Overall, {sorted by Energy,Water,Dynamics scores*.}
*Scoring is based on mean of the pattern correlations for the annual mean, seasonal contrast, and ENSO teleconnections. COLOR TABLE SUMMARY
NetCDF files with data of plotted fields can be found in case directories in this compressed tarfile (10 GB).
| Case ID | Benchmark Case | Notes | Flags | Improvements | Degradations |
bccr_bcm2_0
0.71: 0.71; 0.73; 0.70
A; B; B | ncar_ccsm3_0 | cmip3 | Global Mean rsnt too small.
see also swcftoa, ALBDS
NHM-SHM rsnt too small.
see also swcftoa, ALBDS
OM-LM rsnt too large.
see also swcftoa, ALBDS
Global Mean rlut too small.
see also lwcftoa, tas, TMQ
OM-LM rlut too large.
see also lwcftoa, tas, TMQ
NHM-SHM hfls too small.
|
hfls PCor-ENSO,
hur925 PCor-AC,
hur925 PCor-ENSO,
psl PCor-AC,
|
rsnt PCor-ENSO,
see also swcftoa, ALBDS
rlut PCor-ENSO,
see also lwcftoa, tas, TMQ
pr PCor-ENSO,
ep PCor-ENSO,
hur500 PCor-AM,
|
cccma_cgcm3_1
0.73: 0.74; 0.75; 0.71
A; B; A | ncar_ccsm3_0 | cmip3 | NHM-SHM rsnt too small.
see also swcftoa, ALBDS
OM-LM rsnt too small.
see also swcftoa, ALBDS
NHM-SHM rlut too small.
see also lwcftoa, tas, TMQ
OM-LM rlut too large.
see also lwcftoa, tas, TMQ
OM-LM lwcftoa too small.
|
fs PCor-ENSO,
pr PCor-AM,
ep PCor-AM,
hur925 PCor-AC,
hur925 PCor-ENSO,
psl PCor-AC,
|
rlut PCor-ENSO,
see also lwcftoa, tas, TMQ
zg500 PCor-AC,
wap500 PCor-AM,
psl PCor-ENSO,
hur500 PCor-ENSO,
|
cccma_cgcm3_1_t63
0.76: 0.76; 0.77; 0.74
A; B; B | ncar_ccsm3_0 | cmip3 | Global Mean rsnt too small.
see also swcftoa, ALBDS
NHM-SHM rsnt too small.
see also swcftoa, ALBDS
OM-LM rsnt too small.
see also swcftoa, ALBDS
NHM-SHM rlut too small.
see also lwcftoa, tas, TMQ
|
fs PCor-ENSO,
pr PCor-AM,
hfls PCor-ENSO,
ep PCor-AM,
hur925 PCor-AC,
hur925 PCor-ENSO,
psl PCor-AC,
|
zg500 PCor-AC,
|
cnrm_cm3
0.73: 0.74; 0.72; 0.73
A; B; A | ncar_ccsm3_0 | cmip3 | Global Mean rsnt too small.
see also swcftoa, ALBDS
NHM-SHM rsnt too small.
see also swcftoa, ALBDS
OM-LM rsnt too large.
see also swcftoa, ALBDS
Global Mean rlut too small.
see also lwcftoa, tas, TMQ
OM-LM rlut too large.
see also lwcftoa, tas, TMQ
Global Mean swcftoa too small.
see also ALBDS
OM-LM swcftoa too large.
see also ALBDS
Global Mean lwcftoa too large.
NHM-SHM lwcftoa too small.
OM-LM lwcftoa too small.
Global Mean hfls too large.
|
fs PCor-ENSO,
hfls PCor-ENSO,
hur925 PCor-AC,
|
rlut PCor-ENSO,
see also lwcftoa, tas, TMQ
lwcftoa PCor-AM,
lwcftoa PCor-ENSO,
wap500 PCor-AM,
psl PCor-AM,
|
csiro_mk3_0
0.72: 0.74; 0.69; 0.73
A; A; A | ncar_ccsm3_0 | cmip3 | Global Mean rsnt too small.
see also swcftoa, ALBDS
NHM-SHM rsnt too small.
see also swcftoa, ALBDS
OM-LM rsnt too large.
see also swcftoa, ALBDS
Global Mean rlut too small.
see also lwcftoa, tas, TMQ
OM-LM rlut too large.
see also lwcftoa, tas, TMQ
OM-LM swcftoa too large.
see also ALBDS
Global Mean lwcftoa too large.
NHM-SHM lwcftoa too small.
OM-LM lwcftoa too small.
|
zg500 PCor-ENSO,
hur925 PCor-ENSO,
|
swcftoa PCor-AM,
see also ALBDS
lwcftoa PCor-AC,
ep PCor-ENSO,
zg500 PCor-AM,
zg500 PCor-AC,
|
csiro_mk3_5
0.75: 0.76; 0.73; 0.74
A; A; A | ncar_ccsm3_0 | cmip3 | NHM-SHM rsnt too small.
see also swcftoa, ALBDS
OM-LM rsnt too large.
see also swcftoa, ALBDS
NHM-SHM rlut too large.
see also lwcftoa, tas, TMQ
OM-LM rlut too large.
see also lwcftoa, tas, TMQ
Global Mean lwcftoa too large.
NHM-SHM lwcftoa too small.
OM-LM lwcftoa too small.
|
rsnt PCor-ENSO,
see also swcftoa, ALBDS
lwcftoa PCor-ENSO,
pr PCor-AM,
pr PCor-ENSO,
ep PCor-AM,
zg500 PCor-ENSO,
hur925 PCor-ENSO,
|
zg500 PCor-AC,
|
gfdl_cm2_0
0.78: 0.80; 0.75; 0.81
A; A; A | ncar_ccsm3_0 | cmip3 | Global Mean rsnt too small.
see also swcftoa, ALBDS
NHM-SHM rsnt too small.
see also swcftoa, ALBDS
Global Mean rlut too small.
see also lwcftoa, tas, TMQ
NHM-SHM rlut too small.
see also lwcftoa, tas, TMQ
Global Mean swcftoa too small.
see also ALBDS
|
rsnt PCor-ENSO,
see also swcftoa, ALBDS
swcftoa PCor-ENSO,
see also ALBDS
fs PCor-ENSO,
pr PCor-AM,
pr PCor-AC,
hfls PCor-ENSO,
ep PCor-AM,
zg500 PCor-ENSO,
hur925 PCor-ENSO,
wap500 PCor-AM,
wap500 PCor-AC,
psl PCor-AC,
|
|
gfdl_cm2_1
0.76: 0.76; 0.72; 0.80
A; A; A | ncar_ccsm3_0 | cmip3 | Global Mean rsnt too small.
see also swcftoa, ALBDS
NHM-SHM rsnt too small.
see also swcftoa, ALBDS
Global Mean rlut too small.
see also lwcftoa, tas, TMQ
NHM-SHM rlut too small.
see also lwcftoa, tas, TMQ
|
pr PCor-AM,
pr PCor-AC,
pr PCor-ENSO,
zg500 PCor-ENSO,
hur925 PCor-ENSO,
psl PCor-AC,
|
|
giss_aom
0.59: 0.65; 0.63; 0.49
A; A; A | ncar_ccsm3_0 | cmip3 | Global Mean rsnt too small.
see also swcftoa, ALBDS
NHM-SHM rsnt too small.
see also swcftoa, ALBDS
OM-LM rsnt too large.
see also swcftoa, ALBDS
Global Mean rlut too small.
see also lwcftoa, tas, TMQ
|
|
rsnt PCor-ENSO,
see also swcftoa, ALBDS
rlut PCor-ENSO,
see also lwcftoa, tas, TMQ
fs PCor-AM,
pr PCor-AC,
prw PCor-ENSO,
hfls PCor-AM,
hfls PCor-AC,
hfls PCor-ENSO,
ep PCor-AM,
ep PCor-AC,
ep PCor-ENSO,
rtfs PCor-AM,
rtfs PCor-AC,
rtfs PCor-ENSO,
zg500 PCor-AM,
zg500 PCor-AC,
zg500 PCor-ENSO,
wap500 PCor-AM,
wap500 PCor-AC,
wap500 PCor-ENSO,
psl PCor-AM,
psl PCor-AC,
psl PCor-ENSO,
|
giss_model_e_h
0.47: 0.57; 0.55; 0.28
N/A; N/A; N/A | ncar_ccsm3_0 | cmip3 | NHM-SHM rsnt too small.
see also swcftoa, ALBDS
OM-LM rsnt too large.
see also swcftoa, ALBDS
NHM-SHM rlut too small.
see also lwcftoa, tas, TMQ
OM-LM swcftoa too large.
see also ALBDS
NHM-SHM hfls too small.
|
|
rsnt PCor-ENSO,
see also swcftoa, ALBDS
rlut PCor-ENSO,
see also lwcftoa, tas, TMQ
swcftoa PCor-AM,
see also ALBDS
swcftoa PCor-ENSO,
see also ALBDS
lwcftoa PCor-AM,
lwcftoa PCor-AC,
lwcftoa PCor-ENSO,
pr PCor-AM,
pr PCor-AC,
pr PCor-ENSO,
prw PCor-ENSO,
hfls PCor-AC,
ep PCor-AM,
ep PCor-AC,
ep PCor-ENSO,
zg500 PCor-AM,
zg500 PCor-AC,
zg500 PCor-ENSO,
hur925 PCor-ENSO,
wap500 PCor-AM,
wap500 PCor-AC,
wap500 PCor-ENSO,
psl PCor-AM,
psl PCor-ENSO,
hur500 PCor-AM,
hur500 PCor-AC,
hur500 PCor-ENSO,
|
giss_model_e_r
0.61: 0.70; 0.60; 0.53
A; A; A | ncar_ccsm3_0 | cmip3 | Global Mean rsnt too small.
see also swcftoa, ALBDS
NHM-SHM rsnt too small.
see also swcftoa, ALBDS
OM-LM rsnt too large.
see also swcftoa, ALBDS
NHM-SHM rlut too small.
see also lwcftoa, tas, TMQ
OM-LM swcftoa too large.
see also ALBDS
NHM-SHM hfls too small.
|
|
rlut PCor-ENSO,
see also lwcftoa, tas, TMQ
swcftoa PCor-AM,
see also ALBDS
swcftoa PCor-AC,
see also ALBDS
swcftoa PCor-ENSO,
see also ALBDS
lwcftoa PCor-AM,
lwcftoa PCor-AC,
lwcftoa PCor-ENSO,
prw PCor-ENSO,
hfls PCor-AC,
hfls PCor-ENSO,
ep PCor-AM,
ep PCor-AC,
zg500 PCor-AM,
zg500 PCor-AC,
zg500 PCor-ENSO,
hur925 PCor-ENSO,
wap500 PCor-AM,
wap500 PCor-AC,
wap500 PCor-ENSO,
psl PCor-AM,
psl PCor-ENSO,
hur500 PCor-AM,
hur500 PCor-AC,
hur500 PCor-ENSO,
|
iap_fgoals1_0_g
0.70: 0.72; 0.68; 0.69
A; B; A | ncar_ccsm3_0 | cmip3 | Global Mean rsnt too large.
see also swcftoa, ALBDS
NHM-SHM rsnt too small.
see also swcftoa, ALBDS
OM-LM rsnt too large.
see also swcftoa, ALBDS
Global Mean rlut too small.
see also lwcftoa, tas, TMQ
NHM-SHM rlut too small.
see also lwcftoa, tas, TMQ
OM-LM rlut too large.
see also lwcftoa, tas, TMQ
NHM-SHM lwcftoa too small.
NHM-SHM hfls too small.
|
fs PCor-ENSO,
hfls PCor-ENSO,
hur925 PCor-ENSO,
psl PCor-ENSO,
|
swcftoa PCor-AM,
see also ALBDS
lwcftoa PCor-AC,
fs PCor-AM,
pr PCor-AC,
ep PCor-AM,
ep PCor-AC,
rtfs PCor-AC,
zg500 PCor-AM,
zg500 PCor-AC,
wap500 PCor-AM,
wap500 PCor-AC,
hur500 PCor-AC,
|
ingv_echam4
0.74: 0.73; 0.74; 0.75
A; A; B | ncar_ccsm3_0 | cmip3 | Global Mean rlut too small.
see also lwcftoa, tas, TMQ
OM-LM rlut too large.
see also lwcftoa, tas, TMQ
|
hfls PCor-ENSO,
hur925 PCor-AC,
hur925 PCor-ENSO,
psl PCor-AC,
|
pr PCor-ENSO,
ep PCor-ENSO,
wap500 PCor-ENSO,
hur500 PCor-ENSO,
|
mpi_echam5
0.76: 0.77; 0.76; 0.74
A; A; B | ncar_ccsm3_0 | cmip3 | Global Mean rsnt too small.
see also swcftoa, ALBDS
NHM-SHM rsnt too small.
see also swcftoa, ALBDS
Global Mean rlut too small.
see also lwcftoa, tas, TMQ
NHM-SHM rlut too small.
see also lwcftoa, tas, TMQ
Global Mean swcftoa too small.
see also ALBDS
|
swcftoa PCor-AM,
see also ALBDS
hfls PCor-ENSO,
hur925 PCor-AC,
wap500 PCor-AC,
psl PCor-AC,
|
|
inmcm3_0
0.61: 0.59; 0.60; 0.63
N/A; N/A; N/A | ncar_ccsm3_0 | cmip3 | NHM-SHM rsnt too small.
see also swcftoa, ALBDS
OM-LM rsnt too large.
see also swcftoa, ALBDS
Global Mean rlut too small.
see also lwcftoa, tas, TMQ
NHM-SHM rlut too small.
see also lwcftoa, tas, TMQ
OM-LM rlut too large.
see also lwcftoa, tas, TMQ
|
hur925 PCor-AC,
|
rsnt PCor-ENSO,
see also swcftoa, ALBDS
rlut PCor-AM,
see also lwcftoa, tas, TMQ
rlut PCor-ENSO,
see also lwcftoa, tas, TMQ
swcftoa PCor-ENSO,
see also ALBDS
lwcftoa PCor-AM,
lwcftoa PCor-AC,
lwcftoa PCor-ENSO,
fs PCor-AM,
pr PCor-AM,
pr PCor-AC,
pr PCor-ENSO,
prw PCor-ENSO,
ep PCor-AM,
ep PCor-AC,
ep PCor-ENSO,
rtfs PCor-AC,
rtfs PCor-ENSO,
zg500 PCor-ENSO,
hur925 PCor-ENSO,
wap500 PCor-AM,
wap500 PCor-AC,
psl PCor-ENSO,
hur500 PCor-AM,
hur500 PCor-AC,
hur500 PCor-ENSO,
|
ipsl_cm4
0.67: 0.67; 0.67; 0.67
A; A; A | ncar_ccsm3_0 | cmip3 | Global Mean rsnt too small.
see also swcftoa, ALBDS
NHM-SHM rsnt too small.
see also swcftoa, ALBDS
OM-LM rsnt too large.
see also swcftoa, ALBDS
Global Mean rlut too small.
see also lwcftoa, tas, TMQ
NHM-SHM rlut too small.
see also lwcftoa, tas, TMQ
OM-LM rlut too large.
see also lwcftoa, tas, TMQ
Global Mean swcftoa too small.
see also ALBDS
OM-LM swcftoa too large.
see also ALBDS
|
fs PCor-ENSO,
hfls PCor-ENSO,
|
rlut PCor-AC,
see also lwcftoa, tas, TMQ
lwcftoa PCor-AC,
fs PCor-AM,
fs PCor-AC,
pr PCor-AC,
rtfs PCor-AM,
rtfs PCor-AC,
zg500 PCor-AM,
zg500 PCor-AC,
wap500 PCor-AM,
wap500 PCor-AC,
psl PCor-AM,
|
miroc3_2_hires
0.70: 0.69; 0.67; 0.73
B; B; B | ncar_ccsm3_0 | cmip3 | NHM-SHM rsnt too small.
see also swcftoa, ALBDS
OM-LM rsnt too large.
see also swcftoa, ALBDS
NHM-SHM swcftoa too large.
see also ALBDS
OM-LM swcftoa too large.
see also ALBDS
|
pr PCor-AM,
hfls PCor-AC,
ep PCor-AM,
wap500 PCor-AM,
wap500 PCor-AC,
psl PCor-AC,
|
rsnt PCor-ENSO,
see also swcftoa, ALBDS
rlut PCor-ENSO,
see also lwcftoa, tas, TMQ
swcftoa PCor-ENSO,
see also ALBDS
lwcftoa PCor-ENSO,
prw PCor-ENSO,
ep PCor-ENSO,
rtfs PCor-ENSO,
wap500 PCor-ENSO,
psl PCor-ENSO,
hur500 PCor-ENSO,
|
miroc3_2_medres
0.71: 0.71; 0.69; 0.73
A; A; A | ncar_ccsm3_0 | cmip3 | Global Mean rsnt too small.
see also swcftoa, ALBDS
NHM-SHM rsnt too small.
see also swcftoa, ALBDS
OM-LM rsnt too large.
see also swcftoa, ALBDS
Global Mean rlut too small.
see also lwcftoa, tas, TMQ
Global Mean swcftoa too small.
see also ALBDS
NHM-SHM swcftoa too large.
see also ALBDS
OM-LM swcftoa too large.
see also ALBDS
|
pr PCor-AM,
pr PCor-ENSO,
psl PCor-AC,
|
rsnt PCor-ENSO,
see also swcftoa, ALBDS
swcftoa PCor-AM,
see also ALBDS
swcftoa PCor-ENSO,
see also ALBDS
psl PCor-ENSO,
|
miub_echo_g
0.75: 0.79; 0.75; 0.70
A; A; A | ncar_ccsm3_0 | cmip3 | NHM-SHM rsnt too small.
see also swcftoa, ALBDS
OM-LM rsnt too large.
see also swcftoa, ALBDS
Global Mean rlut too small.
see also lwcftoa, tas, TMQ
NHM-SHM rlut too small.
see also lwcftoa, tas, TMQ
|
rsnt PCor-ENSO,
see also swcftoa, ALBDS
swcftoa PCor-ENSO,
see also ALBDS
fs PCor-ENSO,
pr PCor-AM,
pr PCor-ENSO,
hfls PCor-ENSO,
ep PCor-AM,
ep PCor-ENSO,
rtfs PCor-ENSO,
psl PCor-AC,
|
lwcftoa PCor-AC,
fs PCor-AM,
|
mri_cgcm2_3_2a
0.76: 0.76; 0.74; 0.76
A; B; A | ncar_ccsm3_0 | cmip3 | NHM-SHM rsnt too small.
see also swcftoa, ALBDS
OM-LM rsnt too large.
see also swcftoa, ALBDS
Global Mean rlut too small.
see also lwcftoa, tas, TMQ
NHM-SHM rlut too small.
see also lwcftoa, tas, TMQ
OM-LM rlut too large.
see also lwcftoa, tas, TMQ
OM-LM swcftoa too large.
see also ALBDS
Global Mean lwcftoa too small.
|
rsnt PCor-ENSO,
see also swcftoa, ALBDS
fs PCor-ENSO,
pr PCor-AM,
pr PCor-ENSO,
hfls PCor-ENSO,
ep PCor-AM,
ep PCor-ENSO,
rtfs PCor-ENSO,
zg500 PCor-ENSO,
hur925 PCor-ENSO,
wap500 PCor-AM,
wap500 PCor-ENSO,
psl PCor-AC,
|
lwcftoa PCor-AC,
hur500 PCor-AM,
hur500 PCor-AC,
|
ncar_ccsm3_0
0.73: 0.76; 0.68; 0.75
A; B; A | ncar_ccsm3_0 | cmip3 | Global Mean rsnt too small.
see also swcftoa, ALBDS
NHM-SHM rsnt too small.
see also swcftoa, ALBDS
OM-LM rsnt too large.
see also swcftoa, ALBDS
Global Mean rlut too small.
see also lwcftoa, tas, TMQ
OM-LM rlut too large.
see also lwcftoa, tas, TMQ
Global Mean swcftoa too small.
see also ALBDS
|
|
|
ncar_pcm1
0.62: 0.70; 0.63; 0.52
A; A; A | ncar_ccsm3_0 | cmip3 | NHM-SHM rsnt too small.
see also swcftoa, ALBDS
OM-LM rsnt too small.
see also swcftoa, ALBDS
Global Mean swcftoa too small.
see also ALBDS
Global Mean hfls too large.
|
|
rlut PCor-AC,
see also lwcftoa, tas, TMQ
swcftoa PCor-AM,
see also ALBDS
lwcftoa PCor-AM,
lwcftoa PCor-AC,
pr PCor-AM,
pr PCor-AC,
hfls PCor-AC,
ep PCor-AM,
ep PCor-AC,
zg500 PCor-AM,
zg500 PCor-AC,
hur925 PCor-AM,
wap500 PCor-AM,
wap500 PCor-AC,
hur500 PCor-AM,
hur500 PCor-AC,
hur500 PCor-ENSO,
|
ukmo_hadcm3
0.74: 0.73; 0.75; 0.74
A; B; A | ncar_ccsm3_0 | cmip3 | NHM-SHM rsnt too small.
see also swcftoa, ALBDS
Global Mean lwcftoa too small.
NHM-SHM hfls too small.
|
pr PCor-AM,
pr PCor-AC,
hfls PCor-ENSO,
hur925 PCor-AC,
psl PCor-AC,
|
rlut PCor-ENSO,
see also lwcftoa, tas, TMQ
lwcftoa PCor-ENSO,
fs PCor-AM,
|
ukmo_hadgem1
0.69: 0.69; 0.67; 0.70
A; A; A | ncar_ccsm3_0 | cmip3 | NHM-SHM rsnt too small.
see also swcftoa, ALBDS
OM-LM rsnt too large.
see also swcftoa, ALBDS
OM-LM rlut too large.
see also lwcftoa, tas, TMQ
OM-LM swcftoa too large.
see also ALBDS
Global Mean hfls too large.
NHM-SHM hfls too small.
|
swcftoa PCor-AM,
see also ALBDS
pr PCor-AM,
ep PCor-AC,
zg500 PCor-AM,
wap500 PCor-AC,
psl PCor-AC,
|
rsnt PCor-ENSO,
see also swcftoa, ALBDS
rlut PCor-ENSO,
see also lwcftoa, tas, TMQ
swcftoa PCor-ENSO,
see also ALBDS
lwcftoa PCor-ENSO,
pr PCor-ENSO,
ep PCor-ENSO,
rtfs PCor-ENSO,
wap500 PCor-ENSO,
psl PCor-ENSO,
hur500 PCor-ENSO,
|
