CMAT logo

Created: Mon Jul 22 14:15:10 2019
CMAT Version 1; Methodology

CMAT 1.0 CMIP3 Repository



Overall, {sorted by Energy,Water,Dynamics scores*.}
*Scoring is based on mean of the pattern correlations for the annual mean, seasonal contrast, and ENSO teleconnections. COLOR TABLE SUMMARY

CMIP3 Archive
Case IDBenchmark CaseNotesFlagsImprovementsDegradations
cccma_cgcm3_1_t63
0.74: 0.76; 0.73; 0.74
A; B; B
ncar_ccsm3_0CMIP3 Global Mean rsnt too small.
see also swcftoa, ALBDS
NHM-SHM rsnt too small.
see also swcftoa, ALBDS
OM-LM rsnt too small.
see also swcftoa, ALBDS
NHM-SHM rlut too small.
see also lwcftoa, tas, TMQ


fs PCor-ENSO,
pr PCor-AM,
hfls PCor-ENSO,
ep PCor-AM,
hur925 PCor-AC,
hur925 PCor-ENSO,
psl PCor-AC,



zg500 PCor-AC,
mpi_echam5
0.74: 0.76; 0.72; 0.74
A; A; B
ncar_ccsm3_0CMIP3 Global Mean rsnt too small.
see also swcftoa, ALBDS
NHM-SHM rsnt too small.
see also swcftoa, ALBDS
Global Mean rlut too small.
see also lwcftoa, tas, TMQ
NHM-SHM rlut too small.
see also lwcftoa, tas, TMQ
Global Mean swcftoa too small.
see also ALBDS


swcftoa PCor-AM,
see also ALBDS
hfls PCor-ENSO,
hur925 PCor-AC,
wap500 PCor-AC,
psl PCor-AC,



cccma_cgcm3_1
0.72: 0.74; 0.72; 0.71
A; B; A
ncar_ccsm3_0CMIP3 NHM-SHM rsnt too small.
see also swcftoa, ALBDS
OM-LM rsnt too small.
see also swcftoa, ALBDS
NHM-SHM rlut too small.
see also lwcftoa, tas, TMQ
OM-LM rlut too large.
see also lwcftoa, tas, TMQ
OM-LM lwcftoa too small.


fs PCor-ENSO,
pr PCor-AM,
ep PCor-AM,
hur925 PCor-AC,
hur925 PCor-ENSO,
psl PCor-AC,



rlut PCor-ENSO,
see also lwcftoa, tas, TMQ
zg500 PCor-AC,
wap500 PCor-AM,
psl PCor-ENSO,
hur500 PCor-ENSO,
miub_echo_g
0.73: 0.79; 0.71; 0.70
A; A; A
ncar_ccsm3_0CMIP3 NHM-SHM rsnt too small.
see also swcftoa, ALBDS
OM-LM rsnt too large.
see also swcftoa, ALBDS
Global Mean rlut too small.
see also lwcftoa, tas, TMQ
NHM-SHM rlut too small.
see also lwcftoa, tas, TMQ


rsnt PCor-ENSO,
see also swcftoa, ALBDS
swcftoa PCor-ENSO,
see also ALBDS
fs PCor-ENSO,
pr PCor-AM,
pr PCor-ENSO,
hfls PCor-ENSO,
ep PCor-AM,
ep PCor-ENSO,
rtfs PCor-ENSO,
psl PCor-AC,



lwcftoa PCor-AC,
fs PCor-AM,
ukmo_hadcm3
0.72: 0.72; 0.71; 0.74
A; B; A
ncar_ccsm3_0CMIP3 NHM-SHM rsnt too small.
see also swcftoa, ALBDS
Global Mean lwcftoa too small.
NHM-SHM hfls too small.


pr PCor-AM,
pr PCor-AC,
hfls PCor-ENSO,
hur925 PCor-AC,
psl PCor-AC,



rlut PCor-ENSO,
see also lwcftoa, tas, TMQ
lwcftoa PCor-ENSO,
fs PCor-AM,
gfdl_cm2_0
0.77: 0.80; 0.70; 0.80
A; A; A
ncar_ccsm3_0CMIP3 Global Mean rsnt too small.
see also swcftoa, ALBDS
NHM-SHM rsnt too small.
see also swcftoa, ALBDS
Global Mean rlut too small.
see also lwcftoa, tas, TMQ
NHM-SHM rlut too small.
see also lwcftoa, tas, TMQ
Global Mean swcftoa too small.
see also ALBDS


rsnt PCor-ENSO,
see also swcftoa, ALBDS
swcftoa PCor-ENSO,
see also ALBDS
fs PCor-ENSO,
pr PCor-AM,
pr PCor-AC,
hfls PCor-ENSO,
ep PCor-AM,
zg500 PCor-ENSO,
hur925 PCor-ENSO,
wap500 PCor-AM,
wap500 PCor-AC,
psl PCor-AC,



ingv_echam4
0.72: 0.73; 0.70; 0.75
A; A; B
ncar_ccsm3_0CMIP3 Global Mean rlut too small.
see also lwcftoa, tas, TMQ
OM-LM rlut too large.
see also lwcftoa, tas, TMQ


hfls PCor-ENSO,
hur925 PCor-AC,
hur925 PCor-ENSO,
psl PCor-AC,



pr PCor-ENSO,
ep PCor-ENSO,
wap500 PCor-ENSO,
hur500 PCor-ENSO,
mri_cgcm2_3_2a
0.74: 0.76; 0.70; 0.76
A; B; A
ncar_ccsm3_0CMIP3 NHM-SHM rsnt too small.
see also swcftoa, ALBDS
OM-LM rsnt too large.
see also swcftoa, ALBDS
Global Mean rlut too small.
see also lwcftoa, tas, TMQ
NHM-SHM rlut too small.
see also lwcftoa, tas, TMQ
OM-LM rlut too large.
see also lwcftoa, tas, TMQ
OM-LM swcftoa too large.
see also ALBDS
Global Mean lwcftoa too small.


rsnt PCor-ENSO,
see also swcftoa, ALBDS
fs PCor-ENSO,
pr PCor-AM,
pr PCor-ENSO,
hfls PCor-ENSO,
ep PCor-AM,
ep PCor-ENSO,
rtfs PCor-ENSO,
zg500 PCor-ENSO,
hur925 PCor-ENSO,
wap500 PCor-AM,
wap500 PCor-ENSO,
psl PCor-AC,



lwcftoa PCor-AC,
hur500 PCor-AM,
hur500 PCor-AC,
bccr_bcm2_0
0.70: 0.70; 0.69; 0.70
A; B; B
ncar_ccsm3_0CMIP3 Global Mean rsnt too small.
see also swcftoa, ALBDS
NHM-SHM rsnt too small.
see also swcftoa, ALBDS
OM-LM rsnt too large.
see also swcftoa, ALBDS
Global Mean rlut too small.
see also lwcftoa, tas, TMQ
OM-LM rlut too large.
see also lwcftoa, tas, TMQ
NHM-SHM hfls too small.


hfls PCor-ENSO,
hur925 PCor-AC,
hur925 PCor-ENSO,
psl PCor-AC,



rsnt PCor-ENSO,
see also swcftoa, ALBDS
rlut PCor-ENSO,
see also lwcftoa, tas, TMQ
pr PCor-ENSO,
ep PCor-ENSO,
hur500 PCor-AM,
cnrm_cm3
0.72: 0.74; 0.68; 0.73
A; B; A
ncar_ccsm3_0CMIP3 Global Mean rsnt too small.
see also swcftoa, ALBDS
NHM-SHM rsnt too small.
see also swcftoa, ALBDS
OM-LM rsnt too large.
see also swcftoa, ALBDS
Global Mean rlut too small.
see also lwcftoa, tas, TMQ
OM-LM rlut too large.
see also lwcftoa, tas, TMQ
Global Mean swcftoa too small.
see also ALBDS
OM-LM swcftoa too large.
see also ALBDS
Global Mean lwcftoa too large.
NHM-SHM lwcftoa too small.
OM-LM lwcftoa too small.
Global Mean hfls too large.


fs PCor-ENSO,
hfls PCor-ENSO,
hur925 PCor-AC,



rlut PCor-ENSO,
see also lwcftoa, tas, TMQ
lwcftoa PCor-AM,
lwcftoa PCor-ENSO,
wap500 PCor-AM,
psl PCor-AM,
csiro_mk3_5
0.73: 0.76; 0.68; 0.74
A; A; A
ncar_ccsm3_0CMIP3 NHM-SHM rsnt too small.
see also swcftoa, ALBDS
OM-LM rsnt too large.
see also swcftoa, ALBDS
NHM-SHM rlut too large.
see also lwcftoa, tas, TMQ
OM-LM rlut too large.
see also lwcftoa, tas, TMQ
Global Mean lwcftoa too large.
NHM-SHM lwcftoa too small.
OM-LM lwcftoa too small.


rsnt PCor-ENSO,
see also swcftoa, ALBDS
lwcftoa PCor-ENSO,
pr PCor-AM,
pr PCor-ENSO,
ep PCor-AM,
zg500 PCor-ENSO,
hur925 PCor-ENSO,



zg500 PCor-AC,
gfdl_cm2_1
0.74: 0.76; 0.67; 0.80
A; A; A
ncar_ccsm3_0CMIP3 Global Mean rsnt too small.
see also swcftoa, ALBDS
NHM-SHM rsnt too small.
see also swcftoa, ALBDS
Global Mean rlut too small.
see also lwcftoa, tas, TMQ
NHM-SHM rlut too small.
see also lwcftoa, tas, TMQ


pr PCor-AM,
pr PCor-AC,
pr PCor-ENSO,
zg500 PCor-ENSO,
hur925 PCor-ENSO,
psl PCor-AC,



miroc3_2_medres
0.70: 0.71; 0.65; 0.73
A; A; A
ncar_ccsm3_0CMIP3 Global Mean rsnt too small.
see also swcftoa, ALBDS
NHM-SHM rsnt too small.
see also swcftoa, ALBDS
OM-LM rsnt too large.
see also swcftoa, ALBDS
Global Mean rlut too small.
see also lwcftoa, tas, TMQ
Global Mean swcftoa too small.
see also ALBDS
NHM-SHM swcftoa too large.
see also ALBDS
OM-LM swcftoa too large.
see also ALBDS


pr PCor-AM,
pr PCor-ENSO,
psl PCor-AC,



rsnt PCor-ENSO,
see also swcftoa, ALBDS
swcftoa PCor-AM,
see also ALBDS
swcftoa PCor-ENSO,
see also ALBDS
psl PCor-ENSO,
csiro_mk3_0
0.70: 0.74; 0.64; 0.73
A; A; B
ncar_ccsm3_0CMIP3 Global Mean rsnt too small.
see also swcftoa, ALBDS
NHM-SHM rsnt too small.
see also swcftoa, ALBDS
OM-LM rsnt too large.
see also swcftoa, ALBDS
Global Mean rlut too small.
see also lwcftoa, tas, TMQ
OM-LM rlut too large.
see also lwcftoa, tas, TMQ
OM-LM swcftoa too large.
see also ALBDS
Global Mean lwcftoa too large.
NHM-SHM lwcftoa too small.
OM-LM lwcftoa too small.


zg500 PCor-ENSO,
hur925 PCor-ENSO,



swcftoa PCor-AM,
see also ALBDS
lwcftoa PCor-AC,
ep PCor-ENSO,
zg500 PCor-AM,
zg500 PCor-AC,
iap_fgoals1_0_g
0.68: 0.72; 0.63; 0.69
A; B; A
ncar_ccsm3_0CMIP3 Global Mean rsnt too large.
see also swcftoa, ALBDS
NHM-SHM rsnt too small.
see also swcftoa, ALBDS
OM-LM rsnt too large.
see also swcftoa, ALBDS
Global Mean rlut too small.
see also lwcftoa, tas, TMQ
NHM-SHM rlut too small.
see also lwcftoa, tas, TMQ
OM-LM rlut too large.
see also lwcftoa, tas, TMQ
NHM-SHM lwcftoa too small.
NHM-SHM hfls too small.


fs PCor-ENSO,
hfls PCor-ENSO,
hur925 PCor-ENSO,
psl PCor-ENSO,



swcftoa PCor-AM,
see also ALBDS
lwcftoa PCor-AC,
fs PCor-AM,
pr PCor-AC,
ep PCor-AM,
ep PCor-AC,
rtfs PCor-AC,
zg500 PCor-AM,
zg500 PCor-AC,
wap500 PCor-AM,
wap500 PCor-AC,
hur500 PCor-AC,
miroc3_2_hires
0.68: 0.69; 0.63; 0.72
A; B; B
ncar_ccsm3_0CMIP3 NHM-SHM rsnt too small.
see also swcftoa, ALBDS
OM-LM rsnt too large.
see also swcftoa, ALBDS
NHM-SHM swcftoa too large.
see also ALBDS
OM-LM swcftoa too large.
see also ALBDS


pr PCor-AM,
hfls PCor-AC,
ep PCor-AM,
wap500 PCor-AM,
wap500 PCor-AC,
psl PCor-AC,



rsnt PCor-ENSO,
see also swcftoa, ALBDS
rlut PCor-ENSO,
see also lwcftoa, tas, TMQ
swcftoa PCor-ENSO,
see also ALBDS
lwcftoa PCor-ENSO,
ep PCor-ENSO,
rtfs PCor-ENSO,
wap500 PCor-ENSO,
psl PCor-ENSO,
hur500 PCor-ENSO,
ncar_ccsm3_0
0.71: 0.76; 0.62; 0.75
A; B; A
ncar_ccsm3_0CMIP3 Global Mean rsnt too small.
see also swcftoa, ALBDS
NHM-SHM rsnt too small.
see also swcftoa, ALBDS
OM-LM rsnt too large.
see also swcftoa, ALBDS
Global Mean rlut too small.
see also lwcftoa, tas, TMQ
OM-LM rlut too large.
see also lwcftoa, tas, TMQ
Global Mean swcftoa too small.
see also ALBDS





ukmo_hadgem1
0.67: 0.68; 0.62; 0.69
A; A; A
ncar_ccsm3_0CMIP3 NHM-SHM rsnt too small.
see also swcftoa, ALBDS
OM-LM rsnt too large.
see also swcftoa, ALBDS
OM-LM rlut too large.
see also lwcftoa, tas, TMQ
OM-LM swcftoa too large.
see also ALBDS
Global Mean hfls too large.
NHM-SHM hfls too small.


swcftoa PCor-AM,
see also ALBDS
pr PCor-AM,
ep PCor-AC,
zg500 PCor-AM,
wap500 PCor-AC,
psl PCor-AC,



rsnt PCor-ENSO,
see also swcftoa, ALBDS
rlut PCor-ENSO,
see also lwcftoa, tas, TMQ
swcftoa PCor-ENSO,
see also ALBDS
lwcftoa PCor-ENSO,
pr PCor-ENSO,
ep PCor-ENSO,
rtfs PCor-ENSO,
wap500 PCor-ENSO,
psl PCor-ENSO,
hur500 PCor-ENSO,
ipsl_cm4
0.65: 0.67; 0.62; 0.67
A; A; A
ncar_ccsm3_0CMIP3 Global Mean rsnt too small.
see also swcftoa, ALBDS
NHM-SHM rsnt too small.
see also swcftoa, ALBDS
OM-LM rsnt too large.
see also swcftoa, ALBDS
Global Mean rlut too small.
see also lwcftoa, tas, TMQ
NHM-SHM rlut too small.
see also lwcftoa, tas, TMQ
OM-LM rlut too large.
see also lwcftoa, tas, TMQ
Global Mean swcftoa too small.
see also ALBDS
OM-LM swcftoa too large.
see also ALBDS


fs PCor-ENSO,
hfls PCor-ENSO,



rlut PCor-AC,
see also lwcftoa, tas, TMQ
lwcftoa PCor-AC,
fs PCor-AM,
fs PCor-AC,
pr PCor-AC,
rtfs PCor-AM,
rtfs PCor-AC,
zg500 PCor-AM,
zg500 PCor-AC,
wap500 PCor-AM,
wap500 PCor-AC,
psl PCor-AM,
giss_aom
0.58: 0.65; 0.59; 0.49
A; A; A
ncar_ccsm3_0CMIP3 Global Mean rsnt too small.
see also swcftoa, ALBDS
NHM-SHM rsnt too small.
see also swcftoa, ALBDS
OM-LM rsnt too large.
see also swcftoa, ALBDS
Global Mean rlut too small.
see also lwcftoa, tas, TMQ





rsnt PCor-ENSO,
see also swcftoa, ALBDS
rlut PCor-ENSO,
see also lwcftoa, tas, TMQ
fs PCor-AM,
pr PCor-AC,
hfls PCor-AM,
hfls PCor-AC,
hfls PCor-ENSO,
ep PCor-AM,
ep PCor-AC,
ep PCor-ENSO,
rtfs PCor-AM,
rtfs PCor-AC,
rtfs PCor-ENSO,
zg500 PCor-AM,
zg500 PCor-AC,
zg500 PCor-ENSO,
wap500 PCor-AM,
wap500 PCor-AC,
wap500 PCor-ENSO,
psl PCor-AM,
psl PCor-AC,
psl PCor-ENSO,
ncar_pcm1
0.59: 0.70; 0.57; 0.52
A; A; N/A
ncar_ccsm3_0CMIP3 NHM-SHM rsnt too small.
see also swcftoa, ALBDS
OM-LM rsnt too small.
see also swcftoa, ALBDS
Global Mean swcftoa too small.
see also ALBDS
Global Mean hfls too large.





rlut PCor-AC,
see also lwcftoa, tas, TMQ
swcftoa PCor-AM,
see also ALBDS
lwcftoa PCor-AM,
lwcftoa PCor-AC,
pr PCor-AM,
pr PCor-AC,
hfls PCor-AC,
ep PCor-AM,
ep PCor-AC,
zg500 PCor-AM,
zg500 PCor-AC,
hur925 PCor-AM,
wap500 PCor-AM,
wap500 PCor-AC,
hur500 PCor-AM,
hur500 PCor-AC,
hur500 PCor-ENSO,
inmcm3_0
0.59: 0.59; 0.55; 0.63
N/A; N/A; N/A
ncar_ccsm3_0CMIP3 NHM-SHM rsnt too small.
see also swcftoa, ALBDS
OM-LM rsnt too large.
see also swcftoa, ALBDS
Global Mean rlut too small.
see also lwcftoa, tas, TMQ
NHM-SHM rlut too small.
see also lwcftoa, tas, TMQ
OM-LM rlut too large.
see also lwcftoa, tas, TMQ


hur925 PCor-AC,



rsnt PCor-ENSO,
see also swcftoa, ALBDS
rlut PCor-AM,
see also lwcftoa, tas, TMQ
rlut PCor-ENSO,
see also lwcftoa, tas, TMQ
swcftoa PCor-ENSO,
see also ALBDS
lwcftoa PCor-AM,
lwcftoa PCor-AC,
lwcftoa PCor-ENSO,
fs PCor-AM,
pr PCor-AM,
pr PCor-AC,
pr PCor-ENSO,
ep PCor-AM,
ep PCor-AC,
ep PCor-ENSO,
rtfs PCor-AC,
rtfs PCor-ENSO,
zg500 PCor-ENSO,
hur925 PCor-ENSO,
wap500 PCor-AM,
wap500 PCor-AC,
psl PCor-ENSO,
hur500 PCor-AM,
hur500 PCor-AC,
hur500 PCor-ENSO,
giss_model_e_r
0.59: 0.70; 0.53; 0.53
A; A; N/A
ncar_ccsm3_0CMIP3 Global Mean rsnt too small.
see also swcftoa, ALBDS
NHM-SHM rsnt too small.
see also swcftoa, ALBDS
OM-LM rsnt too large.
see also swcftoa, ALBDS
NHM-SHM rlut too small.
see also lwcftoa, tas, TMQ
OM-LM swcftoa too large.
see also ALBDS
NHM-SHM hfls too small.





rlut PCor-ENSO,
see also lwcftoa, tas, TMQ
swcftoa PCor-AM,
see also ALBDS
swcftoa PCor-AC,
see also ALBDS
swcftoa PCor-ENSO,
see also ALBDS
lwcftoa PCor-AM,
lwcftoa PCor-AC,
lwcftoa PCor-ENSO,
hfls PCor-AC,
hfls PCor-ENSO,
ep PCor-AM,
ep PCor-AC,
zg500 PCor-AM,
zg500 PCor-AC,
zg500 PCor-ENSO,
hur925 PCor-ENSO,
wap500 PCor-AM,
wap500 PCor-AC,
wap500 PCor-ENSO,
psl PCor-AM,
psl PCor-ENSO,
hur500 PCor-AM,
hur500 PCor-AC,
hur500 PCor-ENSO,
giss_model_e_h
0.44: 0.57; 0.49; 0.27
N/A; N/A; N/A
ncar_ccsm3_0CMIP3 NHM-SHM rsnt too small.
see also swcftoa, ALBDS
OM-LM rsnt too large.
see also swcftoa, ALBDS
NHM-SHM rlut too small.
see also lwcftoa, tas, TMQ
OM-LM swcftoa too large.
see also ALBDS
NHM-SHM hfls too small.





rsnt PCor-ENSO,
see also swcftoa, ALBDS
rlut PCor-ENSO,
see also lwcftoa, tas, TMQ
swcftoa PCor-AM,
see also ALBDS
swcftoa PCor-ENSO,
see also ALBDS
lwcftoa PCor-AM,
lwcftoa PCor-AC,
lwcftoa PCor-ENSO,
pr PCor-AM,
pr PCor-AC,
pr PCor-ENSO,
hfls PCor-AC,
ep PCor-AM,
ep PCor-AC,
ep PCor-ENSO,
zg500 PCor-AM,
zg500 PCor-AC,
zg500 PCor-ENSO,
hur925 PCor-ENSO,
wap500 PCor-AM,
wap500 PCor-AC,
wap500 PCor-ENSO,
psl PCor-AM,
psl PCor-ENSO,
hur500 PCor-AM,
hur500 PCor-AC,
hur500 PCor-ENSO,