Overall, {sorted by Energy,Water,Dynamics scores*.}
*Scoring is based on mean of the pattern correlations for the annual mean, seasonal contrast, and ENSO teleconnections. COLOR TABLE SUMMARY
| Case ID | Benchmark Case | Notes | Flags | Improvements | Degradations |
CESM3dev_98b
0.80: 0.79; 0.76; 0.85
A; A; A | CESM2_1 | CESM3dev | NHM-SHM FSNT too small.
see also SWCF, ALBDS
OM-LM FSNT too large.
see also SWCF, ALBDS
OM-LM FLNT too large.
see also LWCF, TREFHT, TMQ
Global Mean LWCF too small.
Global Mean LHFLX too large.
OM-LM LHFLX too small.
|
|
FSNT PCor-ENSO,
see also SWCF, ALBDS
SWCF PCor-ENSO,
see also ALBDS
LHFLX PCor-ENSO,
RTFS PCor-ENSO,
|
CESM3dev_098
0.79: 0.79; 0.76; 0.83
A; A; A | CESM2_1 | CESM3dev | NHM-SHM FSNT too small.
see also SWCF, ALBDS
OM-LM FSNT too large.
see also SWCF, ALBDS
Global Mean LWCF too small.
Global Mean LHFLX too large.
OM-LM LHFLX too small.
|
|
FSNT PCor-ENSO,
see also SWCF, ALBDS
FLNT PCor-ENSO,
see also LWCF, TREFHT, TMQ
SWCF PCor-ENSO,
see also ALBDS
LWCF PCor-ENSO,
RTFS PCor-ENSO,
Z500 PCor-ENSO,
PSL PCor-ENSO,
|
CESM3dev_104
0.79: 0.78; 0.75; 0.84
A; A; A | CESM2_1 | CESM3dev | NHM-SHM FSNT too small.
see also SWCF, ALBDS
OM-LM FSNT too large.
see also SWCF, ALBDS
NHM-SHM SWCF too large.
see also ALBDS
Global Mean LWCF too small.
Global Mean LHFLX too large.
OM-LM LHFLX too small.
|
|
FSNT PCor-ENSO,
see also SWCF, ALBDS
FLNT PCor-ENSO,
see also LWCF, TREFHT, TMQ
SWCF PCor-ENSO,
see also ALBDS
LWCF PCor-ENSO,
LHFLX PCor-ENSO,
RTFS PCor-ENSO,
OMEGA500 PCor-ENSO,
|
CESM3dev_100pi
0.80: 0.82; 0.73; 0.87
A; A; A | CESM2_1 | CESM3dev | 0-2000m Ocean Drifting Warm
0-700m Ocean Drifting Warm
NHM-SHM FSNT too small.
see also SWCF, ALBDS
OM-LM FSNT too large.
see also SWCF, ALBDS
NHM-SHM SWCF too large.
see also ALBDS
Global Mean LWCF too small.
Global Mean LHFLX too large.
OM-LM LHFLX too small.
|
FSNT PCor-ENSO,
see also SWCF, ALBDS
|
|
CESM3dev_103pi
0.79: 0.82; 0.72; 0.84
A; A; A | CESM2_1 | CESM3dev | 0-2000m Ocean Drifting Warm
0-700m Ocean Drifting Warm
NHM-SHM FSNT too small.
see also SWCF, ALBDS
NHM-SHM SWCF too large.
see also ALBDS
Global Mean LWCF too small.
Global Mean LHFLX too large.
OM-LM LHFLX too small.
|
FSNT PCor-ENSO,
see also SWCF, ALBDS
|
Z500 PCor-ENSO,
RELHUM992 PCor-ENSO,
U10 PCor-ENSO,
PSL PCor-ENSO,
|
CESM3dev_099pi
0.79: 0.80; 0.72; 0.85
A; A; A | CESM2_1 | CESM3dev | NHM-SHM FSNT too small.
see also SWCF, ALBDS
OM-LM FSNT too large.
see also SWCF, ALBDS
NHM-SHM SWCF too large.
see also ALBDS
Global Mean LWCF too small.
Global Mean LHFLX too large.
OM-LM LHFLX too small.
|
FSNT PCor-ENSO,
see also SWCF, ALBDS
|
SWCF PCor-ENSO,
see also ALBDS
PSL PCor-ENSO,
|
CESM3dev_101pi
0.79: 0.81; 0.71; 0.85
A; A; A | CESM2_1 | CESM3dev | NHM-SHM FSNT too small.
see also SWCF, ALBDS
OM-LM FSNT too large.
see also SWCF, ALBDS
NHM-SHM SWCF too large.
see also ALBDS
Global Mean LWCF too small.
Global Mean LHFLX too large.
OM-LM LHFLX too small.
|
FSNT PCor-ENSO,
see also SWCF, ALBDS
|
SWCF PCor-ENSO,
see also ALBDS
U10 PCor-ENSO,
PSL PCor-ENSO,
|
CESM3dev_097pi
0.79: 0.81; 0.71; 0.84
A; A; A | CESM2_1 | CESM3dev | 0-2000m Ocean Drifting Cold
0-700m Ocean Drifting Cold
NHM-SHM FSNT too small.
see also SWCF, ALBDS
NHM-SHM SWCF too large.
see also ALBDS
Global Mean LWCF too small.
Global Mean LHFLX too large.
OM-LM LHFLX too small.
|
FSNT PCor-ENSO,
see also SWCF, ALBDS
|
LHFLX PCor-ENSO,
Z500 PCor-ENSO,
U10 PCor-ENSO,
PSL PCor-ENSO,
|
CESM3dev_080pi
0.77: 0.78; 0.71; 0.83
A; A; A | CESM2_1 | CESM3dev | 0-2000m Ocean Drifting Warm
0-700m Ocean Drifting Warm
NHM-SHM FSNT too small.
see also SWCF, ALBDS
OM-LM FSNT too large.
see also SWCF, ALBDS
NHM-SHM SWCF too large.
see also ALBDS
OM-LM SWCF too large.
see also ALBDS
Global Mean LWCF too small.
Global Mean LHFLX too large.
OM-LM LHFLX too small.
|
FSNT PCor-ENSO,
see also SWCF, ALBDS
|
SWCF PCor-AM,
see also ALBDS
SWCF PCor-ENSO,
see also ALBDS
LWCF PCor-AM,
PR PCor-AM,
EP PCor-AM,
Z500 PCor-AC,
U10 PCor-ENSO,
|
CESM3dev_102pi
0.78: 0.80; 0.70; 0.84
A; A; A | CESM2_1 | CESM3dev | 0-2000m Ocean Drifting Warm
0-700m Ocean Drifting Warm
NHM-SHM FSNT too small.
see also SWCF, ALBDS
Global Mean FLNT too large.
see also LWCF, TREFHT, TMQ
OM-LM FLNT too large.
see also LWCF, TREFHT, TMQ
NHM-SHM SWCF too large.
see also ALBDS
Global Mean LWCF too small.
Global Mean LHFLX too large.
OM-LM LHFLX too small.
|
FSNT PCor-ENSO,
see also SWCF, ALBDS
|
SWCF PCor-ENSO,
see also ALBDS
LHFLX PCor-ENSO,
Z500 PCor-ENSO,
RELHUM992 PCor-ENSO,
U10 PCor-ENSO,
|
CESM3dev_105pi
0.78: 0.79; 0.70; 0.85
A; A; A | CESM2_1 | CESM3dev | NHM-SHM FSNT too small.
see also SWCF, ALBDS
OM-LM FSNT too large.
see also SWCF, ALBDS
NHM-SHM SWCF too large.
see also ALBDS
Global Mean LWCF too small.
Global Mean LHFLX too large.
OM-LM LHFLX too small.
|
FSNT PCor-ENSO,
see also SWCF, ALBDS
|
FLNT PCor-ENSO,
see also LWCF, TREFHT, TMQ
SWCF PCor-ENSO,
see also ALBDS
LWCF PCor-ENSO,
PR PCor-ENSO,
EP PCor-ENSO,
Z500 PCor-ENSO,
OMEGA500 PCor-ENSO,
|
CESM3dev_079pi
0.78: 0.79; 0.70; 0.83
A; A; A | CESM2_1 | CESM3dev | 0-2000m Ocean Drifting Warm
0-700m Ocean Drifting Warm
NHM-SHM FSNT too small.
see also SWCF, ALBDS
NHM-SHM SWCF too large.
see also ALBDS
Global Mean LWCF too small.
Global Mean LHFLX too large.
NHM-SHM LHFLX too small.
OM-LM LHFLX too small.
|
FSNT PCor-ENSO,
see also SWCF, ALBDS
|
SWCF PCor-ENSO,
see also ALBDS
PR PCor-AM,
PR PCor-ENSO,
Z500 PCor-ENSO,
OMEGA500 PCor-ENSO,
U10 PCor-ENSO,
PSL PCor-ENSO,
|
CESM3dev_106pi
0.77: 0.78; 0.69; 0.83
A; A; A | CESM2_1 | CESM3dev | 0-2000m Ocean Drifting Warm
0-700m Ocean Drifting Warm
NHM-SHM FSNT too small.
see also SWCF, ALBDS
NHM-SHM SWCF too large.
see also ALBDS
Global Mean LWCF too small.
Global Mean LHFLX too large.
OM-LM LHFLX too small.
|
FSNT PCor-ENSO,
see also SWCF, ALBDS
|
FLNT PCor-ENSO,
see also LWCF, TREFHT, TMQ
SWCF PCor-ENSO,
see also ALBDS
LWCF PCor-ENSO,
PR PCor-ENSO,
LHFLX PCor-ENSO,
EP PCor-ENSO,
Z500 PCor-ENSO,
OMEGA500 PCor-ENSO,
U10 PCor-ENSO,
PSL PCor-ENSO,
|
CESM3dev_104pi
0.77: 0.78; 0.69; 0.83
A; A; A | CESM2_1 | CESM3dev | 0-2000m Ocean Drifting Cold
0-700m Ocean Drifting Cold
NHM-SHM FSNT too small.
see also SWCF, ALBDS
OM-LM FSNT too large.
see also SWCF, ALBDS
NHM-SHM SWCF too large.
see also ALBDS
Global Mean LHFLX too large.
OM-LM LHFLX too small.
|
FSNT PCor-ENSO,
see also SWCF, ALBDS
|
FLNT PCor-ENSO,
see also LWCF, TREFHT, TMQ
SWCF PCor-ENSO,
see also ALBDS
LWCF PCor-ENSO,
PR PCor-ENSO,
LHFLX PCor-ENSO,
EP PCor-ENSO,
Z500 PCor-ENSO,
OMEGA500 PCor-ENSO,
U10 PCor-ENSO,
PSL PCor-ENSO,
|
CESM3dev_110pi
0.77: 0.77; 0.69; 0.84
A; A; A | CESM2_1 | CESM3dev | NHM-SHM FSNT too small.
see also SWCF, ALBDS
OM-LM FSNT too large.
see also SWCF, ALBDS
NHM-SHM SWCF too large.
see also ALBDS
Global Mean LHFLX too large.
OM-LM LHFLX too small.
|
FSNT PCor-ENSO,
see also SWCF, ALBDS
|
FLNT PCor-ENSO,
see also LWCF, TREFHT, TMQ
SWCF PCor-ENSO,
see also ALBDS
LWCF PCor-ENSO,
PR PCor-ENSO,
LHFLX PCor-ENSO,
EP PCor-ENSO,
RTFS PCor-ENSO,
OMEGA500 PCor-ENSO,
U10 PCor-ENSO,
|
CESM3dev_078pi
0.76: 0.78; 0.68; 0.81
A; A; A | CESM2_1 | CESM3dev | 0-2000m Ocean Drifting Cold
0-700m Ocean Drifting Cold
NHM-SHM FSNT too small.
see also SWCF, ALBDS
NHM-SHM SWCF too large.
see also ALBDS
Global Mean LWCF too small.
Global Mean LHFLX too large.
NHM-SHM LHFLX too small.
OM-LM LHFLX too small.
|
FSNT PCor-ENSO,
see also SWCF, ALBDS
|
FLNT PCor-ENSO,
see also LWCF, TREFHT, TMQ
SWCF PCor-ENSO,
see also ALBDS
LWCF PCor-ENSO,
PR PCor-AM,
PR PCor-ENSO,
EP PCor-ENSO,
Z500 PCor-AC,
Z500 PCor-ENSO,
OMEGA500 PCor-ENSO,
U10 PCor-ENSO,
PSL PCor-ENSO,
|
CESM3dev_092pi
0.74: 0.74; 0.68; 0.80
A; A; A | CESM2_1 | CESM3dev | 0-700m Ocean Drifting Cold
NHM-SHM FSNT too small.
see also SWCF, ALBDS
NHM-SHM SWCF too large.
see also ALBDS
Global Mean LWCF too small.
Global Mean LHFLX too large.
OM-LM LHFLX too small.
|
|
FLNT PCor-ENSO,
see also LWCF, TREFHT, TMQ
SWCF PCor-ENSO,
see also ALBDS
LWCF PCor-ENSO,
PR PCor-ENSO,
EP PCor-ENSO,
RTFS PCor-ENSO,
Z500 PCor-ENSO,
OMEGA500 PCor-ENSO,
U10 PCor-ENSO,
PSL PCor-ENSO,
|
CESM3dev_109pi
0.75: 0.76; 0.68; 0.82
A; A; A | CESM2_1 | CESM3dev | NHM-SHM FSNT too small.
see also SWCF, ALBDS
OM-LM FSNT too large.
see also SWCF, ALBDS
NHM-SHM SWCF too large.
see also ALBDS
Global Mean LHFLX too large.
OM-LM LHFLX too small.
|
FSNT PCor-ENSO,
see also SWCF, ALBDS
|
FLNT PCor-ENSO,
see also LWCF, TREFHT, TMQ
SWCF PCor-ENSO,
see also ALBDS
LWCF PCor-ENSO,
PR PCor-ENSO,
TMQ PCor-ENSO,
LHFLX PCor-ENSO,
EP PCor-ENSO,
RTFS PCor-ENSO,
Z500 PCor-ENSO,
OMEGA500 PCor-ENSO,
U10 PCor-ENSO,
PSL PCor-ENSO,
|
