALBDS
Global Mean LWCF too small.


PSL PCor-ENSO,



8
0.81: 0.81; 0.77; 0.84
A; A; A
CESM1LE OM-LM FSNTOA too small.
Global Mean FLNT too small.
see also LWCF, TREFHT, TMQ
OM-LM SWCF too small.
see also ALBDS
Global Mean LWCF too small.


PSL PCor-ENSO,



29
0.80: 0.81; 0.76; 0.83
A; A; A
CESM1LE OM-LM FSNTOA too small.
Global Mean FLNT too small.
see also LWCF, TREFHT, TMQ
OM-LM SWCF too small.
see also ALBDS
Global Mean LWCF too small.





17
0.81: 0.81; 0.76; 0.84
A; A; A
CESM1LE OM-LM FSNTOA too small.
Global Mean FLNT too small.
see also LWCF, TREFHT, TMQ
OM-LM SWCF too small.
see also ALBDS
Global Mean LWCF too small.


PSL PCor-ENSO,



6
0.81: 0.81; 0.76; 0.85
A; A; A
CESM1LE OM-LM FSNTOA too small.
Global Mean FLNT too small.
see also LWCF, TREFHT, TMQ
OM-LM SWCF too small.
see also ALBDS
Global Mean LWCF too small.


PSL PCor-ENSO,



34
0.81: 0.81; 0.76; 0.84
A; A; A
CESM1LE OM-LM FSNTOA too small.
Global Mean FLNT too small.
see also LWCF, TREFHT, TMQ
OM-LM SWCF too small.
see also ALBDS
Global Mean LWCF too small.


PSL PCor-ENSO,



11
0.80: 0.82; 0.76; 0.82
A; A; A
CESM1LE OM-LM FSNTOA too small.
Global Mean FLNT too small.
see also LWCF, TREFHT, TMQ
OM-LM SWCF too small.
see also ALBDS
Global Mean LWCF too small.





27
0.80: 0.80; 0.76; 0.85
A; A; A
CESM1LE OM-LM FSNTOA too small.
Global Mean FLNT too small.
see also LWCF, TREFHT, TMQ
OM-LM SWCF too small.
see also ALBDS
Global Mean LWCF too small.


Z500 PCor-ENSO,
PSL PCor-ENSO,



18
0.80: 0.80; 0.76; 0.82
A; A; A
CESM1LE OM-LM FSNTOA too small.
Global Mean FLNT too small.
see also LWCF, TREFHT, TMQ
OM-LM SWCF too small.
see also ALBDS
Global Mean LWCF too small.





40
0.80: 0.81; 0.76; 0.84
A; A; A
CESM1LE OM-LM FSNTOA too small.
Global Mean FLNT too small.
see also LWCF, TREFHT, TMQ
OM-LM SWCF too small.
see also ALBDS
Global Mean LWCF too small.
Global Mean LHFLX too large.





15
0.81: 0.81; 0.76; 0.85
A; A; A
CESM1LE OM-LM FSNTOA too small.
Global Mean FLNT too small.
see also LWCF, TREFHT, TMQ
OM-LM SWCF too small.
see also ALBDS
Global Mean LWCF too small.


PSL PCor-ENSO,



14
0.80: 0.80; 0.76; 0.83
A; A; A
CESM1LE OM-LM FSNTOA too small.
Global Mean FLNT too small.
see also LWCF, TREFHT, TMQ
OM-LM SWCF too small.
see also ALBDS
Global Mean LWCF too small.





30
0.80: 0.80; 0.76; 0.84
A; B; A
CESM1LE OM-LM FSNTOA too small.
Global Mean FLNT too small.
see also LWCF, TREFHT, TMQ
OM-LM SWCF too small.
see also ALBDS
Global Mean LWCF too small.


PSL PCor-ENSO,



13
0.80: 0.80; 0.76; 0.84
A; A; A
CESM1LE OM-LM FSNTOA too small.
Global Mean FLNT too small.
see also LWCF, TREFHT, TMQ
OM-LM SWCF too small.
see also ALBDS
Global Mean LWCF too small.





2
0.80: 0.80; 0.76; 0.83
A; A; A
CESM1LE OM-LM FSNTOA too small.
Global Mean FLNT too small.
see also LWCF, TREFHT, TMQ
OM-LM SWCF too small.
see also ALBDS
Global Mean LWCF too small.





22
0.79: 0.79; 0.76; 0.84
A; A; A
CESM1LE OM-LM FSNTOA too small.
Global Mean FLNT too small.
see also LWCF, TREFHT, TMQ
OM-LM SWCF too small.
see also ALBDS
Global Mean LWCF too small.


PSL PCor-ENSO,



26
0.80: 0.80; 0.75; 0.83
A; A; A
CESM1LE OM-LM FSNTOA too small.
Global Mean FLNT too small.
see also LWCF, TREFHT, TMQ
OM-LM SWCF too small.
see also ALBDS
Global Mean LWCF too small.





35
0.79: 0.80; 0.75; 0.83
A; A; A
CESM1LE OM-LM FSNTOA too small.
Global Mean FLNT too small.
see also LWCF, TREFHT, TMQ
OM-LM SWCF too small.
see also ALBDS
Global Mean LWCF too small.





25
0.80: 0.81; 0.75; 0.84
A; A; A
CESM1LE OM-LM FSNTOA too small.
Global Mean FLNT too small.
see also LWCF, TREFHT, TMQ
OM-LM SWCF too small.
see also ALBDS
Global Mean LWCF too small.





32
0.79: 0.80; 0.75; 0.84
A; B; A
CESM1LE OM-LM FSNTOA too small.
Global Mean FLNT too small.
see also LWCF, TREFHT, TMQ
OM-LM SWCF too small.
see also ALBDS
Global Mean LWCF too small.


PSL PCor-ENSO,



19
0.79: 0.79; 0.75; 0.83
A; A; A
CESM1LE OM-LM FSNTOA too small.
Global Mean FLNT too small.
see also LWCF, TREFHT, TMQ
OM-LM SWCF too small.
see also ALBDS
Global Mean LWCF too small.





16
0.79: 0.79; 0.75; 0.81
A; B; A
CESM1LE OM-LM FSNTOA too small.
Global Mean FLNT too small.
see also LWCF, TREFHT, TMQ
OM-LM SWCF too small.
see also ALBDS
Global Mean LWCF too small.





36
0.79: 0.80; 0.75; 0.83
A; A; A
CESM1LE OM-LM FSNTOA too small.
Global Mean FLNT too small.
see also LWCF, TREFHT, TMQ
OM-LM SWCF too small.
see also ALBDS
Global Mean LWCF too small.





23
0.79: 0.79; 0.75; 0.84
A; A; A
CESM1LE OM-LM FSNTOA too small.
Global Mean FLNT too small.
see also LWCF, TREFHT, TMQ
OM-LM SWCF too small.
see also ALBDS
Global Mean LWCF too small.


Z500 PCor-ENSO,
PSL PCor-ENSO,



39
0.79: 0.79; 0.75; 0.82
A; A; A
CESM1LE OM-LM FSNTOA too small.
Global Mean FLNT too small.
see also LWCF, TREFHT, TMQ
OM-LM SWCF too small.
see also ALBDS
Global Mean LWCF too small.
Global Mean LHFLX too large.





5
0.78: 0.78; 0.74; 0.83
A; A; A
CESM1LE OM-LM FSNTOA too small.
Global Mean FLNT too small.
see also LWCF, TREFHT, TMQ
OM-LM SWCF too small.
see also ALBDS
Global Mean LWCF too small.





FS PCor-ENSO,
PR PCor-ENSO,
RTFS PCor-ENSO,
9
0.77: 0.77; 0.73; 0.80
A; A; A
CESM1LE OM-LM FSNTOA too small.
Global Mean FLNT too small.
see also LWCF, TREFHT, TMQ
OM-LM SWCF too small.
see also ALBDS
Global Mean LWCF too small.





FSNTOA PCor-ENSO,
SWCF PCor-ENSO,
see also ALBDS
FS PCor-ENSO,
PR PCor-ENSO,
EP PCor-ENSO,
Z500 PCor-ENSO,
OMEGA500 PCor-ENSO,