CMAT logo

Created: Tue May 26 15:12:08 2026
CMAT Version 1; Methodology

CMAT 1.0 CESM3dev Repository


Overall, {sorted by Energy,Water,Dynamics scores*.}
*Scoring is based on mean of the pattern correlations for the annual mean, seasonal contrast, and ENSO teleconnections. COLOR TABLE SUMMARY
CESM3dev Archive
Case IDBenchmark CaseNotesFlagsImprovementsDegradations
CESM3dev_245pi
0.81: 0.83; 0.73; 0.88
A; A; A		CESM2_1CESM3dev NHM-SHM FSNT too small.
see also SWCF, ALBDS
OM-LM FSNT too large.
see also SWCF, ALBDS
Global Mean LHFLX too large.
OM-LM LHFLX too small.


FSNT PCor-ENSO,
see also SWCF, ALBDS
RTFS PCor-ENSO,



PR PCor-AM,
CESM3dev_315
0.83: 0.82; 0.78; 0.88
A; A; A		CESM2_1CESM3dev NHM-SHM FSNT too small.
see also SWCF, ALBDS
OM-LM LHFLX too small.


RELHUM992 PCor-ENSO,



CESM3dev_328pi
0.81: 0.82; 0.73; 0.88
A; A; A		CESM2_1CESM3dev 0-2000m Ocean Drifting Cold
0-700m Ocean Drifting Cold
Global Mean FSNT too small.
see also SWCF, ALBDS
NHM-SHM FSNT too small.
see also SWCF, ALBDS
OM-LM LHFLX too small.


FSNT PCor-ENSO,
see also SWCF, ALBDS
RTFS PCor-ENSO,



CESM3dev_nch
0.83: 0.82; 0.79; 0.88
A; A; A		CESM2_1CESM3dev NHM-SHM FSNT too small.
see also SWCF, ALBDS
OM-LM LHFLX too small.





CESM3dev_316
0.83: 0.82; 0.79; 0.87
A; A; A		CESM2_1CESM3dev Global Mean FSNT too small.
see also SWCF, ALBDS
NHM-SHM FSNT too small.
see also SWCF, ALBDS
Global Mean FLNT too small.
see also LWCF, TREFHT, TMQ
OM-LM LHFLX too small.





CESM3dev_271pi
0.81: 0.82; 0.73; 0.87
A; A; A		CESM2_1CESM3dev NHM-SHM FSNT too small.
see also SWCF, ALBDS
Global Mean LWCF too small.
Global Mean LHFLX too large.
OM-LM LHFLX too small.


FSNT PCor-ENSO,
see also SWCF, ALBDS



PR PCor-AM,
CESM3dev_121
0.82: 0.81; 0.78; 0.87
A; A; A		CESM2_1CESM3dev NHM-SHM FSNT too small.
see also SWCF, ALBDS
OM-LM FSNT too large.
see also SWCF, ALBDS
NHM-SHM SWCF too large.
see also ALBDS
Global Mean LWCF too small.
Global Mean LHFLX too large.
OM-LM LHFLX too small.


RELHUM992 PCor-ENSO,



CESM3dev_213pi
0.79: 0.79; 0.71; 0.87
A; A; A		CESM2_1CESM3dev 0-2000m Ocean Drifting Cold
0-700m Ocean Drifting Cold
Global Mean FSNT too small.
see also SWCF, ALBDS
NHM-SHM FSNT too small.
see also SWCF, ALBDS
OM-LM FSNT too large.
see also SWCF, ALBDS
OM-LM LHFLX too small.


FSNT PCor-ENSO,
see also SWCF, ALBDS



SWCF PCor-ENSO,
see also ALBDS
PR PCor-ENSO,
OMEGA500 PCor-ENSO,
CESM3dev_331pi
0.80: 0.82; 0.72; 0.86
A; A; A		CESM2_1CESM3dev 0-2000m Ocean Drifting Cold
0-700m Ocean Drifting Cold
NHM-SHM FSNT too small.
see also SWCF, ALBDS
OM-LM LHFLX too small.


FSNT PCor-ENSO,
see also SWCF, ALBDS



PR PCor-AM,
RELHUM992 PCor-ENSO,
CESM3dev_237pi
0.80: 0.81; 0.72; 0.86
A; A; A		CESM2_1CESM3dev 0-2000m Ocean Drifting Warm
NHM-SHM FSNT too small.
see also SWCF, ALBDS
NHM-SHM FLNT too small.
see also LWCF, TREFHT, TMQ
Global Mean LHFLX too large.
OM-LM LHFLX too small.


FSNT PCor-ENSO,
see also SWCF, ALBDS



PR PCor-AM,
CESM3dev_334pi
0.80: 0.81; 0.72; 0.86
A; A; A		CESM2_1CESM3dev NHM-SHM FSNT too small.
see also SWCF, ALBDS
OM-LM LHFLX too small.


FSNT PCor-ENSO,
see also SWCF, ALBDS



CESM3dev_330pi
0.80: 0.82; 0.72; 0.86
A; A; A		CESM2_1CESM3dev 0-2000m Ocean Drifting Cold
0-700m Ocean Drifting Cold
NHM-SHM FSNT too small.
see also SWCF, ALBDS
OM-LM LHFLX too small.


FSNT PCor-ENSO,
see also SWCF, ALBDS



Z500 PCor-ENSO,
RELHUM992 PCor-ENSO,
U10 PCor-ENSO,
CESM3dev_319pi
0.79: 0.80; 0.72; 0.86
A; A; A		CESM2_1CESM3dev Global Mean FSNT too small.
see also SWCF, ALBDS
NHM-SHM FSNT too small.
see also SWCF, ALBDS
OM-LM LHFLX too small.


FSNT PCor-ENSO,
see also SWCF, ALBDS



SWCF PCor-ENSO,
see also ALBDS
PR PCor-AM,
Z500 PCor-ENSO,
PSL PCor-ENSO,
CESM3dev_316pi
0.79: 0.81; 0.72; 0.85
A; A; A		CESM2_1CESM3dev 0-700m Ocean Drifting Cold
Global Mean FSNT too small.
see also SWCF, ALBDS
NHM-SHM FSNT too small.
see also SWCF, ALBDS
OM-LM LHFLX too small.


FSNT PCor-ENSO,
see also SWCF, ALBDS



Z500 PCor-ENSO,
U10 PCor-ENSO,
CESM3dev_308pi
0.78: 0.79; 0.70; 0.85
A; A; A		CESM2_1CESM3dev Global Mean FSNT too small.
see also SWCF, ALBDS
NHM-SHM FSNT too small.
see also SWCF, ALBDS
OM-LM LHFLX too small.


FSNT PCor-ENSO,
see also SWCF, ALBDS



SWCF PCor-ENSO,
see also ALBDS
PR PCor-AM,
PR PCor-ENSO,
EP PCor-ENSO,
OMEGA500 PCor-ENSO,
CESM2LE_6
0.82: 0.81; 0.80; 0.85
A; A; A		CESM2_1CESM2LE Global Mean FSNT too small.
see also SWCF, ALBDS
NHM-SHM FSNT too small.
see also SWCF, ALBDS
NHM-SHM SWCF too large.
see also ALBDS


LHFLX PCor-ENSO,
RELHUM992 PCor-ENSO,
U10 PCor-ENSO,



FSNT PCor-ENSO,
see also SWCF, ALBDS
SWCF PCor-ENSO,
see also ALBDS
CESM3dev_98b
0.80: 0.79; 0.76; 0.85
A; A; A		CESM2_1CESM3dev NHM-SHM FSNT too small.
see also SWCF, ALBDS
OM-LM FSNT too large.
see also SWCF, ALBDS
OM-LM FLNT too large.
see also LWCF, TREFHT, TMQ
Global Mean LWCF too small.
Global Mean LHFLX too large.
OM-LM LHFLX too small.





FSNT PCor-ENSO,
see also SWCF, ALBDS
SWCF PCor-ENSO,
see also ALBDS
LHFLX PCor-ENSO,
RTFS PCor-ENSO,
CESM3dev_120pi
0.78: 0.79; 0.71; 0.85
A; A; A		CESM2_1CESM3dev NHM-SHM FSNT too small.
see also SWCF, ALBDS
OM-LM FSNT too large.
see also SWCF, ALBDS
NHM-SHM SWCF too large.
see also ALBDS
Global Mean LWCF too small.
Global Mean LHFLX too large.
OM-LM LHFLX too small.


FSNT PCor-ENSO,
see also SWCF, ALBDS



SWCF PCor-ENSO,
see also ALBDS
LHFLX PCor-ENSO,
U10 PCor-ENSO,
PSL PCor-ENSO,
CESM3dev_315pi
0.78: 0.79; 0.70; 0.85
A; A; A		CESM2_1CESM3dev 0-700m Ocean Drifting Cold
Global Mean FSNT too small.
see also SWCF, ALBDS
NHM-SHM FSNT too small.
see also SWCF, ALBDS
OM-LM LHFLX too small.


FSNT PCor-ENSO,
see also SWCF, ALBDS



SWCF PCor-ENSO,
see also ALBDS
PR PCor-AM,
PR PCor-ENSO,
LHFLX PCor-ENSO,
Z500 PCor-ENSO,
OMEGA500 PCor-ENSO,
U10 PCor-ENSO,
CESM3dev_234pi
0.78: 0.79; 0.70; 0.85
A; A; A		CESM2_1CESM3dev 0-2000m Ocean Drifting Cold
0-700m Ocean Drifting Cold
Global Mean FSNT too small.
see also SWCF, ALBDS
NHM-SHM FSNT too small.
see also SWCF, ALBDS
OM-LM FSNT too large.
see also SWCF, ALBDS
NHM-SHM FLNT too small.
see also LWCF, TREFHT, TMQ
OM-LM LHFLX too small.


FSNT PCor-ENSO,
see also SWCF, ALBDS



SWCF PCor-ENSO,
see also ALBDS
PR PCor-AM,
PR PCor-ENSO,
EP PCor-AM,
Z500 PCor-ENSO,
OMEGA500 PCor-ENSO,
PSL PCor-ENSO,
CESM3dev_314pi
0.78: 0.79; 0.69; 0.85
A; A; A		CESM2_1CESM3dev 0-700m Ocean Drifting Cold
Global Mean FSNT too small.
see also SWCF, ALBDS
NHM-SHM FSNT too small.
see also SWCF, ALBDS
OM-LM LHFLX too small.


FSNT PCor-ENSO,
see also SWCF, ALBDS



SWCF PCor-ENSO,
see also ALBDS
PR PCor-AM,
PR PCor-ENSO,
LHFLX PCor-ENSO,
Z500 PCor-ENSO,
RELHUM992 PCor-ENSO,
OMEGA500 PCor-ENSO,
U10 PCor-ENSO,
PSL PCor-ENSO,
CESM3dev_286pi
0.79: 0.81; 0.72; 0.85
A; A; A		CESM2_1CESM3dev NHM-SHM FSNT too small.
see also SWCF, ALBDS
Global Mean LWCF too small.
Global Mean LHFLX too large.
OM-LM LHFLX too small.


FSNT PCor-ENSO,
see also SWCF, ALBDS



Z500 PCor-ENSO,
U10 PCor-ENSO,
PSL PCor-ENSO,
CESM3dev_327pi
0.78: 0.80; 0.69; 0.84
A; A; A		CESM2_1CESM3dev 0-2000m Ocean Drifting Cold
0-700m Ocean Drifting Cold
Global Mean FSNT too small.
see also SWCF, ALBDS
NHM-SHM FSNT too small.
see also SWCF, ALBDS
OM-LM LHFLX too small.


FSNT PCor-ENSO,
see also SWCF, ALBDS



PR PCor-AM,
PR PCor-ENSO,
LHFLX PCor-ENSO,
Z500 PCor-ENSO,
RELHUM992 PCor-ENSO,
U10 PCor-ENSO,
PSL PCor-ENSO,
CESM3dev_313pi
0.79: 0.80; 0.71; 0.84
A; A; A		CESM2_1CESM3dev 0-700m Ocean Drifting Cold
Global Mean FSNT too small.
see also SWCF, ALBDS
NHM-SHM FSNT too small.
see also SWCF, ALBDS
OM-LM LHFLX too small.


FSNT PCor-ENSO,
see also SWCF, ALBDS



SWCF PCor-ENSO,
see also ALBDS
PR PCor-AM,
Z500 PCor-ENSO,
U10 PCor-ENSO,
PSL PCor-ENSO,
CESM3dev_307pi
0.78: 0.80; 0.71; 0.84
A; A; A		CESM2_1CESM3dev NHM-SHM FSNT too small.
see also SWCF, ALBDS
Global Mean LHFLX too large.
OM-LM LHFLX too small.


FSNT PCor-ENSO,
see also SWCF, ALBDS



SWCF PCor-ENSO,
see also ALBDS
PR PCor-AM,
Z500 PCor-ENSO,
OMEGA500 PCor-ENSO,
PSL PCor-ENSO,
CESM3dev_110pi
0.77: 0.77; 0.69; 0.84
A; A; A		CESM2_1CESM3dev NHM-SHM FSNT too small.
see also SWCF, ALBDS
OM-LM FSNT too large.
see also SWCF, ALBDS
NHM-SHM SWCF too large.
see also ALBDS
Global Mean LHFLX too large.
OM-LM LHFLX too small.


FSNT PCor-ENSO,
see also SWCF, ALBDS



FLNT PCor-ENSO,
see also LWCF, TREFHT, TMQ
SWCF PCor-ENSO,
see also ALBDS
LWCF PCor-ENSO,
PR PCor-ENSO,
LHFLX PCor-ENSO,
EP PCor-ENSO,
RTFS PCor-ENSO,
OMEGA500 PCor-ENSO,
U10 PCor-ENSO,
CESM3dev_290pi
0.77: 0.79; 0.70; 0.84
A; A; A		CESM2_1CESM3dev 0-700m Ocean Drifting Cold
Global Mean FSNT too small.
see also SWCF, ALBDS
NHM-SHM FSNT too small.
see also SWCF, ALBDS
OM-LM LHFLX too small.


FSNT PCor-ENSO,
see also SWCF, ALBDS



FLNT PCor-ENSO,
see also LWCF, TREFHT, TMQ
SWCF PCor-ENSO,
see also ALBDS
LWCF PCor-ENSO,
PR PCor-ENSO,
LHFLX PCor-ENSO,
EP PCor-ENSO,
RTFS PCor-ENSO,
Z500 PCor-ENSO,
OMEGA500 PCor-ENSO,
PSL PCor-ENSO,
CESM3dev_268pi
0.78: 0.81; 0.70; 0.84
A; A; A		CESM2_1CESM3dev NHM-SHM FSNT too small.
see also SWCF, ALBDS
Global Mean LWCF too small.
Global Mean LHFLX too large.
OM-LM LHFLX too small.


FSNT PCor-ENSO,
see also SWCF, ALBDS



PR PCor-AM,
Z500 PCor-ENSO,
RELHUM992 PCor-ENSO,
U10 PCor-ENSO,
PSL PCor-ENSO,
CESM3dev_323pi
0.78: 0.80; 0.70; 0.84
A; A; A		CESM2_1CESM3dev Global Mean FSNT too small.
see also SWCF, ALBDS
NHM-SHM FSNT too small.
see also SWCF, ALBDS
OM-LM LHFLX too small.


FSNT PCor-ENSO,
see also SWCF, ALBDS



SWCF PCor-ENSO,
see also ALBDS
Z500 PCor-ENSO,
RELHUM992 PCor-ENSO,
OMEGA500 PCor-ENSO,
U10 PCor-ENSO,
PSL PCor-ENSO,
CESM3dev_329pi
0.79: 0.82; 0.72; 0.84
A; A; A		CESM2_1CESM3dev 0-2000m Ocean Drifting Cold
0-700m Ocean Drifting Cold
NHM-SHM FSNT too small.
see also SWCF, ALBDS
OM-LM LHFLX too small.


FSNT PCor-ENSO,
see also SWCF, ALBDS



PR PCor-AM,
Z500 PCor-ENSO,
RELHUM992 PCor-ENSO,
U10 PCor-ENSO,
PSL PCor-ENSO,
CESM3dev_280pi
0.76: 0.76; 0.68; 0.84
A; A; A		CESM2_1CESM3dev Global Mean FSNT too small.
see also SWCF, ALBDS
NHM-SHM FSNT too small.
see also SWCF, ALBDS
NHM-SHM FLNT too small.
see also LWCF, TREFHT, TMQ
OM-LM LHFLX too small.


FSNT PCor-ENSO,
see also SWCF, ALBDS



FLNT PCor-ENSO,
see also LWCF, TREFHT, TMQ
SWCF PCor-ENSO,
see also ALBDS
LWCF PCor-ENSO,
PR PCor-ENSO,
LHFLX PCor-ENSO,
EP PCor-ENSO,
RTFS PCor-ENSO,
Z500 PCor-ENSO,
RELHUM992 PCor-ENSO,
OMEGA500 PCor-ENSO,
U10 PCor-ENSO,
CESM3dev_311pi
0.78: 0.79; 0.71; 0.84
A; A; A		CESM2_1CESM3dev 0-700m Ocean Drifting Cold
NHM-SHM FSNT too small.
see also SWCF, ALBDS
Global Mean LHFLX too large.
OM-LM LHFLX too small.


FSNT PCor-ENSO,
see also SWCF, ALBDS



FLNT PCor-ENSO,
see also LWCF, TREFHT, TMQ
SWCF PCor-ENSO,
see also ALBDS
LWCF PCor-ENSO,
Z500 PCor-ENSO,
OMEGA500 PCor-ENSO,
U10 PCor-ENSO,
PSL PCor-ENSO,
CESM3dev_324pi
0.78: 0.80; 0.71; 0.83
A; A; A		CESM2_1CESM3dev Global Mean FSNT too small.
see also SWCF, ALBDS
NHM-SHM FSNT too small.
see also SWCF, ALBDS
OM-LM LHFLX too small.


FSNT PCor-ENSO,
see also SWCF, ALBDS



SWCF PCor-ENSO,
see also ALBDS
PR PCor-ENSO,
Z500 PCor-ENSO,
OMEGA500 PCor-ENSO,
PSL PCor-ENSO,
CESM3dev_098
0.79: 0.79; 0.76; 0.83
A; A; A		CESM2_1CESM3dev NHM-SHM FSNT too small.
see also SWCF, ALBDS
OM-LM FSNT too large.
see also SWCF, ALBDS
Global Mean LWCF too small.
Global Mean LHFLX too large.
OM-LM LHFLX too small.





FSNT PCor-ENSO,
see also SWCF, ALBDS
FLNT PCor-ENSO,
see also LWCF, TREFHT, TMQ
SWCF PCor-ENSO,
see also ALBDS
LWCF PCor-ENSO,
RTFS PCor-ENSO,
Z500 PCor-ENSO,
PSL PCor-ENSO,
CESM3dev_303pi
0.76: 0.78; 0.69; 0.81
A; A; A		CESM2_1CESM3dev NHM-SHM FSNT too small.
see also SWCF, ALBDS
OM-LM LHFLX too small.


FSNT PCor-ENSO,
see also SWCF, ALBDS



FLNT PCor-ENSO,
see also LWCF, TREFHT, TMQ
SWCF PCor-ENSO,
see also ALBDS
LWCF PCor-ENSO,
PR PCor-ENSO,
LHFLX PCor-ENSO,
EP PCor-ENSO,
RTFS PCor-ENSO,
Z500 PCor-ENSO,
RELHUM992 PCor-ENSO,
OMEGA500 PCor-ENSO,
U10 PCor-ENSO,
PSL PCor-ENSO,
CESM3dev_207pi
0.73: 0.75; 0.64; 0.81
A; A; A		CESM2_1CESM3dev 0-2000m Ocean Drifting Cold
0-700m Ocean Drifting Cold
Global Mean FSNT too small.
see also SWCF, ALBDS
NHM-SHM FSNT too small.
see also SWCF, ALBDS
OM-LM FSNT too large.
see also SWCF, ALBDS
OM-LM LHFLX too small.


FSNT PCor-ENSO,
see also SWCF, ALBDS



FLNT PCor-ENSO,
see also LWCF, TREFHT, TMQ
SWCF PCor-ENSO,
see also ALBDS
LWCF PCor-ENSO,
PR PCor-AM,
PR PCor-ENSO,
LHFLX PCor-ENSO,
EP PCor-AM,
EP PCor-ENSO,
RTFS PCor-ENSO,
Z500 PCor-ENSO,
RELHUM992 PCor-ENSO,
OMEGA500 PCor-ENSO,
U10 PCor-ENSO,
PSL PCor-ENSO,
CESM3dev_198pi
0.73: 0.72; 0.65; 0.81
A; A; A		CESM2_1CESM3dev 0-2000m Ocean Drifting Cold
0-700m Ocean Drifting Cold
Global Mean FSNT too small.
see also SWCF, ALBDS
NHM-SHM FSNT too small.
see also SWCF, ALBDS
OM-LM FSNT too large.
see also SWCF, ALBDS
OM-LM LHFLX too small.





FLNT PCor-ENSO,
see also LWCF, TREFHT, TMQ
SWCF PCor-ENSO,
see also ALBDS
LWCF PCor-ENSO,
PR PCor-AM,
PR PCor-ENSO,
TMQ PCor-ENSO,
LHFLX PCor-ENSO,
EP PCor-AM,
EP PCor-ENSO,
RTFS PCor-ENSO,
Z500 PCor-ENSO,
OMEGA500 PCor-ENSO,
U10 PCor-ENSO,
PSL PCor-ENSO,
CESM3dev_278pi
0.74: 0.74; 0.67; 0.81
A; B; A		CESM2_1CESM3dev 0-2000m Ocean Drifting Cold
0-700m Ocean Drifting Cold
NHM-SHM FSNT too small.
see also SWCF, ALBDS
OM-LM FSNT too large.
see also SWCF, ALBDS
NHM-SHM FLNT too small.
see also LWCF, TREFHT, TMQ
OM-LM SWCF too large.
see also ALBDS


FSNT PCor-ENSO,
see also SWCF, ALBDS
RELHUM992 PCor-AC,



FLNT PCor-ENSO,
see also LWCF, TREFHT, TMQ
SWCF PCor-ENSO,
see also ALBDS
LWCF PCor-ENSO,
PR PCor-ENSO,
TMQ PCor-ENSO,
LHFLX PCor-ENSO,
EP PCor-ENSO,
RTFS PCor-ENSO,
Z500 PCor-ENSO,
RELHUM992 PCor-ENSO,
OMEGA500 PCor-ENSO,
U10 PCor-ENSO,
PSL PCor-ENSO,
CESM3dev_118pi
0.76: 0.77; 0.69; 0.81
A; A; A		CESM2_1CESM3dev NHM-SHM FSNT too small.
see also SWCF, ALBDS
OM-LM FSNT too large.
see also SWCF, ALBDS
NHM-SHM SWCF too large.
see also ALBDS
Global Mean LWCF too small.
Global Mean LHFLX too large.
OM-LM LHFLX too small.


FSNT PCor-ENSO,
see also SWCF, ALBDS



FLNT PCor-ENSO,
see also LWCF, TREFHT, TMQ
SWCF PCor-ENSO,
see also ALBDS
LWCF PCor-ENSO,
TMQ PCor-ENSO,
LHFLX PCor-ENSO,
RTFS PCor-ENSO,
Z500 PCor-ENSO,
RELHUM992 PCor-ENSO,
OMEGA500 PCor-ENSO,
U10 PCor-ENSO,
PSL PCor-ENSO,
CESM3dev_078pi
0.76: 0.78; 0.68; 0.81
A; A; A		CESM2_1CESM3dev NHM-SHM FSNT too small.
see also SWCF, ALBDS
NHM-SHM SWCF too large.
see also ALBDS
Global Mean LWCF too small.
Global Mean LHFLX too large.
NHM-SHM LHFLX too small.
OM-LM LHFLX too small.


FSNT PCor-ENSO,
see also SWCF, ALBDS



FLNT PCor-ENSO,
see also LWCF, TREFHT, TMQ
SWCF PCor-ENSO,
see also ALBDS
LWCF PCor-ENSO,
PR PCor-AM,
PR PCor-ENSO,
EP PCor-ENSO,
Z500 PCor-AC,
Z500 PCor-ENSO,
OMEGA500 PCor-ENSO,
U10 PCor-ENSO,
PSL PCor-ENSO,
CESM3dev_276pi
0.75: 0.77; 0.67; 0.81
A; A; A		CESM2_1CESM3dev 0-700m Ocean Drifting Cold
NHM-SHM FSNT too small.
see also SWCF, ALBDS
OM-LM LHFLX too small.


FSNT PCor-ENSO,
see also SWCF, ALBDS



FLNT PCor-ENSO,
see also LWCF, TREFHT, TMQ
SWCF PCor-ENSO,
see also ALBDS
LWCF PCor-ENSO,
PR PCor-AM,
PR PCor-ENSO,
LHFLX PCor-ENSO,
EP PCor-ENSO,
Z500 PCor-ENSO,
RELHUM992 PCor-ENSO,
OMEGA500 PCor-ENSO,
U10 PCor-ENSO,
PSL PCor-ENSO,
CESM3dev_214
0.75: 0.73; 0.71; 0.80
A; A; B		CESM2_1CESM3dev Global Mean FSNT too small.
see also SWCF, ALBDS
NHM-SHM FSNT too small.
see also SWCF, ALBDS
OM-LM FSNT too large.
see also SWCF, ALBDS
Global Mean FLNT too small.
see also LWCF, TREFHT, TMQ
Global Mean LHFLX too large.
NHM-SHM LHFLX too small.
OM-LM LHFLX too small.


RELHUM992 PCor-ENSO,



FSNT PCor-ENSO,
see also SWCF, ALBDS
FLNT PCor-ENSO,
see also LWCF, TREFHT, TMQ
SWCF PCor-ENSO,
see also ALBDS
LWCF PCor-ENSO,
PR PCor-ENSO,
TMQ PCor-ENSO,
LHFLX PCor-ENSO,
EP PCor-ENSO,
RTFS PCor-ENSO,
Z500 PCor-ENSO,
OMEGA500 PCor-ENSO,
PSL PCor-ENSO,
CESM3dev_289pi
0.75: 0.77; 0.68; 0.80
A; A; A		CESM2_1CESM3dev 0-2000m Ocean Drifting Cold
0-700m Ocean Drifting Cold
Global Mean FSNT too small.
see also SWCF, ALBDS
NHM-SHM FSNT too small.
see also SWCF, ALBDS
NHM-SHM FLNT too small.
see also LWCF, TREFHT, TMQ
NHM-SHM LHFLX too small.
OM-LM LHFLX too small.


FSNT PCor-ENSO,
see also SWCF, ALBDS



FLNT PCor-ENSO,
see also LWCF, TREFHT, TMQ
SWCF PCor-ENSO,
see also ALBDS
LWCF PCor-ENSO,
PR PCor-ENSO,
LHFLX PCor-ENSO,
EP PCor-ENSO,
RTFS PCor-ENSO,
Z500 PCor-ENSO,
OMEGA500 PCor-ENSO,
U10 PCor-ENSO,
PSL PCor-ENSO,
CESM3dev_287pi
0.76: 0.79; 0.69; 0.80
A; A; A		CESM2_1CESM3dev 0-700m Ocean Drifting Cold
NHM-SHM FSNT too small.
see also SWCF, ALBDS
Global Mean LWCF too small.
Global Mean LHFLX too large.
OM-LM LHFLX too small.


FSNT PCor-ENSO,
see also SWCF, ALBDS



SWCF PCor-ENSO,
see also ALBDS
LWCF PCor-ENSO,
PR PCor-AM,
PR PCor-ENSO,
LHFLX PCor-ENSO,
EP PCor-ENSO,
Z500 PCor-ENSO,
OMEGA500 PCor-ENSO,
U10 PCor-ENSO,
PSL PCor-ENSO,
CESM3dev_192pi
0.73: 0.74; 0.66; 0.79
A; A; A		CESM2_1CESM3dev NHM-SHM FSNT too small.
see also SWCF, ALBDS
OM-LM FSNT too large.
see also SWCF, ALBDS
Global Mean LHFLX too large.
OM-LM LHFLX too small.





FLNT PCor-ENSO,
see also LWCF, TREFHT, TMQ
SWCF PCor-ENSO,
see also ALBDS
LWCF PCor-ENSO,
PR PCor-ENSO,
TMQ PCor-ENSO,
LHFLX PCor-ENSO,
EP PCor-ENSO,
RTFS PCor-ENSO,
Z500 PCor-ENSO,
RELHUM992 PCor-ENSO,
OMEGA500 PCor-ENSO,
U10 PCor-ENSO,
PSL PCor-ENSO,
CESM3dev_214pi
0.68: 0.68; 0.61; 0.75
A; A; A		CESM2_1CESM3dev 0-2000m Ocean Drifting Warm
Global Mean FSNT too small.
see also SWCF, ALBDS
NHM-SHM FSNT too small.
see also SWCF, ALBDS
OM-LM FSNT too large.
see also SWCF, ALBDS
OM-LM LHFLX too small.





FSNT PCor-ENSO,
see also SWCF, ALBDS
FLNT PCor-ENSO,
see also LWCF, TREFHT, TMQ
SWCF PCor-ENSO,
see also ALBDS
LWCF PCor-ENSO,
PR PCor-AM,
PR PCor-ENSO,
TMQ PCor-ENSO,
LHFLX PCor-ENSO,
EP PCor-AM,
EP PCor-ENSO,
RTFS PCor-ENSO,
Z500 PCor-ENSO,
RELHUM992 PCor-ENSO,
OMEGA500 PCor-ENSO,
U10 PCor-ENSO,
PSL PCor-ENSO,
CESM3dev_235pi
0.71: 0.72; 0.66; 0.74
A; A; A		CESM2_1CESM3dev 0-2000m Ocean Drifting Warm
0-700m Ocean Drifting Warm
Global Mean FSNT too small.
see also SWCF, ALBDS
NHM-SHM FSNT too small.
see also SWCF, ALBDS
Global Mean FLNT too small.
see also LWCF, TREFHT, TMQ
NHM-SHM FLNT too small.
see also LWCF, TREFHT, TMQ
NHM-SHM LHFLX too small.
OM-LM LHFLX too small.





FLNT PCor-ENSO,
see also LWCF, TREFHT, TMQ
SWCF PCor-ENSO,
see also ALBDS
LWCF PCor-ENSO,
PR PCor-ENSO,
TMQ PCor-ENSO,
LHFLX PCor-ENSO,
EP PCor-AM,
EP PCor-ENSO,
RTFS PCor-ENSO,
Z500 PCor-ENSO,
RELHUM992 PCor-ENSO,
OMEGA500 PCor-ENSO,
U10 PCor-ENSO,
PSL PCor-ENSO,